Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

1. Harry & Izzy's

8.5
4050 E 82nd St (Dean Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Castleton · 50 tips and reviews

Stu C.Stu Coleman: Prime rib sandwich and calamari are a must! Shrimp cocktail is just as good as advertised. Prime rib pizza is also delicious.

Michael Antonio C.Michael Antonio Canganelli: Penne Alfredo, calamari (unbreaded), shrimp cocktail, New York Strip steak, mashed potatoes and service were all great!

Ali E.Ali Edwards: First time here & loved it. Esp the brownie and filet sliders. Will be back!

Izakaya is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

2. Izakaya

8.3
7325 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN
Japanese Restaurant · Castleton · 30 tips and reviews

Bill C.Bill Chamberlin: Enjoyed the hibachi, everything cooked wonderfully; chef Sasna was not as talkative or interactive as others. Lunch portion is plenty and prices fair. Calamari rings appetizer was excellent!

Austin W.Austin Wilcox: Great lunchtime hibachi prices! Service is always excellent.

Roger S.Roger Shore: I agree w/others' tips but the Dynamite Roll is off the hook also.

Maggiano's Little Italy is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

3. Maggiano's Little Italy

8.8
3550 E 86th St (Keystone Crossing), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 54 tips and reviews

Joel S.Joel Smith: The calamari is the best in Indy. Hands down!

Denise D.Denise Dixon: Best Italian place ever! Fantastic lasagne!!

Mallory D.Mallory D: Hands down the best service when it comes to gluten free dining! (gfree pasta is tasty too!) the chef comes out to speak w you about your allergies, which let's you really enjoy your meal w no worries

Rick's Cafe Boatyard is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

4. Rick's Cafe Boatyard

8.8
4050 Dandy Trl (at W 38th St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Eagle Creek · 72 tips and reviews

Paula H.Paula Henry: Best Calamari I have ever had. Always a nice escape for a weekday lunch with views of Eagle Creek.

CS_just_CSCS_just_CS: Moscow mule and several other varieties. Try the Caribbean Mule!

Rachel H.Rachel Harrell: Request Rach H. If you tip BIG. Request Grey if you don't tip at all!! :p

Siam Square Thai Cuisine is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

5. Siam Square Thai Cuisine

8.7
936 Virginia Ave (btwn Grove Ave & Buchanan St), Indianapolis, IN
Thai Restaurant · Fountain Square · 78 tips and reviews

Chanie M.Chanie Mobley: if you love calimari and shrimp, try the yum woon sen and pad ba mee. so good!

Erik R.Erik Rowley: Wow what a find, this place is fantastic! The pad Thai is phenomenal, I had pork and spring rolls are a must get appetizer. Waiter was great one of the best Thai restaurants in the U.S.

Kaleb R.Kaleb Ratcliff: The Pad Seuw is fantastic!

Athens On 86th is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

6. Athens On 86th

8.0
2284 W 86th St (Post Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Greek Restaurant · North Willow Farms · 9 tips and reviews

Dylan T.Dylan Tolle: The Calamari was cooked perfectly.

Aja M.Aja May: Athens fries are the best!

tirajeh j.tirajeh jones: LOVE it...

Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

7. Harry & Izzy's

9.1
153 S Illinois St (at W Georgia St in Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 109 tips and reviews

Emory E.Emory Edwards: You can't go wrong with the Downtown Pizza, the Calamari, or the Steakburger....

April W.April Wood: Fillet slides are to die for!

Lindsay N.Lindsay N.: Try their Fried Green Tomatoes... one of my favorites when I am in town!

Mama Corolla's Old Italian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

8. Mama Corolla's Old Italian Restaurant

9.0
1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Meridian Kessler · 46 tips and reviews

Rachel N.Rachel Nealis: Try the calamari! The sauce is magical!!!

JTJT: Very homey American Italian with yummy fresh bread

Scott B.Scott Byerly: Watch out and make sure your entire party is present when you arrive. No call ahead seating or reservations taken. Their house policy is not to seat you until your entire party had arrived.

Mesh is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

9. Mesh

8.3
725 Massachusetts Ave (N Park), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Chatham Arch · 60 tips and reviews

Felicite M.Felicite Moorman: Casey is a phenomenal server!!! She knew the food AND wine menu exquisitely!!! The calamari was tremendous!! Half price cocktails Thursday?! Yes and yes!!!

Ron T.Ron Tatum: Fried calamari

Nicki L.Nicki Laycoax: The Berkshire Salad is really, really good. The chef prepares the pork medium. Say yes to medium. It's great!

Ambrosia is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

10. Ambrosia

7.4
915 E Westfield Blvd (at Guilford Av), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 15 tips and reviews

Chris S.Chris Shaffer: The calamari is awesome, order a plate!

Johnny W.Johnny Wright: Pollo al Chantagiana all day everyday. Best chicken dish in the Midwest.

Johnny W.Johnny Wright: Pollo alla chiantigiana is my personal favorite. If you enjoy sundried tomatoes get this dish!

Binkley's Kitchen & Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

11. Binkley's Kitchen & Bar

8.0
5902 N College Ave (at Kessler Bl E Dr), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 57 tips and reviews

John G.John Gerritsen: The calamari is fantastic!

David W.David Waldman: Great craft beer! Try the Triton Railsplitter IPA!

Yaw A.Yaw Anokwa: - lunch menu is pretty average.

Benihana is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

12. Benihana

8.0
8830 Keystone Xing (Keystone Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Japanese Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 38 tips and reviews

Ryan O.Ryan Oldfather: The lunch menu is a great deal. Get the lunch duo and pick your favorite two entrees. Love the calamari and scallops.

Jennifer E.Jennifer Evans: Great staff and perfect for a fun dinner or quick bite to eat. Sat in sushi bar and had crispy spicy tuna, tempura and edamame for about half off during their Banzai Hour.

Andy W.Andy Wilson: If you order the chicken fried rice (which is the best part of the meal) they just charge you extra and don't bring out the white rice. Ask for the white rice and you can have both for the same cost.

Flatwater Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

13. Flatwater Restaurant

9.1
832 E Westfield Blvd (at IWC Canal Greenway), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 81 tips and reviews

Clarissa C.Clarissa Carey: Pulled pork nachos and calimari! Also, Allen is the best!!!

Ricky P.Ricky Potts: If you are hungry, order a plate of pulled pork nachos. They are to die for. If you ask for a side of BBQ sauce you get an even deeper experience! Delicious.

Dave S.Dave Smiley: Eat the smoked pork nachos with the hot chili sauce

Fleming's Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

14. Fleming's Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar

7.5
8487 Union Chapel Road, Suite 120 (at E 86th St), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 14 tips and reviews

Anastassia Z.Anastassia Zukova: Calamari appetizer is heavenly. Also, for two, one appetizer, two small plates and one desert is plenty! Good wine list too...

Sean M.Sean Molin: Sit in the bar for dinner. They've got a great bar-only menu with many great specials. Not to mention complimentary chips!

Satyen J.Satyen Jhaveri: Roxanne is a great server here. Great food and great service!!

Murphys Craft House is one of The 15 Best Places for Calamari in Indianapolis.

15. Murphys Craft House

8.6
11705 Fox Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Bistro · 3 tips and reviews

David D.David Downend: Clean atmosphere, great french fries, good beer, nice outdoor seating that seems to be dog friendly at times.

Nancy Q.Nancy Quincy McDermott: Salmon was delicious!

Kimberly S.Kimberly Snyder: Beer, wine and craft cocktails on tap!