The Salty Dog Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

1. The Salty Dog Cafe

8.1
232 S Sea Pines Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 121 tips and reviews

Sarah G.Sarah Garlick: The crab cake sandwich is the best!

Stacey S.Stacey Schick: Try the shrimp po boy ....super yummy! and you can't beat the atmosphere :)

Chris H.Chris Holdeman: Salt dog combo plate with gumbo and shrimp sandwich is awesome combination

Skull Creek Boathouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

2. Skull Creek Boathouse

8.9
405 Squire Pope Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 158 tips and reviews

Jennifer J M.Jennifer J McDermott-Grubb: Fried pickle chips, fish tacos, fish sandwiches....it's all good!

Clintyn N.Clintyn Newcombe: The dive to beat the rest! A patio like none other, the crab cake sandwich was delicious, great fries and some nice house got sauces! It's worth noting the great games they have, kids will love it!

Tammy S.Tammy Stuck: Great view. Waitstaff loves dogs! Try the fried shrimp!

The Sandbar Beach Eats is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

3. The Sandbar Beach Eats

8.1
85-99 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928, Hilton Head Island, SC
Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Scott P.Scott Parks: Crab cake sandwich and grouper sandwich are delicious

Bryan C.Bryan Crow: Mahi mahi tacos are great as well as the Mexican street corn dip.

MaríaMaría: You can even get away with a healthy and hearty meal here. Loved the seafood salad, although the plantain fritters were not bad either.

Sea Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

4. Sea Shack

8.3
6B Executive Park Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 62 tips and reviews

Angela I.Angela Ice: Crab cake sandwich was delicious!

Zach D.Zach Dietmeier: Crab cakes and shrimp were soooo good. Great sauces too. Would definitely go back.

Amy C.Amy Coats: Bring your puppy and eat outside

Tiki Hut is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

5. Tiki Hut

8.4
1 S Forest Beach Dr., Hilton Head Island, SC
Lounge · 46 tips and reviews

Jess K.Jess Keathley: Get the crab cake sandwich with sweet potato fries! This lunch far exceeded my expectations for a beachside lunch. However, do NOT get the cheeseburger unless you like dry cafeteria-like patties.

Ed P.Ed Paff: Good service and tasty drinks. Live music is a bonus. Great scenery especially at sunset.

Tisha C. H.Tisha C. Hilton Head Island Realtor: What can we say, The Tiki Hut is an island tradition. Great for people watching, live music, cold adult beverages, and beach volleyball. My friend from Australia wants to make it his permanent home.

The Crazy Crab is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

6. The Crazy Crab

7.6
149 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 100 tips and reviews

KateKate: I have had the crabcake sandwich (awesome!) and the blackened grouper sandwich (even more amazing!) but nothing tops their she crab soup! Yum!!!!!!!!!

Shelley G.Shelley Gray: I forgot this amazing soft shell crab sandwich . Its juicy, fried to perfection with a flavorful chipotle mayo that was delicious.

Adam S.Adam Smith: This place has outstanding food! I had the Surf and Turf. It had 3 small filets topped with crab meat and a 6 oz. lobster tail. Amy had deep fried shrimp and she said it was outstanding.

A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

7. A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant

8.8
32 Palmetto Bay Rd Ste A4, Hilton Head Island, SC
Southern Food Restaurant · 89 tips and reviews

Teresa C.Teresa C.: Was so good for lunch (fried green BLT & crabcake sandwich) we came back for dinner...crabcakes & shrimpNgrits. Thank you!

Amanda R.Amanda Roufs: Crab dip and crab cake sandwich are good. The shrimp & grits are by far the best. Definitely recommend!

Daron D.Daron Davis: The Shrimp and Grits are awesome! The Crab Cakes are fantastic!

The Frosty Frog Pizza & Daiquiri Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

8. The Frosty Frog Pizza & Daiquiri Bar

8.5
1 N Forest Beach Dr (at Avocet Rd), Hilton Head Island, SC
Pizzeria · 80 tips and reviews

Debbie M.Debbie McCall: Crabcake sandwich & pina colada daiquiri

charlie l.charlie lawson: The cheeseburger is awesome

Matt E.Matt Edwards: Try the hurricane and jump start mix! Local favorite!

Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

9. Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks

8.3
1 Hudson Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 85 tips and reviews

Nicole I.Nicole Irving: We had oysters, shecrab soup, shrimp, and the best blackened Mahi Mahi sandwich I have ever had. Incredibly delicious with a laid back atmosphere. This place is everything a seafood place should be.

Tracy K.Tracy Krupitzer: Vegans & Vegetarians, the Spinach and Pear Salad is amazing! As is the 7-Day Cole Slaw.

Leslie K.Leslie Keddie: The food is fabulous but watch out for the hostess Bre, her rudeness and lack of customer service bought us 7 free appetizers and a round of drinks from management! Thanks for the attitude, Bre!

Fishcamp on Broad Creek is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

10. Fishcamp on Broad Creek

8.7
11 Simmons Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 19 tips and reviews

Meghan B.Meghan Bingle: Beers, delicious oysters and seafood. Fun games outside (Cornhole, giant connect four, etc) also a great fire pit.

Courtney D.Courtney Desh: Food is alright, but the view is pretty especially at sunset

Andrew F.Andrew F: Cornhole, Jenga, and giant Connect Four games outside for the kids to play while you wait (or if the kids finish early)

Ela's Blu Water Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

11. Ela's Blu Water Grille

8.8
1 Shelter Cove Ln, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

CindyCindy: Great find! Wonderful location, great view, fabulous food! Well worth the trip, a new island favorite.

Patrick N.Patrick NeSmith: Great food - atmosphere

mrhammrham: The calamari, crab cakes, and grouper are delicious. Very friendly staff. Great environment. Live music. Generally, just a solid place for dinner.

Reilley's Grill & Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

12. Reilley's Grill & Bar

8.5
7D Greenwood Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 32 tips and reviews

Pat C.Pat Clisham: Great Food at Great Prices!!! Excellent service and specials most nights.

Jada R.Jada Reilley: (:

Brock I.Brock Irvin: I recommend the American poboy

Watusi Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

13. Watusi Cafe

8.3
71 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC
Coffee Shop · 30 tips and reviews

Scott K.Scott Key: To start they have Great black coffee, the biscuits and Gravy topped with fried eggs were also outstanding

Chris M.Chris McKinney: The Big Watusi Sandwich is great! Bacon and sausage! Best coffee on the island!

Rj W.Rj Wilkie: It is what it is.

Nick's Steak and Seafood is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

14. Nick's Steak and Seafood

7.5
9 Park Ln, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Dax W.Dax Whitehouse: Great service and good food. Broccoli Alfredo, Steak and She Crab Soup were all excellent.

Justin G.Justin Grant: Always a great place! Food drinks and service always awesome!

Jared R.Jared Rauh: Crab legs and Red Fish was awesome. They've got enough for non-seafood eaters too.

Main Street Cafe & Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Seafood Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

15. Main Street Cafe & Pub

7.4
1411 Main St, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 18 tips and reviews

Kerri B.Kerri Berlin: Honey sriracha wings are out of this world! Angus beef steak is delicious, as was my brisket sandwich!! Great service!

Daniel D.Daniel Dynan: Key lime pie. End of story.

Andy S.Andy Strickland: Love this place, stop there every year for great sandwiches and sides.