1. Harry & Izzy's
9.1
153 S Illinois St (at W Georgia St in Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 109 tips and reviews
Chris Pollone: Try the Shrimp Cocktail - My sinuses jumped, screaming from my face. Tons of horseradish. Awesome.
David Schwartz: It's a staple when you are in Indianapolis. If you like horseradish this is the spot. Their shrimp cocktail is swimming in their STRONG horseradish sauce. Give it a try.
Casey Charpio: Everyone raves about the shrimp cocktail, but other than a lot of horseradish that makes it "unique," I don't get it. I'll take flavor instead. And the pizza crust was made by Firestone.
2. St. Elmo Steak House
9.0
127 S Illinois St (btw Maryland St. & Georgia St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 196 tips and reviews
David Fox: We shared 2 steaks amoung the 5 of us. No extra charge for splitting (though you cut it up yourselves). Also, amazing shrimp coctail. Huge shrimp (prawns?) in a sauce with lots of fresh horseradish.
Todd Norris: Try the Shrimp Cocktail - The amount of horseradish in the aside kicks you in the nuts. So good could not recommend it more,a must try.
Jorge Arango: Shrimp cocktail is special the horseradish sauce is intense!!
Shawn Plew: The shrimp cocktail is great. Large clean shrimp & spicy horseradish cocktail sauce.
Mick Welling: All the steaks are good. NY STRIP is my favorite, but they are known for their Prime Rib. Bone-In, it's huge.
⚜️🇲🇶 🇱🇺🇮🇸: Beginning October 1,2013 you have to pay $2.00 per person if you bring in your own birthday cake.
5. The Rathskeller
8.3
401 E Michigan St (in Athenaeum Building), Indianapolis, IN
German Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 74 tips and reviews
Sarah: Definitely worth the price. You get a ton of food, and there are PRETZELS in the bread baskets! The mustard that comes with is VERY spicy horseradish. Delicious. Apple strudel for dessert!
Sarah: Get the hot wurst platte to share! It is a TON of food, so you might not even need an entrée. The mustard is super spicy but tasty! The jaegerschnitzel is delicious as well.
Kevin DeFord: Go to the Rathskeller and party in the Biergarten
8. McAlister's Deli
7.4
8487 Union Chapel Rd (at E 86th St. (Fashion Mall Commons)), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Keystone at The Crossing · 35 tips and reviews
Brad Trimble: The horseradish roast beef sandwich is great.
Paul Lucas: Top three best menu items are the Orange Cranberry Club, the Mediterranean Feta pizza flat, and the Grilled Chicken Spud. And of course you have to wash it all down with a sweet tea.
Steve Wilmoth: BBQ Nachos cannot be stopped!
David Downend: Clean atmosphere, great french fries, good beer, nice outdoor seating that seems to be dog friendly at times.
Nancy Quincy McDermott: Salmon was delicious!
Kimberly Snyder: Beer, wine and craft cocktails on tap!
10. Bru Burger Bar
8.9
410 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Downtown Indianapolis · 152 tips and reviews
Sean Molin: I'll tell you what's up: Buttermilk chicken tenders, dip in beer cheese. Mac 'n Cheese is incredibad and I don't even like spicy. Bourbon burger, sub the horseradish havarti for sharp white cheddar.
Maria Alviz: Great outside seating area, amazing selection of burgers and very kid-friendly!
Gina Mencias: Try the 3 cheese garlic burger. Tastes like garlic bread with cheese and meatballs!