Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

1. Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company

8.3
647 Virginia Ave (at College Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Fletcher Place · 85 tips and reviews

Angela J.Angela Jorden: The Chai latte is phenomenal and so much better than Starbucks. Always great service and fresh cookies!

Jason Y.Jason Yavor: Love it here. Try the chai

Tonya B.Tonya Beeler: Meet Doug!

McAlister's Deli is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

2. McAlister's Deli

8.4
9140 Rockville Rd (Raceway Market Shops), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Chapel Hill - Ben Davis · 34 tips and reviews

Hannah H.Hannah Huffman: The choose two is awesome! You can get half of a starter,salad, spud or sandwich, or two half portions of any of the above.

Eric T.Eric Thomas: Two words.... SWEET TEA! Read more.

Nancy R.Nancy Roberts: Great for sweet tea and a wholesome meal!

McAlister's Deli is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

3. McAlister's Deli

8.2
9450 N Meridian St Ste C (Park Meridian), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Nora - Far Northside · 31 tips and reviews

Mattie S.Mattie S: Try ordering the veggie club with chicken. Sweet tea is amazing!

Matt J.Matt Jacobson: Sweet tea, enough said

LisaLisa: Get the Chicken Tortilla Soup it's amazing!!

Rick's Cafe Boatyard is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

4. Rick's Cafe Boatyard

8.8
4050 Dandy Trl (at W 38th St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Eagle Creek · 72 tips and reviews

Jon B.Jon Brewer: Great food! Great view and location. Good beers on hand too.

Paula H.Paula Henry: Best Calamari I have ever had. Always a nice escape for a weekday lunch with views of Eagle Creek.

Rachel H.Rachel Harrell: Request Rach H. If you tip BIG. Request Grey if you don't tip at all!! :p

McAlisters Deli is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

5. McAlisters Deli

7.8
8840 Michigan Rd Ste 104 (at Vincennes Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · College Park · 53 tips and reviews

Chris R.Chris R: One of the best McAllister's Delis I've been to. The atmosphere and the excellent service staff really made the difference on my last visit. Food made to order and at the right temp. Sweet tea!

aaron d.aaron doster: The sweet tea is liquid crack.

Scott K.Scott Keath: Ask for Scott. He's awesome! Best....employee...ever!

Buca di Beppo is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

6. Buca di Beppo

7.1
6045 E 86th St (at Castleton Square Dr), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Castleton · 17 tips and reviews

Cory B.Cory Brown: Buca has a special place in my heart. The atmosphere is good and the servers are always pleasant. Take time to sip on wine and enjoy the company of others. Highly recommend for small social gatherings

Crystal I.Crystal Irvine: Best Italian food around!!! Must have a meatball!!

Stephen H.Stephen Howard: Everything is good. But the pizza is great.

Buca di Beppo is one of The 7 Best Places for Fresh Cookies in Indianapolis.

7. Buca di Beppo

7.3
35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 51 tips and reviews

Mandi P.Mandi Paul: Excellent restaurant, excellent food! The wait staff are excellent and the chef personally came out to see how we liked the food.

Tim L.Tim Landess: The GM Chris and staff rock! What a great experience and awesome food!

Robin H.Robin Hartowicz: Best bread with oil an vinegar EVER.