Rocket Fizz is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

1. Rocket Fizz

8.9
52 Monument Cir, Indianapolis, IN
Candy Store · Downtown Indianapolis · 17 tips and reviews

Kassie J.Kassie Jahr: Lots of fun flavors of pop (PB&J, pumpkin pie), as well as nostalgic and interesting candies. A "must try" in downtown Indy!

Lydia B.Lydia Boyer: Really great place! Love it here!!!!

Jenna R.Jenna Renee: Best soda/candy selection in Indy!

Taylor's Bakery is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

2. Taylor's Bakery

8.7
6216 Allisonville Rd (at E 62nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · 23 tips and reviews

Greeneyed B.Greeneyed Beauty: My favorite treats at Taylor's Bakery are the Brownies with or with out nuts,the Pumpkin pie,and the glazed cake donuts. Yum Yum Yum 😋

April G.April Gregory: The best cakes and cupcakes! The cake is so good and the icing is even better. Full bakery including cookies, candies, and donuts. And try their homemade ice cream.

Jennifer C.Jennifer Coffey: Best birthday cakes, cookies and cupcakes in the city for birthdays!

Wheatleys is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

3. Wheatleys

7.9
8902 Southeastern Ave (Northeastern Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Wanamaker · 6 tips and reviews

Greg E.Greg Earle: I always enjoy the biscuits & gravy on the weekends.

Nora C.Nora Caguioa: The fish is awesome. The atmosphere comfortable. The carrot cake was the best I have had since my grandmas. Will definitely come again

Daniel G.Daniel Graves: Awesome as always! Great food at a good price! Gotta love supporting small businesses

Lulu's Coffee and Bakehouse is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

4. Lulu's Coffee and Bakehouse

8.5
2292 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · North Willow Farms · 14 tips and reviews

Thomas S.Thomas Stair: Great small privately owned coffee shop with great service. Coffee is great along with pastries

jennifer h.jennifer hill: My favorite drink is the rhubarb oolong iced tea. Tastes like summer! Also, the scones are simply amazing! Can't decide if the chocolate chip or peach vanilla is my favorite. I love Lulu's!

Brittany H.Brittany Hendrix: Best coffee shop in town! Everything is great but the scones and pie are a must try.

PEARings Frozen Yogurt & Beyond is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

5. PEARings Frozen Yogurt & Beyond

8.8
6 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Downtown Indianapolis · 28 tips and reviews

MarissaMarissa: The coffee is awesome and the Fro-yo flavors were delicious. Great combo! This place also seems to be Gluten-Free friendly.

Kimberly M.Kimberly McWhorter: Reasonably priced, great selection. Friendly service.

Kayleigh D.Kayleigh Dye: Salted Carmel Pretzel Frozen Yogurt is amazing. I am now determined to try all their flavors!

MCL Restaurant & Bakery is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

6. MCL Restaurant & Bakery

8.0
3630 S East St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

MCL Restaurant & BakeryMCL Restaurant & Bakery: Father's Day menu includes Prime Rib, Chopped Steak and Oven Roasted Salmon. Full menu available here: Read more.

Chris W.Chris Wellman: Food and service:-)

Barb I.Barb Irick-davis: To much $$ for what you get

MCL Restaurant & Bakery is one of The 7 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Indianapolis.

7. MCL Restaurant & Bakery

7.7
6002 Crawfordsville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Mike K.Mike Kivett: Country fried catfish, mac n cheese, n cornbread, and a fresh slice of pie to top it off with, hmmmm good...

Alex H.Alex Hoff: 90% of the people here think Foursquare is another word for hopscotch. Still the best homemade food around

DanielJames S.DanielJames Sedam: I'd say if it's your first time here, get the roast beef, served every Tuesday