Portillo’s is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

1. Portillo’s

8.4
8150 US 31 S, Indianapolis, IN
Restaurant · No tips or reviews
Arni's Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

2. Arni's Restaurant

8.7
4705 E 96th St (at Brandt Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Keystone at The Crossing · 41 tips and reviews

Anita K.Anita Kerlin: Southern fried chicken salad with honey mustard. Be sure to get your garlic bread! Amazing!

Dustin W.Dustin Weber: Paige is the greatest server!

Sarah L.Sarah Lutomski: Paige S is the best server!

Marco's Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

3. Marco's Restaurant

7.9
54th Street (Keystone), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · 32 tips and reviews

Jason S.Jason Schall: The $10.95 Filet Meal on Tuesday is one of the best deals in town!

Jen G.Jen Gifford: Horribly rude hostess!! And apparently they only seat reservations on Saturday night.

Shawn D.Shawn Dickensheets: Upgrade to the wedge salad. Worth it!

Red Lion Grog House is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

4. Red Lion Grog House

8.5
1043 Virginia Ave (in the G. C. Murphy Building), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Fountain Square · 63 tips and reviews

Jeremy W.Jeremy Williams: The Fish & Chips are great. Be sure to order a side of the spicy curry sauce, it's awesome.

Flounder L.Flounder Lee: Get the curry sauce with pretty much anything.

Megan B.Megan Bennett: Strong Bow on tap!

The Rathskeller is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

5. The Rathskeller

8.6
401 E Michigan St (in Athenaeum Building), Indianapolis, IN
German Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 74 tips and reviews

Amy B.Amy Brockway-Jackl: The Ayinger Celebrator Double Bock is a don't-miss for dark beer fans! Authentic German atmosphere and dishes but plenty of non-German food for any diners who are mostly there for the drink.

Kevin D.Kevin DeFord: Go to the Rathskeller and party in the Biergarten

Kevin S.Kevin Scott: The Rathskeller is a theme restaurant that serves good German food."

Ralston's DraftHouse is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

6. Ralston's DraftHouse

8.1
635 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Chatham Arch · 57 tips and reviews

Celeste T.Celeste Thayer: Great people watching. Tasty appetizers, and outdoor seating is nice, when the weather cooperates

Andrea T.Andrea Townsend: Beer list is great! Also, try the Guinness mustard.

Shan P.Shan Parker: The Recession Burger is amazing! Better than anything you'll find at Bru Burger. The rosemary potatoes were also especially tasty!

Ale Emporium is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

7. Ale Emporium

9.0
8617 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Castleton · 109 tips and reviews

Adam Z.Adam Zeigler: World famous "Hermanki Wings".(A must try! Spicy Teriyaki sauce blend grilled on to the wings)

Paris G.Paris Gray: Order the hermanaki wings best ever

Men's Health MagMen's Health Mag: Funny finding a place like this in a strip mall. The joint offers more than 100 beers from around the world, pizza, and sports on TV. Snag a Bitburger, and soak up all America has to offer.

Kilroy's Bar N' Grill is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

8. Kilroy's Bar N' Grill

7.7
831 Broad Ripple Ave (Guilford Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Sports Bar · Broad Ripple · 63 tips and reviews

DanaDana: Pretty cool place! Lots of t.v.'s + some good choices of flavored shots!

Brady S.Brady Stout: Great bar. Def the most awkward urinal setup I've ever seen

Rachel R.Rachel Rubes: The wait staff here is terribly slow, and the Long Island pitchers will give you diarrhea.

Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge is one of The 9 Best Places for Mushroom Caps in Indianapolis.

9. Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge

7.6
20 N Meridian St (at Monument Cir), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Downtown Indianapolis · 58 tips and reviews

Lauren W.Lauren Weatherall: One of downtown Indy's hidden gems. It's like walking into a 1920s lounge. Grab a couch and a strong cocktail. You have to try their stuffed olives!

Geoff T.Geoff Tracey: Behave yourself

EsquireEsquire: Congratulations, you've found one of Esquire's Best Bars in America. At Nicky Blaine's, everyone is sexy and full-blooded. Something about the lighting. Or maybe it's the Dean martinis. Read more.