Bluebeard is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

1. Bluebeard

9.1
653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 60 tips and reviews

Jonathan C.Jonathan Coffin: Pendennis club cocktail is a must. And the brussels sprouts --- really --- are amazing. Or, and the bread pudding is pretty darn good too, assuming its on the menu.

Florence H.Florence H: Menu changes pretty regularly, so make sure you check on their website. But definitely try the brussels sprouts and the bread pudding. The bread pudding was magical.

Jennifer E.Jennifer Evans: Fantastic local gem with an amazing staff. Get the fresh baked bread and butters, bread pudding and small plates and starters to share. Loved the scallops but menu always changes.

Mesh is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

2. Mesh

8.3
725 Massachusetts Ave (N Park), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Chatham Arch · 60 tips and reviews

Joy H.Joy H: If the bread pudding is on the dessert menu, try it! It's creamy, not too sweet and rich with flavor.

Adrienne W.Adrienne Wright: The bread pudding is amazing!

B Barnett @.B Barnett @notoriousb_o_b: And get the Bread Pudding with Grater's...it's so good!

Edelweiss Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

3. Edelweiss Restaurant

8.2
8602 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
German Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Christina H.Christina Hunt-Schubnell: The Wednesday buffet is great. Try the bread pudding ;)

Bill C.Bill Chamberlin: Wonderful place! If you can manage dessert, go for the apple strudel with ice cream or the bread pudding.

Aaron B.Aaron Bradshaw: I would bathe in the German potato salad if it were socially acceptable.

Charleston's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

4. Charleston's Restaurant

8.0
6815 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Castleton · 32 tips and reviews

AmandaAmanda: Great food! The Bread Pudding is AMAZING!

Joseph D.Joseph Dixon: Great place to meet or greet! Food is fantastic and so is the service. If I might add, they have the best bread pudding you’ve ever had!

Chris R.Chris R: Excellent service, great food, and warm atmosphere. Highly recommend the Waldorf salad and a Sun King Cream Ale!

George's Neighborhood Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

5. George's Neighborhood Grill

7.6
6935 Lake Plaza Dr (Binford Blvd), Indianapolis, IN
Bar · 49 tips and reviews

Lakisha J.Lakisha Johnson: Get the donut bread pudding -- it's amazing!

PJ S.PJ Steele: Love the donut bread pudding!

SanslenomSanslenom: Proportions are huge. With the fillet...perfectly medium rare...you are served soup of the day (mushroom was awesome), salad, starch (potato or rice), vegetable, and roll. Wine is $5 a glass.

Northside Social is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

6. Northside Social

8.1
6525 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 18 tips and reviews

Kyle H.Kyle Hodges: Love the macaroni & cheese, wine & beer selections and bread pudding. Steak fondue appetizer is also great.

April G.April Gregory: Excellent food. Great atmosphere. Good for a group.

Jesika G.Jesika Gunter: The Ketel One Lemon Shake-up is so good!

Nine Irish Brothers is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

7. Nine Irish Brothers

8.5
575 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Irish Pub · Downtown Indianapolis · 21 tips and reviews

Dana P.Dana Parker: Fish and chips, a real ploughman's lunch, and the best bread pudding all make this a great new addition. Try the Trojan Horse, Guinness and Coca Cola!

Melanie P.Melanie P.: Food: Delicious Pots of Gold (potato skins). Drink: Black Fog (Guinness + raspberry liqueur).

MichaelMichael: Food and service is great. A beautiful place to dine !!

Sullivan's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

8. Sullivan's Steakhouse

8.1
3316 E 86th, Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Keystone at The Crossing · 33 tips and reviews

Julie S.Julie Singer: The Bananas Foster Bread Pudding is the best dessert on the menu and maybe even in the city!

Cindy W.Cindy Wine: The BEST bananas foster in the world! YUMMMMMM!

Brandi E.Brandi Escue: 1/2 price martinis on Thursday! Read more.

