HotBox Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

1. HotBox Pizza

7.4
30 E Georgia St (at S Scioto St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 13 tips and reviews

Lori T.Lori Taylor: The ranch is bomb & so simple.... HVR Buttermilk seasoning & follow directions on pkg! Confirmed tonight by the friendly staff!

Jordan F.Jordan Foss: Holy shit this place is better than any sex you'll ever have in your life.

Reggie B.Reggie B: Grab a slice after a night out at Howl At The Moon.

Bru Burger Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

2. Bru Burger Bar

9.0
410 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Downtown Indianapolis · 152 tips and reviews

Sean M.Sean Molin: I'll tell you what's up: Buttermilk chicken tenders, dip in beer cheese. Mac 'n Cheese is incredibad and I don't even like spicy. Bourbon burger, sub the horseradish havarti for sharp white cheddar.

IS K.IS KLE: Top five burger. Great onion rings and beer selection. Homemade ketchup, Bbq sauce and Greta chicken wings w homemade sauce.

Gina M.Gina Mencias: Try the 3 cheese garlic burger. Tastes like garlic bread with cheese and meatballs!

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

3. Chick-fil-A

8.1
6231 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · Glendale · 6 tips and reviews

David L.David Leszcynski: Great service and great food, as always. Talk about a brand that is cohesive amongst stores.

JS N.JS Nagi: Dirty Bathrooms, outside property was dirty smelled bad, food below average at this location, dining area dirty as well

Elizabeth O.Elizabeth Olden: The chicken sandwich is #Life

Puccini's Pizza Pasta is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

4. Puccini's Pizza Pasta

8.4
1508 W 86th St (Ditch Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · North Willow Farms · 16 tips and reviews

Violet F.Violet Feaster: Great lunch specials! Angel hair spaghetti with a meatball is my favorite.

Sean M.Sean Molin: My favorite pizza place in town. Marginally better than Baxbeux, but wait staff is equally uninterested in you. The Sweet lil' Razorback is to die for.

Teresa T.Teresa Tatum: Razorback and Campfire are musts (they do halvsies!). A salad with homemade dressing, a pitcher of Osiris & you're set!

BBI Sandwich Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

5. BBI Sandwich Bar

8.6
4825 Oakbrook Dr, Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Snacks - Guion Creek · 16 tips and reviews

Matt W.Matt Williams: I had the grilled chipotle chicken sandwich (half) and the chicken chile soup. Delicious!

Justin B.Justin Bishop: They now have gyros!! They are delicious!

Nathan B.Nathan B.: Everything is very good

The Loft Restaurant at Traders Point Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

6. The Loft Restaurant at Traders Point Creamery

8.9
9101 Moore Rd (at W 92nd St), Zionsville, IN
American Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Marcia E.Marcia Erne: Excellent service and incredible food! The Quinoa Cakes are great, and I usually can say no to dessert, but the Peach/Strawberry/Ginger Pie was amazing!

Kevin F.Kevin Faulkner: Amazing cuisine and ambience, with a price to match. Get the salmon. Start with the cheese plate.

Chris S.Chris Stringfellow: The Chicken Macaroni and Cheese casserole is awesome!

Kona Jack's is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

7. Kona Jack's

8.6
9419 N Meridian St (in Meridian North Shopping Center), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · Nora - Far Northside · 18 tips and reviews

ʇʇoɔs ɹ.ʇʇoɔs ɹolʎɐʇ: Very filling, very delicious - great service and atmosphere. I'll be back :)

Noah S.Noah Swint: Great food, fast service and great atmosphere. All food was made from scratch and the Romano Herb Bread with Macadamia Nut butter was superb.

Bob S.Bob St Claire: Very good selection of seafood, preparations conservative but delicious. A bit pricey, particularly for lunch.

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

8. Chick-fil-A

9.0
3360 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · College Park · 29 tips and reviews

ArcyArcy: Ask for a kids size cone or sundae, which are not on the menu.

Lisa G.Lisa Green: Always great customer service!

ArcyArcy: Kids night Mondays 5:30-7:30 - Free kids meal per adult meal, face paint, & balloon animals

Transformations Salon and Spa is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

9. Transformations Salon and Spa

8.2
8083 A South Madison Avenue (at Stop 11 Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Health and Beauty Service · 10 tips and reviews

Laura F.Laura Farr: Great place! I've been coming here for over a year. Ask for Nicole!

Stacy S.Stacy Stuber: Nicole is the best!

Allie W.Allie Winger: Nicole is the greatest! Super sweet and good stylist!

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

10. Starbucks

8.7
5702 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Irvington · 25 tips and reviews

Chris S.Chris Suttile: Try the new Willow Blend. I like bold coffees but it's a nice change of pace for the weekends or an afternoon fix.

Kelsey D.Kelsey Dulgar: This is the best Starbucks ever.

Karina O.Karina Oertel: My fave Starbucks in the world!

PEARings Frozen Yogurt & Beyond is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

11. PEARings Frozen Yogurt & Beyond

8.8
6 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Downtown Indianapolis · 28 tips and reviews

Andrew M.Andrew Martz: Excellent duck sausage crepes. Much better than imagined!

Kimberly M.Kimberly McWhorter: Reasonably priced, great selection. Friendly service.

Kayleigh D.Kayleigh Dye: Salted Carmel Pretzel Frozen Yogurt is amazing. I am now determined to try all their flavors!

Keystone Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

12. Keystone Deli

7.5
2342 E 53rd St (at N Keystone Av), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

SarahSarah: Super cheap, quick and delicious. The smokehouse breakfast is a good deal. The biscuits and gravy were tasty too!

Bradley M.Bradley Moore: Mama's pancake breakfast!

Jeremiah L.Jeremiah Little: This place is awesome!

Illinois Street Food Emporium is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

13. Illinois Street Food Emporium

8.3
5550 N Illinois St (at 56th), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Butler - Tarkington · 18 tips and reviews

Kelsey V.Kelsey V.: Chicken salad is fabulous & the croissants are to die for. Enjoy!

Carol C.Carol Collins: Get the baked goods!!

Matt S.Matt S: Great food. Roast beef sandwich rules

Stoney's Liquor is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

14. Stoney's Liquor

8.4
5135 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
Liquor Store · Irvington · 12 tips and reviews

Chris D.Chris Donaghey: Come here. Now. Best craft beer selection on the east side by far, and among tops in Indy! Cold bombers of craft beer.

Will H.Will Hodges: Talk to casheer, she is a hoot!!!

Bryan S.Bryan Stonebraker: Best Craft beer Store on the east side.

Jazz Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Buttermilk in Indianapolis.

15. Jazz Kitchen

8.8
5377 N College Ave (at E 54th St), Indianapolis, IN
Jazz and Blues Venue · Meridian Kessler · 33 tips and reviews

Kyle H.Kyle Hodges: Good food, great place for company parties/events. Live jazz, funk, soul & hip-hop (select nights) and Indy original.

amanda c.amanda coleman: Rob Dixon, Nicholas Gerlach, Sleepy Floyd, Brandon Meeks and then some! It's funky in here!

SuperBowl 2012SuperBowl 2012: Voted one of the “World’s Top 100 Jazz Clubs in the World” The Jazz Kitchen features the best in local, regional and international jazz plus and a mix of New Orleans, Latino and midwest cuisine.