Sweet Carolina Cupcakes is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

1. Sweet Carolina Cupcakes

8.7
Coligny Plaza Shopping Center (1 N. Forest Beach Drive, Unit 203), Hilton Head Island, SC
Cupcake Shop · 19 tips and reviews

Christian S.Christian Sloan: Just had the chocolate chip cheesecake and one of the best cupcakes ever! Just be sure to get some milk with it.

Cupcake CrusadersCupcake Crusaders: We've been told from a Guest Crusader that the Carrot Cake is great!

Tiffany B.Tiffany B: We loved the wedding cake cupcake! Key lime didn't taste any different than vanilla.

Sage Room is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

2. Sage Room

8.6
81 Pope Ave Ste 13, Hilton Head Island, SC
Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

CindyCindy: Mario's Turtle Cheesecake is the best in town

John B.John Belen: Try the Champagne Poached Scallops - Champagne Poached Scallops over sautéed spinach and Parmesan risotto cake.... And fricken AWESOME!!!

Jonathan A.Jonathan Andersen: Lamb chops, squash soup, halibot, steaks, blue cheese scalloped potatoes - you can't go wrong!

Hilton Head Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

3. Hilton Head Ice Cream

9.0
55 New Orleans Rd Ste 114, Hilton Head Island, SC
Ice Cream Parlor · 26 tips and reviews

Ryan S.Ryan Stoner: Awesome red velvet cake. Amazing

John B.John Brandt: Delicious ice cream. Try the Oreo or brownie cheesecake!

Taylor R.Taylor Reis: The coconut ice cream, butter pecan, and peanut butter cup are delicious!!

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

4. Starbucks

8.7
416 Hwy 278 William Hilton Parkway, Hilton Head Island, SC
Coffee Shop · 20 tips and reviews

First L.First Last: The frappes are amazing and the coffee cakes are delicious

Alison G.Alison G.: By far the nicest baristas in the lowcountry!

Angelique M.Angelique M.: Very friendly drive thru staff!

Trattoria Divina is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

5. Trattoria Divina

8.1
33 Office Park Rd Ste 224, Hilton Head Island, SC
Italian Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

MichaelMichael: Loved the mushroom ravioli and the scallops special with angel hair and shrimp. Also loved the molten lava cake for dessert!

Paige R.Paige Romanowski, CPT: Amazing food! Paige was an excellent server. Great evening! Tiramisu is worth it.

MalJNewMalJNew: Absolutely amazing! The seafood pasta with scallops lobster and the fresh tomato noodles was mind blowing. Get the sorbets in the ice sculpture!

Publix is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

6. Publix

8.4
45 Pembroke Dr (off Wm Hilton Parkway), Hilton Head Island, SC
Grocery Store · 9 tips and reviews

Robert S.Robert Sedgwick: Best Birthday Cakes, for that matter, best cakes in the country!

Firehouse Z.Firehouse Zen: The closest thing to a genuine italian #hoagie in the South. They make their own rolls, which are the same texture and taste as Amaroso's. #food

EM H.EM H'van: Friendly service and they have it all

Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

7. Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana

8.8
37 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

G T.G T: Amazing place. Love it all. Get the molten lava cake.

Chris K.Chris Katon: Try the Braised Pork Belly - served with truffle bean purée, fried leaks and pork jus $11

Chris K.Chris Katon: Visit the Market! Open 10 - 4 / Mon - Sat. Featuring authentic meats, cheeses, homemade sauces + specialty items!

Salty Dog Cafe-Waterside Deck is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

8. Salty Dog Cafe-Waterside Deck

8.0
Hilton Head Island, SC
Bar · 11 tips and reviews

Shellie Y.Shellie Yale: The brownie cheesecake is to die for!!!!

Justin G.Justin Grant: Best shrimp on the island!

Jared R.Jared Rauh: Popular and busy with tourists. It’s a fun atmosphere with live music, shops, food and ice cream!

The Purple Cow is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

9. The Purple Cow

7.7
24 Palmetto Bay Rd Ste G, Hilton Head Island, SC
Dessert Shop · 3 tips and reviews

John F.John Fails: Incredible cheesecake, great coffee shop like atmosphere, and Bernie the owner is awesome.

Kim D.Kim Dearsley: The best baked donuts. And sweet treats

Sue R.Sue R: Very cute place... Nice service... Yummy deserts

Wiseguys is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

10. Wiseguys

8.3
1513 Main St (at I-278), Hilton Head Island, SC
Lounge · 42 tips and reviews

Karen B.Karen Bigos: For four people, try the chocolate fonduefpr dessert. Fun go dip bananas, pound cake, strawberries and cinnamon sticks.

Steve S.Steve Sinicropi: The food is killer. Go with the small plates and be sure to try the chicken and waffles. Everything is good. Great gluten free selections.

Chris S.Chris Spargur: Ask for Chef Russels Liquid Olives

Watusi Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

11. Watusi Cafe

8.3
71 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC
Coffee Shop · 30 tips and reviews

Derek S.Derek Showerman: Cheesecake yogurt is the way start! Then load up!!!

Joe D.Joe Dejulio: The beat lunch on the Island. Daily specials are reasonably priced. Yogurt and coffee drinks are great also.

Chris M.Chris McKinney: The Big Watusi Sandwich is great! Bacon and sausage! Best coffee on the island!

Street Meet is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

12. Street Meet

8.3
95 Mathews Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
Pub · 35 tips and reviews

Gerry P.Gerry Petet: Great atmosphere, incredibly unique food, insanely delicious desserts!!! Fried strawberry cheesecake, wow!!

ᴡ B.ᴡ Boatright: The cuban is outstanding, as are the fries. The 'pulled pork nachos' are a must try.

Ben W.Ben Wardlaw: You will enjoy the great food and friendly service at Street Meet.

Cups & Cones is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

13. Cups & Cones

7.2
149 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Ice Cream Parlor · 6 tips and reviews

Haven K.Haven Koehler: Birthday cake :) yum!!!

Danny Y.Danny Young: Oddly enough, this may be the best ice cream in the island.

LadymayLadymay: Yummy ice cream and sorbet.

Charlie’s l’Etoile Vert is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

14. Charlie’s l’Etoile Vert

8.7
Orleans Rd., Hilton Head Island, SC
French Restaurant · 12 tips and reviews

Jordan V.Jordan Valimont-Bobo: The filet migon with the mild cheese sauce is the best steak I've ever had in my life- and I've been around the world (literally)!

Nick O.Nick Ober: If it's being offered, the Trigger Fish is always a great call!

AlaynaAlayna: Try the veal. It's exceptional

The Crazy Crab is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Hilton Head.

15. The Crazy Crab

7.6
149 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 100 tips and reviews

Alicia K.Alicia Kate: Stuffed flounder and pumpkin cheesecake highly recommended!!!

Kathryn N.Kathryn Neidhardt: Best fried shrimp I've had - anywhere. Keep coming back for over 15 years.

Amy C.Amy Coulter: Don't fill up on the amazing hush puppies before your meal comes out like I did. 😊