Sottocasa Pizzeria is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

1. Sottocasa Pizzeria

9.5
227 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Central Harlem · 45 tips and reviews

KonstantinKonstantin: Delicious Neapolitan Pizza. Very friendly and welcoming staff. Service is great. Wonderful place for families.

S M.S M: My favorite pizza in NYC (and I eat a lot of pizza in NYC). Try the Brussels sprouts and speck with a sparkly glass of champagne - you can't go wrong! Owners are wonderful, sweet and accommodating.

Milan P.Milan Petrovic: Warm, Italian atmosphere. Owners are doing great job with the real Italian style pizza, and great espresso caffe. Pizza Regginela is on the level of the best pizza places in Napoli! Bravo!

babbalucci is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

2. babbalucci

8.7
331 Malcolm X Blvd (127th Street), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Central Harlem · 33 tips and reviews

Zayed K.Zayed Khan: The St Nic is terrific. Near perfect thin crust, and very high quality toppings.

Evan H.Evan Harms: Risotto croquettes, honey pizza and eggplant parm was a great combo for our group of 4. Great beer and wine too!

NicoleNicole: Attentive service at a dim, low-key spot for dinner. Excellent pizzas and pastas with fresh, seasonal ingredients. I want to try everything on the menu! Ask for wine recommendations and order a pizza.

Harlem Pizza Co. is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

3. Harlem Pizza Co.

7.4
135 W 116th St, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Central Harlem · 18 tips and reviews

Mil4n S.Mil4n S: If you are into thin crust pizza this is the place!! specials worth trying!

Victor A.Victor Almonte Martinez: Excellent place and excellent pizza

Jason C.Jason Camilleri: Best pizza in Manhattan bar none

Pizza Stop is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

4. Pizza Stop

7.5
531 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Central Harlem · 9 tips and reviews

Margie B.Margie Braxton: Philly Cheese Steak Pizza FTW !

Joi-MarieJoi-Marie: Try the lasagna pizza! Always a winner :)

Jarrel E.Jarrel Ellison: Best pizza in Harlem!

Best Market is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

5. Best Market

7.4
2187 Frederick Douglass Blvd (btwn 118th & 119th St), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Central Harlem · 103 tips and reviews

Joanna P.Joanna Pena-Bickley: Good Fresh Pizza. Great produce selection

Kari-Ann W.Kari-Ann W: Like the pizza from the bakery.

Kai'Cee H.Kai'Cee H.: Don't live in the area. I'm a vendor for them. The pizza smells really good. May try one day.

Whole Foods Market is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

6. Whole Foods Market

8.0
100 W 125th St. (at Lenox Ave), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Central Harlem · 16 tips and reviews

Evelyn A.Evelyn Arana: Pizza is delicious!

NiaNia: Try the Beyond Burger- no SOY, all vegan "bleeding Burger"!

Harlem A.Harlem Ambassador: Construction is about completed on what is sure to be the smallest, yet most over speculated Whole Foods to date. The real estate vultures have already used it as justification to overcharge on rent!

Mama's Fried Chicken is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

7. Mama's Fried Chicken

7.6
2158 Frederick Douglass Blvd (116th st), New York, NY
Fried Chicken Joint · Central Harlem · 4 tips and reviews

Pennylane Y.Pennylane Yilmaz: The pizza is surprisingly really delicious

Nick T.Nick Tyrell: If you're drunk as hell and you're walking home, stop in and get a spicy chicken from L

Lincoln H.Lincoln Hayes: Spicy chicken sandwich is delicious

Olive Garden is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

8. Olive Garden

7.5
100 W 125th St, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Central Harlem · 1 tip

SebastianSebastian: Too much cheese.

Lido Harlem is one of The 9 Best Places for Pizza in Central Harlem, New York.

9. Lido Harlem

8.5
2168 Frederick Douglass Blvd (at W 117th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Central Harlem · 134 tips and reviews

HectorHector: Good for dates. Enjoy some wine and delicious Italian dishes in this cozy restaurant. Definitely make a reservation.

__TR3V__TR3V: Get there before 1pm to beat the church crowd for Sunday brunch. The French toast and the chicken panini are great options to try. Opt for the bottomless mimosas. Well worth it

Harlem A.Harlem Ambassador: Finally an eatery that gives good service, good wine, good food and good face. This is one good looking staff. Check out their gay night for the hipster folk with cash.