St. Elmo Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

1. St. Elmo Steak House

8.9
127 S Illinois St (btw Maryland St. & Georgia St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 196 tips and reviews

Big S.Big Sweatt: The Ribeye was AMAZING! ask for Jordan he is hands down the best waiter in the place

Luz Z.Luz ZS: The bone-in cowboy ribeye it's just perfectly delicious!! :9

Jennifer E.Jennifer Evans: Amazing dinner but come hungry! Loved the shrimp cocktail, ribeye steak and lobster mac n' cheese. Homemade apple pie was delicious!

Ruth's Chris Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

2. Ruth's Chris Steak House

8.9
2727 E 86th St (96th Street & Keystone), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Nora - Far Northside · 30 tips and reviews

Douglas K.Douglas Karr: Cowboy ribeye is an amazing steak. Read more.

Nieka D.Nieka D.: Petite Ribeye is to die for!

Cory B.Cory Brown: It's gonna cost you but it's worth it. Don't hold back and get a ribeye w/ the bone in, start off w/ lobster bisque, and finish the meal off with a slice of carrot cake, made right in the restaurant

The Columbia Club is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

3. The Columbia Club

8.1
121 Monument Cir (at N Meridian St), Indianapolis, IN
Hotel · Downtown Indianapolis · 18 tips and reviews

Jeff M.Jeff McQuary: The cowboy ribeye steak is the best steak in town.

Anastasia Y.Anastasia Yokosawa: Ribeye special on the "Devour Menu" was excellent. Take a pass on the caramel custard, though...it was awful. Chocolate martinis were awesome👍

Jeff M.Jeff McQuary: Check out the seafood cobb salad on the lunch/French Room menu. It's a half pound of seafood on mixed field greens and is healthful and delicious.

Texas Roadhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

4. Texas Roadhouse

7.7
1405 N. Shadeland Avenue (at E. 14th St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · East Gate · 30 tips and reviews

Will H.Will Hampton: Fort Worth Ribeye is Awesome!!!

Bro Jeff W.Bro Jeff Wolfe: If you like Ribs and Chix and your Spouse likes Sirloin and Ribeye, the get the ribeye and Chix dinner and Sirloin and Ribs Dinner, then swap when you get home - works great!!!

David L.David Leszcynski: Great food for great prices. Love getting mushrooms and onions on my steak.

Bynum's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

5. Bynum's Steakhouse

8.5
3850 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · 17 tips and reviews

Brian H.Brian Ho: Bone-in ribeye is amazing!

Charley c.Charley csChasMan: Everything is good here but the Prime cuts are the best. You will not be disappointed with your meal.

⚜️🇲🇶 .⚜️🇲🇶 🇱🇺🇮🇸: Beginning October 1,2013 you have to pay $2.00 per person if you bring in your own birthday cake.

Chipotle Mexican Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

6. Chipotle Mexican Grill

8.4
6 E Washington St Ste 100 (Washington and Meridian), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 10 tips and reviews

Nieka D.Nieka D.: Petite Ribeye is to die for

ᴡ N.ᴡ Norment: Burrito bowl. Only way to go.

John (.John (aka “PHATFoodFan”): Amazing service! They ran out of chicken for my salad bowl so I had to wait 15 mins for the fresh batch, they didn't charge me for the entire meal! Wasn't expecting that at all! First class business!

Eddie Merlot's is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

7. Eddie Merlot's

8.5
3645 E 96th St (at E Advisory Way), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Keystone at The Crossing · 20 tips and reviews

Michael L.Michael Lombardi: Best waitress: Kathy. Best entrée: Ribeye. Get dessert.

SarahSarah: Went for my birthday with my best friend with a Groupon type thing from Costco. I tried the New Orleans Mixed Grill, which was a treat. My friend got truffle fries as her side and they were delicious.

Eddie M.Eddie Merlot's: Our specialties are prime aged beef and seafood. Let us know how we can serve you!

LongHorn Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

8. LongHorn Steakhouse

7.3
5910 E 82nd St, Castleton, IN
Steakhouse · 24 tips and reviews

Tela P.Tela Perkins: The best ribeyes at a great price!!

