Izakaya is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

1. Izakaya

8.0
7325 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN
Japanese Restaurant · Castleton · 30 tips and reviews

Matt K.Matt Klein: Try the j and j roll.. Not on the menu.. Soft shell crab plus lots of goddieness...

Shelly M.Shelly McM: Try the Crazy James Roll.....it is the best roll at Izakaya! (Not on the menu must ask for it)

Bill C.Bill Chamberlin: Enjoyed the hibachi, everything cooked wonderfully; chef Sasna was not as talkative or interactive as others. Lunch portion is plenty and prices fair. Calamari rings appetizer was excellent!

Eddy's Neighborhood Bar & Grill at Geist is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

2. Eddy's Neighborhood Bar & Grill at Geist

7.7
11693 Fall Creek Rd (Fall Creek and Brook School Road), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Mike O.Mike O'Connell: The staff is fantastic. I've always enjoyed the food and asked for the sw chicken salad which was a special and not on the menu. They gladly made it which involved a lot more prep. I highly recommend.

Ty A.Ty Anderson: Great food. Outside dining is awesome

Patricia R.Patricia R: Elizabeth is a very attentive server.

Tomo Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

3. Tomo Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar

8.6
7411 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Japanese Restaurant · 36 tips and reviews

Mick W.Mick Welling: Spicy Cajun Salmon Roll ... It's not on the menu, it's a Chef's Special. ASK FOR IT, you won't be sorry!

Jeremy W.Jeremy Wade: Great sushi place for sushi lovers. If you love sauces and fancy arrangements they have that too... but the fish is the star of the show here.

MichaelMichael: Pretend it's your birthday. Get free iced cream and fried banana.

Big City Grill & Lemonade is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

4. Big City Grill & Lemonade

8.3
23 E 38th St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Mapleton - Fall Creek · 13 tips and reviews

rye d.rye dinius: Guys here are really awesome try the veggie gyro, it's not on the menu tho

Dee D.Dee Dee: I love love love the lemonade here!!!!

Stephen H.Stephen Hiser: The Italian Beef Combo is great unless you can't handle hot peppers.

Noodles & Company is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

5. Noodles & Company

7.6
927 Broad Ripple Ave (at Winthrop Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Noodle Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 19 tips and reviews

Hope B.Hope Berndt: This place is GREAT for groups, but horrible for indecisive folks! But you really can't go wrong with anything off the menu!

Jesika G.Jesika Gunter: Manager and cashier are awesome! Such great service! I love the penne rosa with parm chicken and the Thai soup.

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Party punch: equal parts Fresca, Hi-C punch, Sprite. Yum!

Carrabba's Italian Grill is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

6. Carrabba's Italian Grill

8.0
4690 Southport Crossings Dr, Southport, IN
Italian Restaurant · 18 tips and reviews

DeanDean: Their Rigatoni (which is THE BOMB) is not on the menu, but you can still ask for it. And should.

MichaelMichael: My favorite Italian Resteraunt! Try the quatro formaggi pizza...

Matt R.Matt Ribar: Ask for Josh, if he is available, he is the best waiter we have had. Little known secret: get Sicilian Chicken Soup and ask for a Soup n Scoop, they'll put in a scoop of mashed. Unbelievable!

Ginza Japanese Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

7. Ginza Japanese Steak House

7.7
5380 W 38th St (at Moller Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · 19 tips and reviews

Stephanie S.Stephanie Swaney Brandhoefer: Shrimp Kami roll is good, not on the menu!

Sean M.Sean Molin: Where do I begin? I've been to almost every Japanese Steak House in Indy. None come close to Ginza for sheer food quality. Ginza Star is to die for. My favorite filet and scallops anywhere.

Stephanie S.Stephanie Swaney Brandhoefer: Crazy roll is best!

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

8. Chick-fil-A

9.0
3360 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · College Park · 29 tips and reviews

ArcyArcy: Ask for a kids size cone or sundae, which are not on the menu.

Joe A.Joe Allman: The new chicken tortilla soup is really nice and relatively low-cal

Lisa G.Lisa Green: Always great customer service!

Ball & Biscuit is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

9. Ball & Biscuit

8.8
331 Massachusetts Ave (at E New York St.), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Downtown Indianapolis · 77 tips and reviews

Alex R.Alex Rhea: If you love whiskey or bourbon order the Trinidad Sour off the menu. Best drink I've had in a while.

Reggie B.Reggie B: Great sliders. Old Fashioned was tasty

Gregory G.Gregory Goodin: Best cocktails in the city with a tremendous cheese menu.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

10. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

7.8
2340 Post Dr, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Raymond Park · 20 tips and reviews

Tanisha S.Tanisha S: Try the Grandma Sampler. It's not on the menu. Pancakes or french toast, eggs, hash brown casserole or apples, and bacon, sausage, and ham.

A. David V.A. David Vasquez: Little known fact - Country Boy breakfast comes with unlimited apples and hashbrown casserole...

Antione L.Antione Lowery: Staff has always been friendly and I've never had a bad plate. I like the old fashion store too.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

11. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

8.1
4350 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Edgewood · 29 tips and reviews

Angel L.Angel Lane: Grandma's breakfast: it's not on the menu, but they know it...it's pancakes, eggs, any side, bacon, sausage, and ham! Holy cow...it's a whole lotta food!

John L.John Lane: Sunday Chicken is a can't miss! Served only Sundays:( Add mashed potatoes, mac n' cheese, & biscuits.

Brian K.Brian Kukich: Awesome atmosphere the fire place is straight roarin. Oil laterns at each table. Great food to boot...

Culver's is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

12. Culver's

8.0
7105 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · Castleton · 28 tips and reviews

Morgan K.Morgan Kidd: Order the veggie burger, it's not on the menu.

Kara C.Kara Calloway Landis: Pomegranate Cooler is great on a hot day. It will definitely cool you down.

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Cheeseburger kid's meal is enough food for an adult AND includes a scoop of frozen custard w/ a topping!!

Culver's is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

13. Culver's

7.7
5020 W 71st St, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · Park 100 · 14 tips and reviews

Nick R.Nick Revell: It's not on the menu, but ask for the Bacon Bleu Burger.

Karen T.Karen Turnbough: The Wisconsin cheese curds are always epic, and so is the shrimp dinner!

Melissa D.Melissa D: The cheese curds are sooo good. Read more.

Bonefish Grill is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

14. Bonefish Grill

7.7
4501 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · 38 tips and reviews

JackJack: Don't like fish? Ask for some grilled chicken and fries (not on the menu). Good enough if you find yourself here but don't really like fish.

Mandy D.Mandy Dicks: I've had the majority of the menu items and the crabcakes and mussels are phenomenal . As always, the aug ratin potatoes were yummy and unique to other places.

Omar H.Omar Habayeb: The Swordfish with Pumpkin Ravioli is Outstanding!

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places with Off-Menu Items in Indianapolis.

15. Starbucks

1420 N Capitol Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Near Northside · 65 tips and reviews

Nadia M.Nadia Mahaney: Iced green tea soy latte =  not on the menu but its awesome!!

Nik L.Nik Layton: This store comes in at #2 on the Most friendly Indianapolis area Starbucks. Great drinks combine with great attitudes make this a great location to visit. Only second to the Greenwood Mall location.

TJTJ: I am a big fan of not being a douche. Order your drink and get out of my way.