Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

1. Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

8.3
304 Owen Dr, Fayetteville, NC
Sandwich Spot · 5 tips and reviews

Donald W.Donald Warren: Excellent sub sandwiches! A foot-long is usually enough for two people to share! Fresh toppings, too!

Ya'akov K.Ya'akov Ki: Italian Extra Special!

Demetria D.Demetria Dixon: The steak and cheese salads are my favorite!

New Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

2. New Deli

8.8
2153 Valleygate Dr #1, Fayetteville, NC
Sandwich Spot · 18 tips and reviews

Sean H.Sean Hayes: The Dessert Apple are amazing! I love the cheesecake apple!

Esther L.Esther Lian: Love it here! I come after lunch to have it all to myself. Chicken salad like no other. And the reeses apple

Jennifer R.Jennifer Ray: If your looking for true deli not frozen ezperience, try Panera Bread but be prepared its crazy expensive. New Deli did have one redeeming factor.. chocolate covered strawberries.

Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

3. Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

7.8
102 S Eastern Blvd, Fayetteville, NC
Sandwich Spot · Downtown Fayetteville · 1 tip

Nathan M.Nathan Maxwell: Check out the free WiFi while you're here!

Pizza Palace is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

4. Pizza Palace

7.7
109 Hope Mills Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Pizzeria · 5 tips and reviews

Victor S.Victor Stills: The food is just good here and their salads are wonderful and great service also

Celeste H.Celeste Hope: The thick crust pizza is awesome! YUM! the service was super friendly! House salad was ok. Garlic bread was pretty good. I wish I had discovered this place while I still lived in Hope Mills!

Dwayne S.Dwayne Smith: Best spaghetti in town. There salad dressings are made from scratch.

Fazoli's is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

5. Fazoli's

7.7
538 N McPherson Church Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

John C.John Cook: Baked spaghetti is awesome! One of my favorites.

Paige R.Paige R: Tuesdays = $.99 Kids Meals with purchase of 1 entree ~ NO age limit ~ with unlimited breadsticks & drink included with kids meal, our family of 5 adult appetites can eat for under $10!

Jason B.Jason Baker: Great food. Great price.

Mellow Mushroom is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

6. Mellow Mushroom

8.4
301 N McPherson Church Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Pizzeria · 49 tips and reviews

Jason Y.Jason Yap: Ask for the Steak & Stout. It's not on the menu but they always have it and its amazing

AmyAmy: Awesome place. Especially if you've got that one picky person with you. Made to order, delicious, and everyone is chill & super nice.

Josh W.Josh Winburn: The tv's at the bar are a pain to watch

Jersey Mike's Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

7. Jersey Mike's Subs

7.6
4225-B Ramsey Street, Fayetteville, NC
Sandwich Spot · 5 tips and reviews

John R.John R: You can't go wrong with a Jersey Mike Sub. Always fresh. Have it Mike's way

Ya'akov K.Ya'akov Ki: Best sandwich shop in town!!!

Evette T.Evette Thompson: Loving the stake and cheese sub from Jerseys Mike's and the combo is off the chain.Freshness each time I go:-)

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

8. Starbucks

7.5
2800 Raeford Rd (inside Harris Teeter), Fayetteville, NC
Coffee Shop · 7 tips and reviews

Tony O.Tony O: Love the fast service and the convenience

primpinainteazyprimpinainteazy: Caramel Brulée Latte

Ya'akov K.Ya'akov Ki: It’s Starbucks! Enough said!!!!

Rudino's Pizza and Grinders is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

9. Rudino's Pizza and Grinders

7.5
5075 Morganton Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Pizzeria · 5 tips and reviews

Jeremiah J.Jeremiah Johnson: Best cheesesticks in the 'Nam. And the chicken parm pizza is one of the top five available in the city.

Ray T.Ray Towe: Love their pizza

Sarah F.Sarah F: The BEST meatball grinder i have ever had!

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

10. Starbucks

8.3
1445 Walter Reed Road (at All American Exwy), Fayetteville, NC
Coffee Shop · 49 tips and reviews

Izzy K.Izzy King: amazing, I definitely recommend the double chocolate chip frapp❤️❤️

A.M. L.A.M. LaVey: It's the better of the two in Fayetteville.

Truds B.Truds Bryan-Urso: My fav Starbucks by far!

Mash House Chophouse & Brewery is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

11. Mash House Chophouse & Brewery

8.2
4150 Sycamore Dairy Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Brewery · 55 tips and reviews

Dave G.Dave Gehringer: Fried green tomatoes ate excellent. Try the peach cheesecake. It's amazing

GinaGina: Best IPA ever.

Michael L.Michael Larkin: This is my favorite restaurant in Fayetteville. Try the IPA and the bruschetta.

Zorba's Gyro is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

12. Zorba's Gyro

7.6
2919 Raeford Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Greek Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Thomas P.Thomas Pope: The Friday special - lasagna, salad & bread - is excellent.

Jeremy A.Jeremy Adams: Best breakfast in town.

AshMcDashAshMcDash: Best Gyro & spaghetti in town!

Subway is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

13. Subway

7.3
6900 Cliffdale Rd (Reilly Rd), Fayetteville, NC
Sandwich Spot · No tips or reviews
Joe's Crab Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

14. Joe's Crab Shack

7.8
155 Mcpherson Church Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Seafood Restaurant · 33 tips and reviews

Parker D.Parker Dunahay: The strawberry Rita is hitting the spot and my favorite dinner is the third coast platter!

Andrew B.Andrew Buser: The steam pots are awesome!!

Ry H.Ry Halliday: Gotta order a steampot!

Schlotzsky's is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Fayetteville.

15. Schlotzsky's

7.4
131 N McPherson Church Rd, Fayetteville, NC
Deli · 13 tips and reviews

Becky R.Becky Roberson: The Sourdough bread is wonderful

Lo-Cell E.Lo-Cell Ervin: My original was hot and fresh. They seemed to have slacked on the meat and olives. The Schlotzskys back in the day in Austin was the bomb. They don't make them like they use to. But still good.

Wendy D.Wendy Doubles: Jalapeno Bread!