Tony X.Tony Xerri: Didn't expect it to be that good, but always love to be proved wrong. Rib eye was on point and the cauliflower casserole was great. Eat here.

Tom H.Tom Haynes: Wow. Just wow. Porterhouse for two was amazing!

Ruth's Chris Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

9. Ruth's Chris Steak House

8.2
45 S Illinois St (Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 28 tips and reviews

Marcelo V.Marcelo Vieira: Cowboy ribeye

CC F.CC Ferguson: The porterhouse for two, gives you filet and strip, with the sizzling butter, yummy! Martin's presentation was fab. Definitely one of Indys best steaks!

Aaron B.Aaron Bailey: Kelli is the best!

Weber Grill Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

10. Weber Grill Restaurant

8.0
110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 91 tips and reviews

Lluis L.Lluis Lleonart: Choose the ribeye! Wowww!

Hannah S.Hannah Simpson: I had the ribeye, and my date had the brisket. All I can say is wow. Didn't need a knife to cut my steak. Literally the most tender, flavorful steak I've ever tasted. Not cheap, but WELL worth the $$

Ronda H.Ronda Heding-Pedley: We were a group of 5 and each of us were very satisfied with our meals. Our waitress was excellent and we will for sure visit this restaurant again when in Indianapolis. 2 thumbs up and 5 stars!

Indiana State Fairgrounds is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

11. Indiana State Fairgrounds

8.3
1202 E 38th St (btwn E Fall Creek Pkwy N Dr & Monon Trl), Indianapolis, IN
Fair · 113 tips and reviews

DeanDean: The 4 Fair Food Groups: 1. Fried Cheese, 2. Hoosier Ribeye, 3. Dairy Barn Milkshake, 4. Hoosier Producers Pork Chop... Desert: Deep-fried Snickers Bar.

Corey U.Corey Urick: Hoosier Beef Congress is this weekend. Come get a ribeye sandwich!

Chris R.Chris R: Came for the 2018 fair. Simply an outstanding state fair. Love the farm areas, fishing with the DNR, scavenger hunt, and OH MY the circus was worth the price of admission by itself this year!

Bubbaz Bar & Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

12. Bubbaz Bar & Grill

8.0
7799 South US 31, Indianapolis, IN
Bar · 20 tips and reviews

Douglas K.Douglas Karr: Start with the glazed bacon, and Bubba's Signature Ribeye is fantastic.

Glynn G.Glynn Geyer: Great food and beer. The bacon pizza is nice. They blend bacon onto their burgers too. Very unique.

Austin R.Austin Richmond: $2 Coors & Miller Lite pints, Everyday $2 wells, everyday

Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

13. Harry & Izzy's

9.0
153 S Illinois St (at W Georgia St in Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 109 tips and reviews

Dan C.Dan Carlascio: Pepper encrusted rib eye

Aaron B.Aaron Bradshaw: At $20, the three course lunch special is on point. I suggest the sliders, either fillet or shrimp po boy.

Lindsay N.Lindsay N.: Try their Fried Green Tomatoes... one of my favorites when I am in town!

Late Harvest Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

14. Late Harvest Kitchen

7.4
8605 River Crossing Blvd, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 26 tips and reviews

Stacy H.Stacy Hoehle: Excellent ribeye but dinner marred by poor service. Server constantly MIA, got snotty and noticeably rolled his eyes when we declined his appetizer sales pitch. :(

TimTim: Great wine, great service, great atmosphere, wonderful meal. Great wine... Did I say that?

Devon P.Devon P McGinnis: Order the sticky toffee pudding. It is life-changing.

Prime 47 - Indy's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Rib Eye Steak in Indianapolis.

15. Prime 47 - Indy's Steakhouse

7.4
47 S Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 13 tips and reviews

Tony P.Tony Petrucciani: Ketel dirty w blue cheese olives and ribeye is a can't lose proposition!

Douglass L.Douglass L.: Bread to the desert, this place is amazing w/ service that's par excellent! A perfectly designed atmosphere. Nothing here is by accident this was orchestrated. A great experience.

Douglass L.Douglass L.: This drink....is Amazing! Hints of basil and awesomeness. First on the menu of signature cocktails.