Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

1. Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana

8.8
37 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Chris K.Chris Katon: Visit the Market! Open 10 - 4 / Mon - Sat. Featuring authentic meats, cheeses, homemade sauces + specialty items!

Sharon C.Sharon Cook: Love the ribbon pasta with the Homemade bolognese sauce.

G T.G T: Amazing place. Love it all. Get the molten lava cake.

Pomodori is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

2. Pomodori

8.9
1 New Orleans Rd Ste G, Hilton Head Island, SC
Italian Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Blanche T. S.Blanche T. Sullivan: Amanda's homemade gnocchi are amazing, especially with bolognese!

Debbie S.Debbie Stesney Janoski: This place is absolutely amazing. Been here twice now and it is the best homemade Italian food I have ever eaten out! And I married into an Italian family are amazing cooks!

John B.John Belen: Both the zucchini and the calamari appetizers are out of this world!!

Fat Baby's Pizza And Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

3. Fat Baby's Pizza And Subs

8.3
120 Arrow Ro. Suite B (Target Rd.), Hilton Head Island, SC
Pizzeria · 36 tips and reviews

Fat Baby's P.Fat Baby's Pizza&Subs: Try our homemade lasagna every Thursday! Read more.

Thomas L.Thomas Love: Ask for the "Hots". Homemade red pepper sauce. Freaking amazing.

Carlos V.Carlos Vargas: Our first time here, they do have the best pizza on the island, the Greek pizza was really, really good.

Southern Coney & Breakfast is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

4. Southern Coney & Breakfast

8.5
70 Pope Ave Ste J, Hilton Head Island, SC
Breakfast Spot · 21 tips and reviews

Jim F.Jim Forte: Yummy homemade corned beef hash

Lauren N.Lauren Nolan: Try the shecrab soup if it's available...amazing! Also, really great workers and owners!

Graham B.Graham Bowers: Southern coney has the BEST pancakes

Hilton Head Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

5. Hilton Head Ice Cream

8.9
55 New Orleans Rd Ste 114, Hilton Head Island, SC
Ice Cream Parlor · 26 tips and reviews

Elliott P.Elliott Plack: All the ice cream 🍦 is homemade! Try the heath bar.

Mike B.Mike Brewer: The ice cream is really good. Other tipsters are right that it's costly. $17 for 3 kids and a small. But, it's worth it, the ice cream is made in house and tastes great.

R L.R Levy: The Cookie Monster was the bomb!!! ...best part was the free topping bar w/ purchase of ice cream! Yaaaa!!! 💕💕💕💕

The French Kiss Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

6. The French Kiss Bakery

8.0
1 N Forest Beach Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
Bakery · 11 tips and reviews

AmberAmber: Homemade yumminess. Real French pastries.

Claire-Louise M.Claire-Louise McIntyre: Amazing baguette. Lovely friendly staff.

Addie M.Addie Marin: Try the strawberry cream cheese anything

Stu's Surfside Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

7. Stu's Surfside Subs

8.1
1 N Forest Beach, Hilton Head Island, SC
Sandwich Spot · 20 tips and reviews

Matt C.Matt Compton: Homemade bread is the best. Super nice service too!

Trisha T.Trisha Thommi: Best sub I have had in awhile! I got the islander #17. All of them are fresh & good as well! Definitely come eat here, it's worth it!

Janet C.Janet Cully: Amazing fresh baked bread! I love #14 - "The Local"

Truffles Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

8. Truffles Cafe

8.3
71 Lighthouse Rd Unit 411, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

PatrickPatrick: the homemade black bean burger is BEAST!

Justin G.Justin Grant: New favorite restaurant on the island! EVERYTHING WAS GREAT! THE RIBS ARE FIRE!!!

Mary D.Mary Darcy: Get the Blondie! It is the most amazing food you will ever put in your mouth!

Street Meet is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

9. Street Meet

8.4
95 Mathews Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
Pub · 35 tips and reviews

Rick M.Rick Mclemore: This is the best hotdogs on the island by far.. here's another tip order chili on the side with jalapeno peppers and put them on your homemade chips ..

ᴡ B.ᴡ Boatright: The cuban is outstanding, as are the fries. The 'pulled pork nachos' are a must try.

Ben W.Ben Wardlaw: You will enjoy the great food and friendly service at Street Meet.

Palmetto Bay Sunrise Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

10. Palmetto Bay Sunrise Cafe

9.0
302 Helmsman Way, Hilton Head Island, SC
Breakfast Spot · 64 tips and reviews

AbbeyAbbey: homemade eggs benedict, also try the banana rum pancakes! always good food

Deepak P.Deepak Padmanabhan: Try the shrimp hash, quiche and French toast!

Alisa S.Alisa Sweeney: Food is AMAZING! Everyone's friendly. Eggs benedict and quiche were delicious.

A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

11. A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant

8.5
32 Palmetto Bay Rd Ste A4, Hilton Head Island, SC
Southern Food Restaurant · 89 tips and reviews

Kalea E.Kalea Eileen: Order the crab cake benedict with homemade biscuits. Prices are great and you’ll get the feeling you are in your own low country backyard.

Daron D.Daron Davis: The Shrimp and Grits are awesome! The Crab Cakes are fantastic!

Rj W.Rj Wilkie: What a fabulous place, great food,great service,cozy atmosphere.A MUST, Suggest the Meatloaf Sandwhich.

It's Greek To Me II is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

12. It's Greek To Me II

8.1
11 Lagoon Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Greek Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Kathy G.Kathy Gaudette: I have to be iodine free, gluten free & dairy free. So far so good. It was pretty easy to order... We'll see

Tess G.Tess Goldberger: Best Greek I have had outside of Greece. Grilled octopus is amazing. They do come in chunks though just a heads up. We have been going here for over 15 years. Always a favorite. Try the rice pudding

Matthew R.Matthew Rogers: Opa!

Earl of Sandwich Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

13. Earl of Sandwich Pub

7.2
1 N Forest Beach Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
Burger Joint · 12 tips and reviews

BrandyBrandy: Great food, big sandwiches and yummy pasta salad. Homemade chips!!

Carla O.Carla Olson: Had the Turkey Pilgrim sandwich with homemade chips. Good size portions and tasted delicious.

Ivy R.Ivy Rowland: Swept the floor burger!!!

The Studio is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

14. The Studio

8.4
20 Executive Park Rd (Wm Hilton Pkwy), Hilton Head Island, SC
New American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Mary M.Mary Mallaney: Sit at the bar and you won't be disappointed. The owners are extremely hospitable, the art is beautiful and the food is delicious! Such a great idea for a restaurant.

Jennifer D.Jennifer Doyle: Amazing restaurant! Not your typical beach fare, not really kid friendly (which is not a bad thing!!). Will definitely come again.

Cheyenne B.Cheyenne Brooks: The best restaurant ON Hilton Head Island! Everything was creatively crafted and delicious.

Ela's Blu Water Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Homemade Food in Hilton Head.

15. Ela's Blu Water Grille

8.8
1 Shelter Cove Ln, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

CindyCindy: Great find! Wonderful location, great view, fabulous food! Well worth the trip, a new island favorite.

Patrick N.Patrick NeSmith: Great food - atmosphere

mrhammrham: The calamari, crab cakes, and grouper are delicious. Very friendly staff. Great environment. Live music. Generally, just a solid place for dinner.