Mulberry Street is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

1. Mulberry Street

8.7
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Raffaela S.Raffaela Scaffa: Food is amazing. Great dishes. Great prices.

Andra M.Andra Matera: All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.

Bill Mary Seymour M.Bill Mary Seymour Martini: Alfredo sauce :-)

White Cap Fish is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

2. White Cap Fish

8.6
130 Main St, Islip, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Jake C.Jake Cohen: Great old school dockside fish joint and market. Raw or cooked they have it.

Alexandra M.Alexandra Martignette: Long Island chowder is to die for

Ulonda J.Ulonda Jemmott: The fried soft shell crab sandwich is absolutely amazing!

Pie At Salvatore's is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

3. Pie At Salvatore's

8.2
120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

April S.April Scarduzio: I've had a lot of pizza and this is by far the best! All their other food is great as well.

Steve F.Steve Fog: Best pizza in Bay Shore.

GinaGina: The filleto is worth the 30 minute drive to get here from our house. Not to mention the pizza is the best I've ever had.

Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

4. Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store

8.1
10 W Main St (at 4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Dustin R.Dustin Ress: Olive oil is the best around. Dry aged steaks are to die for!!!

Erin S.Erin Shaw: The eggplant lasagna is delicious!

P. D.P. D.: As good an Italian grocery and deli as you'll find in New York City. Tucked into Bay Shore without nearly the noteriety it deserves. Mozzarella at the register is warm to the touch; that's how fresh!

Mamma Lombardi's is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

5. Mamma Lombardi's

8.1
877 Main St, Holbrook, NY
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

RoseAnne F.RoseAnne Foxx: This a great local Italian restaurant with A pizza restaurant attached. Which is 2nd to Gino's as far as pizza. BUT...a good wine list with some great California wines..attentive staff. Ask for Dan.

Lou C.Lou Capezza: Just smelling the food makes me full.

Megan S.Megan Splain: Amazing hot food bar... Whole wheat pasta is yummy! Best eggplant parm around!

Mamas Italian Restaurant Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

6. Mamas Italian Restaurant Pizza

7.8
1352 Montauk Hwy, Islip Terrace, NY
Italian Restaurant · 1 tip

Chris G.Chris Garfield: Great gluten free menu!

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

7. Tony's Pizza & Restaurant

7.6
161 Clarke St, Brentwood, NY
Pizzeria · 12 tips and reviews

Edwin T.Edwin Tardy: Margarita Pizza - unquestionably Delicious, and can't forget desert Canoli

RR: Best pizza in Brentwood!

Eye M.Eye Muffler: The f'ing best. Old school brentwood all the way.

Butera's Restaurant Of Sayville is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

8. Butera's Restaurant Of Sayville

7.7
100 S Main St (at Collins Ave.), Sayville, NY
Italian Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Huge family style portions of delicious food!

James P.James Picon: They should have a coupon for check in!!!!

Vincent F.Vincent Fuori: Excellent food, great ambiance, and try the Limencello Shrimp!

Albert's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

9. Albert's Pizza

7.6
676 Motor Pkwy Ste E, Hauppauge, NY
Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Eye M.Eye Muffler: Best garlic knots and you get one free with your slice if dining in.

MattMatt: Worst pizza of all time.

Eye M.Eye Muffler: This place has changed for the better 100% with this staff in comparson to two years ago. Great food. They are killing it.

Bono's pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

10. Bono's pizza

7.6
1397 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Pizzeria · 5 tips and reviews

Escape C.Escape Cardona: Bono's is a staple in the community. The pizza is reliable and always taste great. The crunchy bottom crust always makes me happy.

Sarina G.Sarina Giorgio: Love the pizza here

Joe M.Joe Maniscalco: Best regular slices ever!

Peter Pan Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

11. Peter Pan Diner

7.9
854 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
Diner · 31 tips and reviews

Jessica P.Jessica Palladino: Feta cheese & tomato omelette is so good!

Tim B.Tim B: Ask for Marsha....

Courtenay B.Courtenay B💋: The greek salad and wrap are the best! Love the jumbo burgers. Curly fries are awesome. Cole slaw is yummy. Love the gyros. They give you plenty of food. Ugh food is just so tasty!

New Idle Hour Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

12. New Idle Hour Deli

7.5
1500 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY
Deli · 6 tips and reviews

Mark H.Mark Heyert: Homemade Baked goods! The homemade coffee cake and brownies are wonderful! There are also great homemade desserts including Rice pudding. The hot entrées are freshly prepared. Highly recommended!

SeanSean: There egg sandwiches are the best in the area

John P.John P: Get the half and halfs!!

Carlo's Pizza Oven is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

13. Carlo's Pizza Oven

7.4
23 Patchogue-Holbrook Rd, Holbrook, NY
Pizzeria · 6 tips and reviews

Kellei A.Kellei Ammirati Burke: Best Italian food ! Great owners and staff! Always use for our catering events !

Ryan A.Ryan Arnold Nauert: Fantastic food and the owners are super nice guys. Been eating here for over 20 years

AlanAlan: Grate food

Vinny's Mulberry Street Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

14. Vinny's Mulberry Street Pizza

7.1
42 W Main St, East Islip, NY
Pizzeria · 13 tips and reviews

Gary N.Gary N: Very good pizza! Chicken Parm pizza was very good. And the regular slice was perfect!

Nicole S.Nicole S: The veggie pie is delicious. Be prepared to wait in line.

Liz K.Liz Karstens: Food is good, prices are good, service is very slow during lunch (except for the busboy, he was great and efficient).

Surf's Out is one of The 15 Best Places for Clam Sauce in Islip.

15. Surf's Out

7.4
1 Bay Walk, Kismet, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 12 tips and reviews

Kayleigh H.Kayleigh Harrington: The tuna sushi bowl is a must. Fresh and satisfying lunch before a day on the beach.

Ryan D.Ryan Drushel: Mike makes a great vodka mojito! Ask him for it!

James F.James Ferguson: Compared to NYC, the food is more expensive, but that's the same all over the island