Fried zucchini with scordalia dip is awesome! I can have that with side gyro as a meal :)
Very good authentic Greek. Gyro is the best outside NYC!
Really good gyros!
They have a great lunch and dinner menu. Most come with salad and bread. Food is reasonably priced. Staff is great!
All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.
Alfredo sauce :-)
Everything we had was really good ,the nachos is excellent and big
White bean chili and that white raspberry cheesecake. Yes!
Food was right on point as usual but it's the first time I dined in house and I hope tonight's service isn't indicative of the overall staff. They somehow forgot about us and brought wrong entree.
Best fish store around. Shrimp platters are great for any occasion & super nice staff
Like a good food steal? We featured The Fish Store as one of the 10 best places to get a meal for $10 or less on Long Island! Read more.
They always have the best salmon!
Veal tenderloin is excellent and very large portions. Great dinner.
Newsday #1 pick for New American on LI. Try Cinnamon donuts with dulce de leche cream and a Mexican hot Chocolate
Striped bass was amazing! Excellent service
Cocktail sauce is fantastic, grilled chicken sandwich pretty good too. Staff very friendly!
Hidden gem of a restaurant in the middle of nowhere. A+!
Get the gator bites! You will not be disappointed!!
They have a fabulous Denver omelet with a side of home fries. Everything I've purchased has been delicious. I recommend them for breakfast or lunch. You can eat in or take out.
Good food great prices.
Ok good. Beyond over priced. Go sparingly. When just in that mood go overpriced food
It's one of the places in west Islip that make the best egg sandwiches!!!
The egg sandwiches are AMAZING. The line is usually to the door but it's sooooo worth the wait!
Chai is great! However, you may need a bathroom close by part of the day. Worth it!
Bread bowl chicken noodle soup is awesome
Huge family style portions of delicious food!
They should have a coupon for check in!!!!
Excellent food, great ambiance, and try the Limencello Shrimp!
Great food pizza, calamari, pasta's are great
Just smelling the food makes me full.
Amazing hot food bar... Whole wheat pasta is yummy! Best eggplant parm around!
Tuna tartar, smoked salmon and avocado salad and Mediterranean soup was outstanding. One of the best dirty martinis I've had in a while.
Good for light dinner or drinks on the deck..wouldn't bring the kids for dinner.
I far the Bedell Chardonnay
Try the Lentil Patty, and the Quinoa salad...Delicious!
Sandwich is overpriced, but everything else there seems great.
Salmon is yummy. Pre-made green salads are great.
Very good diner. The staff is friendly but brash. It is a bit pricey but you do get a good meal. The onion rings are the best anywhere.
BEST DINER ON LONG ISLAND
The guy throws cookies at you
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA