The Rathskeller is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

1. The Rathskeller

8.6
401 E Michigan St (in Athenaeum Building), Indianapolis, IN
German Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 74 tips and reviews

Charlie R.Charlie Reid: Great mustard. Unforgettable goes with you.

Kerstyn B.Kerstyn B.: Spicy mustard and tasty beer, delicious!

Eric M.Eric McCutchan: Will, the tears are WHY the mustard is awesome!

Shapiro's Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

2. Shapiro's Delicatessen

8.7
808 S Meridian St (bt Sycamore & W McCarty Sts), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Downtown Indianapolis · 97 tips and reviews

Frank D.Frank Dominguez: Corned Beef on Rye with Mustard ...

Guy K.Guy Kaiser: You cannot go wrong with peppered beef on rye with brown mustard. If you're sitting and eating, make sure to grab a potato pancake too.

Robyn M.Robyn Miller: Corned beef, Shapiro's rye, mustard, and a pickle spear. This is a must.

Ralston's DraftHouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

3. Ralston's DraftHouse

8.1
635 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Chatham Arch · 57 tips and reviews

Andrea T.Andrea Townsend: Beer list is great! Also, try the Guinness mustard.

Dawn D.Dawn DeVirgilio: The food is amazing. Pretzels with amazing mustard sauces to the Holyoke sliders - you can't go wrong with any dish!

Vanessa J.Vanessa Jennette: Their house made honey mustard dressing is magical.

Some Guys Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

4. Some Guys Pizza

9.3
6235 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Eastwood · 28 tips and reviews

Christy M.Christy Merriman: House salad with honey mustard dressing and agree the BBQ chicken wood oven pizza soo good

SarahSarah: The house salad with the Italian dressing with gorgonzola is the perfect starter. The spinach and artichoke dip is also very tasty.

David W.David Waldman: Amazing food. Triton Brewing Company Railsplitter IPA in the bottle. Exceptional service. A favorite!

Which Wich? Superior Sandwiches is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

5. Which Wich? Superior Sandwiches

8.4
910 W 10th St Ste 10, Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Downtown Indianapolis · 15 tips and reviews

Ryan G.Ryan Gregory: Get the Wicked, toasted on white bread, with American cheese, iceberg lettuce, bell peppers, black olives, salt, pepper and honey mustard. Delicious!!

Andrew M.Andrew Murphy: Very friendly staff great experience loved the way to order very different and very cool!! A tad pricey but not overly expensive on a tight college student budget!!

Adnarim S.Adnarim Sirdne: The shakes are awesome as well as the service & friendly staff. So glad they finally opened one downtown.

Ripple Bagel & Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

6. Ripple Bagel & Deli

8.5
850 Broad Ripple Ave (at Guilford Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
Bagel Shop · Broad Ripple · 83 tips and reviews

Joe H.Joe Harris: Get the pastrami on a garlic bagel with peperjack and honey mustard

SarahSarah: Going in the daytime is never a problem, though. Service is quick and friendly. The Greek bagel is my favorite!

Dawn D.Dawn DeVirgilio: Try Sarah's Secret or The Gin Blossom. Delicious at 3am and 3pm!

Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

7. Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar

8.5
823 E Westfield Blvd (btwn College Ave. and Guilford Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Broad Ripple · 33 tips and reviews

cognetic c.cognetic cognetic: Seriously... Chicken paillard with lemon and mustard sauce on the side over pommes purée... As basics good French cuisine with a Prosecco is the best!

Brian M.Brian McGowan: Another top midwestern brunch spot located in Indy. Stunning croque madame and monsieur and omletes.

Air-Tan U.Air-Tan USA: They had me at Prosecco Cocktails !! LOVE !

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

8. Chick-fil-A

7.4
420 University Blvd Ste 120, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 4 tips and reviews

David P.David Poindexter: Ask for the honey mustard bbq!

Ben R.Ben Risinger: Nuggets. Polynesian Sauce. Perfect.

Say it in ShirtsSay it in Shirts: Tuesday night is kids night! Kids eat free w/the purchase of an adult entree.

Arni's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

9. Arni's Restaurant

8.3
4705 E 96th St (at Brandt Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Keystone at The Crossing · 41 tips and reviews

Anita K.Anita Kerlin: Southern fried chicken salad with honey mustard. Be sure to get your garlic bread! Amazing!

Kris G.Kris Good: Fantastic Gluten Free pizza if you're a GF type. My wife has celiac so GF is a must

Dustin W.Dustin Weber: Paige is the greatest server!

Dairy Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

10. Dairy Queen

7.3
3826 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Christian Park · 3 tips and reviews

David M.David Mayo: Footling Hotdog with cheese, relish, onion and mustard is really good.

Carrie H.Carrie H.: Pecan cluster blizzard with butterscotch cone dip mixed in instead of chocolate!

Kris R.Kris Reed: Oreo blizzard with extra oreos so yummy!!!!

Cafe Patachou is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

11. Cafe Patachou

8.8
225 W Washington St (at Capital), Indianapolis, IN
Café · Downtown Indianapolis · 125 tips and reviews

Visit IndyVisit Indy: Get the Broken Yolk w/ bacon & avocado & add the grainy mustard -- your stomach will thank you!

Kristin L.Kristin Lukowski: A+ experience. Omelets and sandwiches are great, fruit bowl is a nice touch, coffee is self-serve and delicious, and gluten-free bread is available.

Paul K.Paul Kalka: The broken yoke sandwiches are awesome!

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

12. Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

8.8
65 E Pearl Street, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 57 tips and reviews

Etta W.Etta Ward: Great calzones! Try it with chicken and mushrooms...and a side of honey mustard. Hannah is the best server. She gets the highest tip from me :-)

Ray M.Ray Meury: Best pizza of my life! The buffalo pizza!

David AllenDavid Allen: Fergy is the shit ,D.A. approved!

Thunderbird is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

13. Thunderbird

7.9
1127 Shelby St (Morris street), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Fountain Square · 25 tips and reviews

Brittany P.Brittany Pikula Castner: May I suggest the kale salad with portobello mushroom bacon, sweet potatoes, pickled peppers, mustard vinaigrette and a poached egg?! Rotating local craft beer taps and unique cocktails. Welcome to FS

Andy @.Andy @hust0058: The beet salad is a must. And the kale salad is terrific. Have fun exploring this strong list of cocktails!

SarahSarah: Service can be slow, but that's to be expected on Saturday nights. Most beers are $6 for a pint and they have quite a good selection of beers on tap.

Indy All Night is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

14. Indy All Night

8.6
1324 S East St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Near Southside · 100 tips and reviews

Marie G.Marie Graves: My favorite sandwich is the Italian!It has something sweet on it, not sure if it is the mustard or what, but it is wonderful!I break my diet for this sandwich.

claire d.claire deleo: I like just about everything on their menu especially their portions of pasta. This place is really one of the best restaurants that I've ever tasted. I am really craving for more of their food

Nicolas H.Nicolas Harvey: The pizza was so good;the cheese more flavorful than regular delivery, the toppings were fresh and even the crust was delicious! Everything was great.

McAlister's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Mustard in Indianapolis.

15. McAlister's Deli

7.8
9702 E Washington St Ste 600 (at N Mitthoefer Rd. (Cherry Tree Plaza)), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Far Eastside · 20 tips and reviews

Tyler M.Tyler Martin: The Grilled Chicken Club is delicious but ask for a side of honey mustard.

David L.David Leszcynski: Great service, and great products. The food is always fresh and the sweet tea is amazing.

RondaRonda: Spicy Southwest Chicken sandwich & Chicken Tortilla soup ;)