St. Elmo Steak House is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

1. St. Elmo Steak House

8.9
127 S Illinois St (btw Maryland St. & Georgia St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 196 tips and reviews

John P.John Pestka: The Shrimp Cocktail is a must though beware the heat... holy cow. I also highly recommend the infused Maker's Mark on the rocks - tasty and enjoyable. Extensive wine list with something for all.

Martin O.Martin Ovando: Definitively my fav restaurant in Indianapolis so far! Try the Filet Mignon with potatoes, a beauty!

Visit IndyVisit Indy: Shrimp Cocktail is amazing and the cocktails are even better. Try the Bloody Mary that is made with St. E's famous cocktail sauce!

The Melting Pot is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

2. The Melting Pot

8.6
5650 E 86th St Ste A (at Castleton Corner Dr), Indianapolis, IN
Fondue Restaurant · Castleton · 20 tips and reviews

Haley B.Haley Butcher: Great for a girls night out or birthday party. Chocolate lovers: Try the chocolate fondue. They have multiple selections including milk chocolate, white chocolate, and a "yin yang" flavor.

G. R.G. Rock: Wisconsin cheese is fantastic.

Sarah O.Sarah Oliver: Try the smores chocolate fondue, it is to die for!

Northside Social is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

3. Northside Social

8.1
6525 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 18 tips and reviews

April G.April Gregory: Excellent food. Great atmosphere. Good for a group.

Jesika G.Jesika Gunter: The Ketel One Lemon Shake-up is so good!

Pete B.Pete B: Make sure to try one of the signature cocktails!

Union 50 is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

4. Union 50

8.6
620 N East St, Indianapolis, IN
Gastropub · Downtown Indianapolis · 31 tips and reviews

Erik R.Erik Rowley: If I were Will Smith in Hitch this is where I'd go. This place has style and one of my favorite bars in Indy. Live music, lounge chairs, games on tv, outdoor patio, and excellent drink choices.

Whitney Q.Whitney Q: They have skee ball and good drinks! Win win.

David L.David Leszcynski: Outstanding drink selection and the band was amazing. The atmosphere topped of the evening. I will definitely be returning.

North End Barbecue And Moonshine is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

5. North End Barbecue And Moonshine

8.3
1250 E 86th St (Evergreen Ave), Indianapolis, IN
BBQ Joint · Nora - Far Northside · 24 tips and reviews

Dana P.Dana Parker: Amazing brisket, the Mac and cheese gave me warm fuzzies, and the sauces are too good to pick just one. They even play classic movies! We saw Convoy and The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. Solid place!

Joseph L.Joseph Loria: Pulled pork, brisket, Mac and cheese, baked beans, corn bread, collard greens.

Vanessa J.Vanessa Jennette: All you need: bone marrow fries & moonshine punch

Iozzo's Garden Of Italy is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

6. Iozzo's Garden Of Italy

8.1
946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 38 tips and reviews

Erik R.Erik Rowley: The Lasagna at Iozzo's is the best I've had anywhere in the US! A must eat when in Indy. This is one of my favorite restaurants in the city, family run since the 1940s (Pictures all over the walls).

Jason Z.Jason Zickler: Great Marsala!

Kaye K.Kaye Kendall: They have one of the most extensive gluten-free menus around. Email Chef Kathy ahead of time for the best service...most of the menu can be modified to be gluten free. I have always left happy!

New Bethel Ordinary is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

7. New Bethel Ordinary

7.9
8858 Southeastern Ave (Northeastern Avenue), Wanamaker, IN
Pizzeria · 17 tips and reviews

Steve A.Steve Aldridge: Best pizza around, no contest!

Craig C.Craig Chaos: Best pizza hands down!

Dale J.Dale Johnson: The pizza is crazy good!!!!!

Modita is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

8. Modita

7.5
850 Massachusetts Ave Ste 110, Indianapolis, IN
Asian Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 2 tips and reviews

John (.John (aka “PHATFoodFan”): Nice ambience, good service, creative presentation, but taste was way too salty, even for someone just recovering from Covid. Go with the salmon if you visit. https://www.instagram.com/p/CWj1n__j-g8/?

Zach S.Zach Schlicher: Great service, great cocktails and great food.

Oceanaire Seafood Room is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

9. Oceanaire Seafood Room

8.2
30 S Meridian St (btwn E Maryland St and E Washington St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 44 tips and reviews

Ernie S.Ernie Smith: Unbelievably wonderful food! Great for business parties or guests, or for an anniversary. Oceanaire is probably the best seafood restaraunt I have ever eaten at. Enjoy!! Read more.

Jessica B.Jessica Brown: Order the Chocolate Mousse!

John K.John Kinder: Have bartender Jessica make a 'Fresca' substituting Death's Door White Whisky for tequila. You'll be glad you did.

Grindstone Charley's is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

10. Grindstone Charley's

7.6
5383 Rockville Rd (at Lynhurst Dr), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

Jennifer H.Jennifer Harmon-Freund: Parmesan chicken and BBQ chicken flatbread pizza is the best and easy to share between 2 people

Nancy R.Nancy Roberts: Jack Daniels ribs are the best! Ask for Nikki in the bar,!

AshlizbruAshlizbru: Don't show up on a horse and expect to be served at the bar!

Bru Burger Bar is one of The 11 Best Places for Maker's Mark in Indianapolis.

11. Bru Burger Bar

8.9
410 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Downtown Indianapolis · 152 tips and reviews

Matthew S.Matthew Sadler: Great burgers! I loved the Melt Your Face Burger.

Gina M.Gina Mencias: Try the 3 cheese garlic burger. Tastes like garlic bread with cheese and meatballs!

Matt H.Matt Hunckler: The bacon here is money. Order it on everything. Everything.