Shapiro's Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

1. Shapiro's Delicatessen

8.7
808 S Meridian St (bt Sycamore & W McCarty Sts), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Downtown Indianapolis · 97 tips and reviews

Kenney M.Kenney Marlatt: You can't go wrong with the hot Pastrami Reuben. Killer cookies too.

TimTim: Reubens here are awesome.

Bill C.Bill Chamberlin: Great Reuben!

Fat Dan's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

2. Fat Dan's Deli

8.9
5410 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Meridian Kessler · 52 tips and reviews

Casey W.Casey Wiscons: A couple of my favs: Chicago dogs, wings, tots, any burger...love the Reuben with cole slaw (instead of kraut). Nice beer selection. Great location & outdoor seating.

SarahSarah: We must have gone when they were low on fries as it seemed like they skimped on our order. The Reuben was great, though.

Brent S.Brent Sutton: Best Reuben in town.

Illinois Street Food Emporium is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

3. Illinois Street Food Emporium

8.3
5550 N Illinois St (at 56th), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Butler - Tarkington · 18 tips and reviews

Wayne B.Wayne Burrell: Try the Philly Reuben with side chili! Very filling and tastes sooo good.

Carrie S.Carrie Savage-Zimmerman: Anything from their bakery, especially rugala! Sandwiches are fresh. And strawberry whipped frosting cake is to die for😛 A wonderful space when business meeting is needed.

Kelsey V.Kelsey V.: Chicken salad is fabulous & the croissants are to die for. Enjoy!

The Pawn Shop Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

4. The Pawn Shop Pub

8.3
2222 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN
Wine Bar · 25 tips and reviews

SarahSarah: The food is CHEAP - and it's delicious. The Reuben was awesome!

TerbowTerbow: Burgers and tenderloin are excellent. Friends say fish and chips are delicious.

sara m.sara mcguyer: Where else can you play cornhole in a parking lot, surrounded by stray pub kitties?

Union Jack Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

5. Union Jack Pub

8.3
924 Broad Ripple Ave (at Winthrop Av), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Broad Ripple · 55 tips and reviews

LeAnn B.LeAnn Bradshaw: Reubens are great!

Neda B.Neda Blessing: Bavarian pretzel sticks. Spinach & artichoke dip. White Chicken chili. Pizza. Chicago style Italian beef. Beer. With any of those, you can't go wrong here.

Chavonte M.Chavonte Martin: It was great pizza

Rick's Cafe Boatyard is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

6. Rick's Cafe Boatyard

8.8
4050 Dandy Trl (at W 38th St), Indianapolis, IN
Seafood Restaurant · Eagle Creek · 72 tips and reviews

J. Todd C.J. Todd Campi: Grouper reuben is outstanding!

Mike K.Mike Kivett: #1 place in Indy for a fun night out. Great food and drinks on the deck overlooking Eagle Creek.

Paula H.Paula Henry: Best Calamari I have ever had. Always a nice escape for a weekday lunch with views of Eagle Creek.

Good Morning Mama's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

7. Good Morning Mama's Cafe

8.9
1001 E 54th St (at Winthrop), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Meridian Kessler · 68 tips and reviews

Chris R.Chris Ruel: The meatball sandwich here is really something special. Also, the Reuben is one of, if the not the best, I have ever had.

Kayla J.Kayla Johnson: My favorite breakfast spot in Indy! Unpretentious, delicious food. Servers are always so nice and attentive here. Weekends are super busy so get there early, or late. Eggs in purgatory, coffe, mimosa!

Jonathan 👬 C.Jonathan 👬 Crockett: 1st time there; I was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere is great. I had a Hawaiian breakfast (name escapes me) it was fantastic; totally recommend!

McAlisters Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

8. McAlisters Deli

7.8
8840 Michigan Rd Ste 104 (at Vincennes Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · College Park · 53 tips and reviews

Aubrey P.Aubrey Phillips: Fantastic tortilla soup. Great to pair with the Reuben!

Paul T.Paul Thomas: Love the Pick Two, let's you pick your two favorite items for one low price $6.79

aaron d.aaron doster: The sweet tea is liquid crack.

Taylor's Pub at Nora is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

9. Taylor's Pub at Nora

7.7
1546 E 86th St (at Westfield Blvd.), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Nora - Far Northside · 8 tips and reviews

tobias s.tobias smith: Go see Grace on Sunday nights!

Robin G.Robin Gilmour: Good Luck Jodie on your new adventures in school. I will miss your smile and your A+ customer service. Robin G.

Shan P.Shan Parker: The breaded tenderloin and fries are awesome here!

Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

10. Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar

8.5
1325 W 86th St (at Ditch Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 16 tips and reviews

Leslie C.Leslie C: Great place to bring a group and have parties. Come early on Friday nights to get a good spot on the patio.

Leslie C.Leslie C: Ask for Miss Leslie for the best service of your life!

☠Bill C.☠Bill Cesavice☠: Tip well, the staff deserves it.

Culver's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

11. Culver's

8.7
4701 Kentucky Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Fast Food Restaurant · Valley Mills · 16 tips and reviews

Leigha E.Leigha Elliott: Love the soup and cheese curds!

Patty R.Patty Rork: Love it love it love it

Nicole S.Nicole Smith: Make sure to try the cheese curds! :-)

High Velocity is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

12. High Velocity

7.2
10 S West St (at W Maryland St), Indianapolis, IN
Sports Bar · Downtown Indianapolis · 50 tips and reviews

John P.John Pestka: Tons of TVs and a few tables where you have your own... perfect if you're watching something that's not being featured. The turkey Reuben is fantastic. Only complaint is the service - a bit slow.

AFLVAFLV: Delicious food in a convenient location. If you are pressed for time, we recommend calling in to-go food; it will get busy with our large conference and other events!

Javier G.Javier Garcia: Absolute best food I've ever had at a hotel. DO NOT pass them up!

BBI Sandwich Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

13. BBI Sandwich Bar

8.5
4825 Oakbrook Dr, Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Snacks - Guion Creek · 16 tips and reviews

Justin B.Justin Bishop: They now have gyros!! They are delicious!

Matt W.Matt Williams: I had the grilled chipotle chicken sandwich (half) and the chicken chile soup. Delicious!

Nathan B.Nathan B.: Everything is very good

Kona Jack's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

14. Kona Jack's

8.6
9419 N Meridian St (in Meridian North Shopping Center), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · Nora - Far Northside · 18 tips and reviews

ʇʇoɔs ɹ.ʇʇoɔs ɹolʎɐʇ: Very filling, very delicious - great service and atmosphere. I'll be back :)

Noah S.Noah Swint: Great food, fast service and great atmosphere. All food was made from scratch and the Romano Herb Bread with Macadamia Nut butter was superb.

Bob S.Bob St Claire: Very good selection of seafood, preparations conservative but delicious. A bit pricey, particularly for lunch.

The District Tap is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Indianapolis.

15. The District Tap

8.9
3720 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Sports Bar · Castleton · 27 tips and reviews

Liz F.Liz Faye: Really great beet veggie burger and Caesar salad! Beer is a little pricey but wine and cocktails are actually on the lower side of price-evens out. Service has been great every time we've been!

Dana P.Dana Parker: Really good Cajun Mac and Cheese! Lots of beers and good atmosphere

Elizabeth R.Elizabeth Renneisen: Amazing beer selection!