Local Burger is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

1. Local Burger

8.0
62 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Burger Joint · 23 tips and reviews

Anonie A.Anonie Anonnon: Amazing. The malts are great and the truffle oil fries are a must have. Burgers are also fantastic. They even burn the zip code on the buns :))

Diana C.Diana Caronti-Levine: Love the quinoa burger and truffle fries. We also had the red zone burger and pulled pork sandwich. Service was excellent

Keith P.Keith Palazzolo: Beer, Shakespeare and of course the Burgers.

Five Guys is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

2. Five Guys

8.5
601 Veteran's Highway, Hauppauge, NY
Burger Joint · 25 tips and reviews

Elizabeth P.Elizabeth Peter: I recommend getting the small burger! They don't tell you that the regular actually has two burgers on the bun. Plus you're going to want to save room for all those fries! Yum

Renee B.Renee Barnes: Burgers are good and toppings are free. You can top your burger with as many toppings as you please. The fries are delicious and are filled in cups and overflow into your brown bag. YUM!

Michael Z.Michael Z: Awesome burgers, you cant beat grilled onions. Seemingly endless fries, and rich shakes.

Five Points Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

3. Five Points Cafe

8.0
22-28 Railroad Ave, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 30 tips and reviews

Tom M.Tom Murray: Great burgers. Great live music on Thursday nights too.

S D.S Diaz: Ask about the special burger of the day.

Jennifer H.Jennifer Hoek: Want an excellent burger? Try 21 Main down the road. $9 beer & a burger! What's better then that!?

The Sayville Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

4. The Sayville Inn

8.1
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Two things you can count on being delicious....the burgers, and anything on the specials board.

Joanne B.Joanne Bartolomeo: I agree,hamburgers are awesome...love their blackboard specials...always something great!

Djalmo M.Djalmo Mourato: Only take cash, check, or amex. Other than that, Hamburgers were great. The fries were amazing.

Blackbirds' Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

5. Blackbirds' Grille

8.7
553 Old Montauk Hwy, Sayville, NY
Bar · 18 tips and reviews

Ivanka S.Ivanka Sorich: Amazing burgers and grilled vegetable salad!

Tara P.Tara Perez: Burgers are phenomenal!! Super friendly staff too!

Diana C.Diana Clarke: Hidden gem of a restaurant in the middle of nowhere. A+!

Out of the Park Burgers is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

6. Out of the Park Burgers

7.4
101 S Research Pl (Carleton Ave), Central Islip, NY
Burger Joint · 18 tips and reviews

Daniel M.Daniel Maksym: The change to "steak burgers" has had a negative impact on the flavor. They really should change to a custom, multi-cut, grind like Shake Shack, for example.

Jeanette M.Jeanette Michael: Didnt bring my curbside order out to me, forgot my shake, added tomato when I didnt want it, "buffalo" tenders were awful, burger is greasy, phone guy definitely was not trained at all before starting

JonJon: Love this place, I'm here all the time and always had a good experience. Get the Chipotle Bacon Burger, it's amazing!

Peter Pan Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

7. Peter Pan Diner

7.9
854 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
Diner · 31 tips and reviews

Charlie Y.Charlie Y: best gyro in the world and the jumbo burgers is always amazing

Charlie Y.Charlie Y: jumbo burger is always awesome

Courtenay B.Courtenay B💋: The greek salad and wrap are the best! Love the jumbo burgers. Curly fries are awesome. Cole slaw is yummy. Love the gyros. They give you plenty of food. Ugh food is just so tasty!

Off the Block Gourmet Kitchen & Meats is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

8. Off the Block Gourmet Kitchen & Meats

8.4
501 Main St, Islip, NY
Butcher · 10 tips and reviews

DreXousPriMeDreXousPriMe: Smokehouse burger... nuff said

Nick G.Nick Giassakis: Amazing burgers. The meat taste so fresh. And the fries remind me of thashers fries I had in ocean city Maryland.

Sheila 🌊☀️ M.Sheila 🌊☀️ M: I had the roasted Cajun chicken sandwich & tried the 16hr brisket... Wow. So good 😍

Crickets is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

9. Crickets

7.8
98 Main St, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Tom M.Tom Murray: Lunch special on burgers. $3.95 if you sit at the bar and buy a beer. Can't be beat.

Tattooed J.Tattooed Jasiu: Love the burger special! Can't beat it.

UnicornFoodie ..UnicornFoodie .: The burger and fries

Sea Levels is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

10. Sea Levels

8.1
391 N Windsor Ave (orinoco), Brightwaters, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Craig Peter LowCraig Peter Low: Best burgers in the WORLD!

Gary N.Gary N: Great burger! Drinks were a little expensive! But cool atmosphere and nice people.

Paul D.Paul Dua: Great people, nice patio in the back. The perfect place to eat and hang out. Stop by, best place in town

Karvers Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

11. Karvers Grille

8.2
480-1 Patchogue Holbrook Rd, Holbrook, NY
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Chris W.Chris Woodward: Wings are perfection and the bacon Cheeseburger is insane.

Albert R.Albert Restaino: Mac & Cheese, Steak, Burgers, Appetizers

James P.James P: Great Food, Great Value, Great Ambience! We loved it. A Must Try! We will be back.

Dunkin' is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

12. Dunkin'

7.7
4541 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia, NY
Donut Shop · 5 tips and reviews

Frank H.Frank Hohmann: There still very friendly and quick with a response when I ordered 2 double cheese burgers and curly spicy french fries. ..lol

Leena H.Leena Hnetinka: Friendly Staff & Fast service, I ordered coffee and cheese burger :-)

Angela L.Angela Luongo: This Dunkin Donuts has the friendliest staff of all. Love those guys!

Henleys Village Tavern is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

13. Henleys Village Tavern

8.3
184 Orinoco Dr, Brightwaters, NY
American Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

John D.John Dempsey: Modern take on the pub menu. Loved the kale Ceasar with chicken and the house burger with excellent fries. Only downside is that the sparse design makes the room deafeningly loud.

Christina F.Christina Fassnacht: Excellent food , service and atmosphere. Not to mention wine list. Definitely will be back again. If you haven’t tried this place for lunch, you must, everything was delicious !

Bonnie G.Bonnie Georgi: The beer battered meatballs are amazing. Beef short rib is delicious. Great atmosphere. Nice staff. Give it a try.

Tula Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

14. Tula Kitchen

8.9
41 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Kissel M.Kissel Mandujano: The lentil burger is so good!

Mike B.Mike Berrios: Very good food. I liked the chicken Reuben and the roasted potatoes. The dessert is really good also.

Michelle d.Michelle dammit: Great bar!

Parlor House Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Burgers in Islip.

15. Parlor House Grill

8.3
298 W Main St (Sunset Dr.), Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

C M.C M: Turkey burger with fries is a great option for lunch here.

Joanne C.Joanne Carlos: Good food! Had the roast beef Au jus sandwich with fries, hit the spot!

Michael Z.Michael Z: French dip, Crab cakes