Graeter's Ice Cream is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

1. Graeter's Ice Cream

9.2
2136 Bethel Rd (Pickforde Dr), Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 24 tips and reviews

Nick A.Nick Albright: try the Toffee Chip! :)

SURESHKUMARAN E.SURESHKUMARAN EASWARAN: Believe it or not!Each and every flavor has its own lingering taste.Service is too good, they give you a scoop of each flavor to taste patiently.Chocolate Chip topped wit butter scotch was jus amazing

CameronCameron: Buckeye Blitz is AMAZING

Krema Nut Company is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

2. Krema Nut Company

8.5
1000 Goodale Blvd, Columbus, OH
Food and Beverage Retail · 13 tips and reviews

NathanNathan: Best peanut butter ever! Try the butter toffee peanuts!

Paul H.Paul Haggard: This place is so great. You can grab a homemade PB&J or get your favorite nuts, snacks or sweets. A gem in Columbus.

Robbie B.Robbie Brickner: get a bag of Buckeye Crunch!!

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

3. Cold Stone Creamery

7.8
101 Mill St, Ste 108, Gahanna, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews

Mark S.Mark Salerno: Fudge truffle with brownies (left) was AMAZING! Strawberry w/ whipped cream (right) light and fluffy

REGINALD W.REGINALD WILLIAMS: Be prepared to b fat

Tiffany C.Tiffany Cox: Fresh mixed ice cream. Amazing taste and experience

Sidebar is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

4. Sidebar

8.3
122 E Main St (at S Lazelle St), Columbus, OH
Cocktail Bar · 32 tips and reviews

Jessica H.Jessica Hercule: My new favorite place - the food is to die for, service is stellar, and every drink I've had is amazing.

Wendy B.Wendy B: Amazing cocktails and delicious food! Bacon strips for bar snacks...genius!!!!

Kehinde M.Kehinde M.: The appetizers and drinks are outstanding!

Starbucks is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

5. Starbucks

8.0
1782 N High St, Columbus, OH
Coffee Shop · 28 tips and reviews

Cheyenne C.Cheyenne Clark: Most amazing baristas. Good place to study and hang out obviously. But seriously I love every single barista <3

Dylan K.Dylan Karel: Sign up for the rewards program, if you're going to spend money here anyway, you may as well get a freebie every so often. Also: free soy, coffee/tea refills, and syrups at the gold level!

Dylan H.Dylan Henrich: Great & friendly service! During the school year, it can get really busy between classes & around lunch.

Final Cut Steak & Seafood is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

6. Final Cut Steak & Seafood

7.2
Hollywood Casino Columbus, Columbus, OH
Steakhouse · 6 tips and reviews

Brian W.Brian Waggle: Great cuisine! I had the NY STRIP and it was wonderful. My wife and my staff ate from the price fix menu and there was ALOT of food of high quality. We'll be back. Service was superb; great job!

Kurt J.Kurt Jeffers: Awesome Casino. Just wish I won more.

Betsy S.Betsy Sharp: Not impressed. I really expected more out of a "Forbes four star" restaurant. Filet was charred so long in the broiler that it was extremely tough. Boo!

Starbucks is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

7. Starbucks

7.6
339 N Front St, Columbus, OH
Coffee Shop · 29 tips and reviews

Wes C.Wes Crow: Easily the best Starbucks I've visited. Friendly, efficient, knowledgeable staff.

Jonathan P.Jonathan Poma: Absolutely the best, friendliest staff I've ever seen at a Starbucks.

Greg T. M.Greg T. Moss: The best Starbucks team in town.

Polaris Fashion Place is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

8. Polaris Fashion Place

8.2
1500 Polaris Pkwy (Lyra Dr), Columbus, OH
Shopping Mall · 67 tips and reviews

Presley B.Presley Burley: This indoor mall features over 190 dining, entertainment and retail options! Upscale dining, or quick bites from the food court. Kid's entertainment & activities and shopping galore!

Amanda V.Amanda Vogt: I love this mall! It's one of my favorites! And a little known fact? The mall is so big that if you walk around the mall twice you will have walked a mile!

ErinErin: Watch out for the "natural nails" sales stand on the first floor. Those European sales guys will chase you down and try to touch you even if you're practically running away.

Short North Pint House is one of The 9 Best Places for Toffee in Columbus.

9. Short North Pint House

7.8
780 N High St (Warren St. & Hull Alley), Columbus, OH
Beer Garden · 40 tips and reviews

Matthew B.Matthew Bryson: Really cool concept! Beer waterfalls, and the bar has an ice track to keep your beer cold. Definitely a place to get good pints for only $6!

Jason M.Jason McLaughlin: A line to get in? Where's the line to get OUT!!???

KlyKly: Bring your kid. In a stroller. You won't be the only one,... #parentfail