Greiner's Submarine Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

1. Greiner's Submarine Shop

8.4
2126 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Near Southside · 5 tips and reviews

Diet S.Diet Stu: Try the hoagie!

Tracey R.Tracey R: Try the mac and cheese, the one at the top of the menu! Awesome, best ever! Puts chain restaurants to shame. Their sea salt-topped brownies are perfect. Ask the owner to fix you her favorite sub.

Rew V.Rew Van Wyck: Great fresh subs

Murphys Craft House is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

2. Murphys Craft House

8.6
11705 Fox Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Bistro · 3 tips and reviews

David D.David Downend: Clean atmosphere, great french fries, good beer, nice outdoor seating that seems to be dog friendly at times.

Nancy Q.Nancy Quincy McDermott: Salmon was delicious!

Kimberly S.Kimberly Snyder: Beer, wine and craft cocktails on tap!

Portillo’s is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

3. Portillo’s

8.2
8150 US 31 S, Indianapolis, IN
Restaurant · No tips or reviews
Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

4. Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar

8.6
1325 W 86th St (at Ditch Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 16 tips and reviews

Johnny W.Johnny Wright: Best neighborhood bar around. Excellent food, excellent people. A bit smoky. The Thursday steak special is FTW

Leslie C.Leslie C: Ask for Miss Leslie for the best service of your life!

☠Bill C.☠Bill Cesavice☠: Tip well, the staff deserves it.

The District Tap is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

5. The District Tap

8.9
3720 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Sports Bar · Castleton · 27 tips and reviews

Jes N.Jes Nijjer: Fish tacos and carnitas tacos are excellent. Smokey mac fully hits the spot.

Dana P.Dana Parker: Really good Cajun Mac and Cheese! Lots of beers and good atmosphere

Elizabeth R.Elizabeth Renneisen: Amazing beer selection!

Rock-Cola Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

6. Rock-Cola Cafe

8.7
5730 Brookville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Diner · Irvington · 25 tips and reviews

Chris I.Chris Inks: The burgers are fantastic. They are large and very juicy for being 90% lean beef. Very nostalgic atmosphere. And they offer Choc ola!

Missy V.Missy Vail: Best breakfast on them east side. YUM!!!

Stephanie A.Stephanie Anderson: Don't sleep on or Satuday morning buffet....we are up early getting it ready for you

Kona Jack's is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

7. Kona Jack's

8.6
9419 N Meridian St (in Meridian North Shopping Center), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · Nora - Far Northside · 18 tips and reviews

Bob S.Bob St Claire: Very good selection of seafood, preparations conservative but delicious. A bit pricey, particularly for lunch.

ʇʇoɔs ɹ.ʇʇoɔs ɹolʎɐʇ: Very filling, very delicious - great service and atmosphere. I'll be back :)

Noah S.Noah Swint: Great food, fast service and great atmosphere. All food was made from scratch and the Romano Herb Bread with Macadamia Nut butter was superb.

Bynum's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

8. Bynum's Steakhouse

8.5
3850 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · 17 tips and reviews

Mick W.Mick Welling: All the steaks are good. NY STRIP is my favorite, but they are known for their Prime Rib. Bone-In, it's huge.

⚜️🇲🇶 .⚜️🇲🇶 🇱🇺🇮🇸: Beginning October 1,2013 you have to pay $2.00 per person if you bring in your own birthday cake.

Samantha H.Samantha Hurley: John is one of the best servers we've ever had anywhere! They are making the nuts for the salad request only so if you like them remember to ask and you'll get them. Not a bad thing on the menu.

Stoney's Liquor is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

9. Stoney's Liquor

8.1
5135 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
Liquor Store · Irvington · 12 tips and reviews

Erin B.Erin Barnett Nichols: Crazy good local/craft beer selection. Second only to Kahn's.

Will H.Will Hodges: Talk to casheer, she is a hoot!!!

Bryan S.Bryan Stonebraker: Best Craft beer Store on the east side.

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

10. Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta

8.0
7755 E Washington St (at I-465, exit 46), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Raymond Park · 4 tips and reviews

Joshua "LEGO" l.Joshua "LEGO" lohrman: Try the meatlovers with BBQ sauce also the service is great

Mike S.Mike Schmidt: Excellent customer service and better pizza!!

Carley A.Carley Abernathy: First time n wonderful experience. We got free soda n cookies while waiting on our order...

A2Z Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

11. A2Z Cafe

8.2
4705 E 96th St #35 (Grey Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Keystone at The Crossing · 19 tips and reviews

Gina L.Gina Latham: Everything is delicious here and the service is always top notch. The A2Z plate is my favorite.

Stephanie D.Stephanie Daily: Open at 7, great coffee, breakfast deals. Support Local!

Stephanie D.Stephanie Daily: Try the Portabello Pannini, Yummy

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

12. Panera Bread

8.1
3824 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Castleton · 15 tips and reviews

Ricky P.Ricky Potts: Panera as a whole is an incredible establishment. Their food selections are endless & always changing and their coffee is comparable to the best in the business. Providing free wi-fi is HUGE as well. Read more.

Sandra S.Sandra Suran: Cinnamon crunch bagels are awesome!

Melissa F.Melissa Feathers: LOVE the hazelnut coffee. Not overpowering, but definitely flavorful...yum!

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

13. Panera Bread

7.9
9145 E 56th St, Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · 11 tips and reviews

Renee L.Renee Larson-Endsley: Best place to get some work done! Healthy options as well!

Audra H.Audra Hodgin: Very pleasant and helpful employees at this Panera

NikiNiki: Terrible wifi. Fairly sluggish and it's out every 20 min.

New Bethel Ordinary is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

14. New Bethel Ordinary

7.9
8858 Southeastern Ave (Northeastern Avenue), Wanamaker, IN
Pizzeria · 17 tips and reviews

Mark C.Mark Cavanaugh: Wow!!! Great service!!! Amazing pizza!!! Lackluster bread sticks

Craig C.Craig Chaos: Best pizza hands down!

Dale J.Dale Johnson: The pizza is crazy good!!!!!

Boathouse Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Hoagies in Indianapolis.

15. Boathouse Grille

8.4
6225 W 56th St (at N High School Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · 32 tips and reviews

Lin F.Lin Fox: Great place.. good atmosphere...worth going again and again

Allen A.Allen Archibald: Joy, is a joy!!!

Shawn D.Shawn Dickensheets: Katie is top notch server!