Red Lion Grog House is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

9. Red Lion Grog House

8.4
1043 Virginia Ave (in the G. C. Murphy Building), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Fountain Square · 63 tips and reviews

Theresa G.Theresa Goodwin: The bread pudding is awesome!

Andie M.Andie Meise: The stuffed portabella mushroom is delicious and make sure to grab some local sun king beer!

Flounder L.Flounder Lee: Get the curry sauce with pretty much anything.

Cafe Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

10. Cafe Bistro

7.4
8702 Keystone Xing, Indianapolis, IN
Diner · Keystone at The Crossing · 7 tips and reviews

Jasmine P.Jasmine Penarejo: Try the White Chocolate Raspberry Bread Pudding dessert!!! It's heavenly!!! Melt in your mouth delicious! Thank you Tom for suggesting it!!

Morgan K.Morgan Kidd: Order off the kids menu for a cheap lunch,/ awesome staff/ also the bistro club without meat is still amazing!

Gregory G.Gregory Gilmore: The fries and dipping sauce are out of this world.

Dale's Family Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

11. Dale's Family Restaurant

7.5
5209 E Thompson Rd (at S Emerson Av), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · I65-South Emerson · 30 tips and reviews

Christy M.Christy Merriman: Very very good food. Cajun chicken dinner for me and cajun shrimp alfredo for him. Bread pudding for the finish.. four thumbs up :) server was slow and unattentive but very nice and did a great job.

Christy M.Christy Merriman: We love the Alfredo. The Louisiana shrimp pasta is awesome too! We have never had bad food here. Top notch every time. Our waitress Missy is the best waitress ANYWHERE we have ever been. Over the top.

Molly P.Molly Pennington: Always a good choice. Good food n service

St Elmo's 1933 Lounge is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

12. St Elmo's 1933 Lounge

8.7
127 S Illinois St (above St Elmo's Steakhouse), Indianapolis, IN
Speakeasy · Downtown Indianapolis · 21 tips and reviews

Erik R.Erik Rowley: Perfect place to grab their signature shrimp cocktail and Elmo Colas while waiting for a table to open downstairs.

Jake S.Jake Smith: Sit at the bar and order a drink (not a beer)! Great spot if you're waiting for a table at the steakhouse or if you've just finished there.

Matt B.Matt Barbini: Don't even read the menu. Just get the sliders and mac and cheese.... Okay fine read the menu for the drinks but skip the last page where the food is because you're getting the sliders and mac.

Capri is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

13. Capri

8.2
2602 Ruth Dr, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Duncan A.Duncan Alney: This is a lovely traditional experience - even one that transports you to old world Italy! The service is very very good - and Michael will give you a taste of personal service. Prices are reasonable!

Jaime L.Jaime Lira: The BEST cannoli in town !

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Amazing food, fresh pasta. Great place, great people. Mentioned that it was my first time, and that we were celebrating a birthday... scored free, made-in-house Limoncello~ tasty!

Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

14. Harry & Izzy's

7.4
7800 Col H Weir Cook Mem Dr (in Indianapolis International Airport), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 63 tips and reviews

BeirneBeirne: I had the prime rib pizza and the chocolate bread pudding. Both were great!

Dalton S.Dalton Spear: Grab a drink at the bar while you wait on your flight. Or get a killer breakfast

Niles I.Niles Ingalls: Power plugs under the bar, 312 on draft.

Rock-Cola Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Bread Pudding in Indianapolis.

15. Rock-Cola Cafe

8.5
5730 Brookville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Diner · Irvington · 25 tips and reviews

Chris I.Chris Inks: The burgers are fantastic. They are large and very juicy for being 90% lean beef. Very nostalgic atmosphere. And they offer Choc ola!

Missy V.Missy Vail: Best breakfast on them east side. YUM!!!

Stephanie A.Stephanie Anderson: Don't sleep on or Satuday morning buffet....we are up early getting it ready for you