bd's Mongolian Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

1. bd's Mongolian Grill

8.7
6242 Sawmill Rd (at Martin Rd), Dublin, OH
Asian Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Dave L.Dave Luckett: Try the sea salt vanilla ice cream with cocaine sprinkles!

Courtney H.Courtney Hess: Favorite dish! NY Strip, chicken, broccoli, with the BD's bbq sauce and add the brown rice! Great tasting and healthy too!

sade l.sade locke: BRING YO FAT PANTS

Dairy Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

2. Dairy Queen

7.7
364 Granville St (at S. Hamilton Rd.), Gahanna, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 6 tips and reviews

Brent D.Brent Dickman: Mud Pie isn't on the standard menu but you can still order it! Vanilla Ice Cream, Fudge, Oreo cookie, and coffee, nothing less than Amazing!!

John F.John Fornshell: Vanilla ice cream. They even had dog treats for my dog.:-)

Shujin C.Shujin Cell: The largest Extra Large arctic rush I've ever had! ! Great!

The Brown Bag Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

3. The Brown Bag Deli

9.3
898 Mohawk St (at Whittier), Columbus, OH
Deli · 37 tips and reviews

Aimee D.Aimee DeLuca: Try the Ugandan vanilla bean ice cream by jeni's! So good.

Danny D.Danny D: The best deli on the southside of cbus. I can't get enough of the fresh ingredients, and the fresh salad case! Always something new to try.

Joey M.Joey Murphy: Take your ex-wifes sister here. She will love the tuna melt.

Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

4. Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse

8.6
89 E Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH
Steakhouse · 5 tips and reviews

Adam M.Adam Mason: Steak. Fries. The bar. What more do you need?

Sew D.Sew Dee: Impecable service. Dry aged steak was phenomenal, Almost as good as Quality Meats NYC. Mushrooms were out of this world.

Rob P.Rob Perkins: Bread, steak, salad, crab cakes

Krema Nut Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

5. Krema Nut Company

8.5
1000 Goodale Blvd, Columbus, OH
Food and Beverage Retail · 13 tips and reviews

Paul H.Paul Haggard: This place is so great. You can grab a homemade PB&J or get your favorite nuts, snacks or sweets. A gem in Columbus.

Robbie B.Robbie Brickner: get a bag of Buckeye Crunch!!

NathanNathan: Best peanut butter ever! Try the butter toffee peanuts!

Rockmill Tavern is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

6. Rockmill Tavern

8.2
515 South Front St (W. Livingston Ave.), Columbus, OH
Brewery · 6 tips and reviews

jireselljiresell: The beer and food are delicious. The kitchen can be a bit unorganized.

Meredith M.Meredith Miles: Make sure you ask staff to recommend a beer pairing for any one of the delicious menu items - you won't be disappointed!

Andrew S.Andrew Schulak: Tavern burger

Local Cantina is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

7. Local Cantina

8.3
1423 Grandview Ave (in Grandview Center), Columbus, OH
Mexican Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

DanDan: Love that they have self serve chips and salsa. I had fish, buffalo chicken, and chorizo egg tacos and house margaritas. All fantastic. Waiting for a table when this place can be awkward. No hostess.

Sarah K.Sarah Keller: Can't miss the fish tacos! Awesome!

Kathryn S.Kathryn Sanders Smith: Ask for a Moscow mule! Grey goose with gosling ginger beer and lime over ice. Pairs beautifully with spicy veggie tacos ,) enjoy!

The Hickory House is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

8. The Hickory House

8.5
7051 E Main St (Rosehill Road), Reynoldsburg, OH
BBQ Joint · 12 tips and reviews

Hunter Y.Hunter Young: Filet and Ribs. All-time best.

Tony B.Tony Burkhart: The ribs and burgers are amazing!

Samantha H.Samantha Herbert: The ribs and the grilled shrimp are absolutely wonderful

Wine on High is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

9. Wine on High

8.0
789 N High St, Columbus, OH
Wine Bar · 6 tips and reviews

jireselljiresell: Nice shop. Intimate, but staff is very helpful.

Jan H.Jan Humphries: New pizza menu by Hubbard Grill.

Brian W.Brian Whitaker: 3rd Tuesday is taste 20 wines for $20. One of my favorite things

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

10. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

9.0
4247 N High St, Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 37 tips and reviews

Matt D.Matt Dermody: This is The Only Ice Cream. All Time Greatest. Sample as many flavors as you want first. You can't go wrong.

Kate R.Kate Rhoades: Shut up and eat the ice cream.

Paul M.Paul Mackenzie Ross: Not from round here? Then it would be rude not to get a "Buckeye State" ;-)

Cameron's American Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

11. Cameron's American Bistro

8.4
2185 W Dublin Granville Rd, Worthington, OH
American Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

FourStarrFourStarr: ask for the captain's list if you're a wine drinker. the muscovy duck was dwarfed by the copious amounts of rice on the plate. our server was attentive but a bit too aggressive in demeanor.

ElizabethElizabeth: Not open until 5pm during the week

Brooke S.Brooke Stull: Best calamari ever!!!

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

12. Cold Stone Creamery

7.8
101 Mill St, Ste 108, Gahanna, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews

Mark S.Mark Salerno: Fudge truffle with brownies (left) was AMAZING! Strawberry w/ whipped cream (right) light and fluffy

REGINALD W.REGINALD WILLIAMS: Be prepared to b fat

Tiffany C.Tiffany Cox: Fresh mixed ice cream. Amazing taste and experience

Sonic Drive-In is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

13. Sonic Drive-In

8.1
1031 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH
Fast Food Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

NicolieNicolie: Winter time: get the Spiced Sugar Cookie Blast <3

Mickey H.Mickey Hawk: Get the tots--not fries.

Lizzy Leigh .Lizzy Leigh 🐈: The new, fresh brewed iced teas are relish!

The Mad Greek is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

14. The Mad Greek

8.3
4210 E Broad St (btwn Beechwood & Pinewood Dr), Columbus, OH
Greek Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Samuel C.Samuel Camacho: This place is a gem!! Gyro meat is delicious and plentiful in both sandwich and platter forms. It's lentil soup is bold and rich with flavor. Don't forget to try one of several desserts made in house

Tom O.Tom Ohmer: Having a gyro, but waited a while for a server. No, this place is not busy now.

Aaron B.Aaron Butts: Best gyro I have ever had in my life. I would die for their garlic sauce.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is one of The 15 Best Places for Vanilla Ice Cream in Columbus.

15. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

8.8
1281 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 48 tips and reviews

Dana D.Dana D: If you like your tastebuds to tingle with delectable combinations of flavor, Jeni's is a must stop for subtle nuances of seasonal flavor to double-take pairings you'll delight in. Ice cream heaven.

LeahLeah: Try the Riesling Poached Pear! It's fantastic.

Austin S.Austin Schafer: You got to try the Brown Butter Almond Brittle.