Mulberry Street is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

1. Mulberry Street

8.7
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Steven C.Steven C: They have a great lunch and dinner menu. Most come with salad and bread. Food is reasonably priced. Staff is great!

Andra M.Andra Matera: All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.

Bill Mary Seymour M.Bill Mary Seymour Martini: Alfredo sauce :-)

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

2. The Cheesecake Factory

8.5
1701 Sunrise Hwy Westfield South Shore, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Arnold M.Arnold Marmol: Everything we had was really good ,the nachos is excellent and big

Daniel W.Daniel W: White bean chili and that white raspberry cheesecake. Yes!

john r.john rossiello: Food was right on point as usual but it's the first time I dined in house and I hope tonight's service isn't indicative of the overall staff. They somehow forgot about us and brought wrong entree.

Villa Lombardi's is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

3. Villa Lombardi's

8.1
877 Old Patchogue - Holbrook Rd, Holbrook, NY
Italian Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Michael M.Michael Meyer: Excellent food and service! The staff is warm and personable!

Phil K.Phil Kohler: Went here for a Gatsby themed New Years Eve party that was NOT Gatsby themed. Food and staff were excellent. Music was so loud you couldn't hear someone right next to you.

Larry K.Larry Khulmann: #Weddings are fantastic at Villa Lombardi. I come here a few times a year and always #ride here with Aaron #Limousines Ltd at 516-236-5735 or www.limo.li

The Lake House is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

4. The Lake House

8.2
240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Mark A.Mark Agovino: Veal tenderloin is excellent and very large portions. Great dinner.

Michelle C.Michelle C.: Newsday #1 pick for New American on LI. Try Cinnamon donuts with dulce de leche cream and a Mexican hot Chocolate

Amy S.Amy Sigillo: Striped bass was amazing! Excellent service

Mamas Italian Restaurant Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

5. Mamas Italian Restaurant Pizza

7.8
1352 Montauk Hwy, Islip Terrace, NY
Italian Restaurant · 1 tip

Chris G.Chris Garfield: Great gluten free menu!

Da Noi Italian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

6. Da Noi Italian Restaurant

7.8
301 Main St (N. Ocean Ave), Islip, NY
Italian Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

Marco N.Marco Navarra: Finally found a great Long Island Italian! Great Buratta appetizer, Veal Valdosta entree and apple tart desert. Great service too. Finally a place to look forward to dining "By Us."

RickRick: You can't miss! Everything on the menu is fantastic. If you don't see it ask. They are very accompanying!

Robert S.Robert S: Stuffed peppers, yes!

Mamma Lombardi's is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

7. Mamma Lombardi's

8.1
877 Main St, Holbrook, NY
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

PETER B.PETER BONNA: Great food pizza, calamari, pasta's are great

Lou C.Lou Capezza: Just smelling the food makes me full.

Megan S.Megan Splain: Amazing hot food bar... Whole wheat pasta is yummy! Best eggplant parm around!

fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

8. fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro

7.9
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 28 tips and reviews

carolyn b.carolyn bos: Tuna tartar, smoked salmon and avocado salad and Mediterranean soup was outstanding. One of the best dirty martinis I've had in a while.

Michele R.Michele Ryan: Good for light dinner or drinks on the deck..wouldn't bring the kids for dinner.

Christina F.Christina Fassnacht: I far the Bedell Chardonnay

The Sayville Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

9. The Sayville Inn

8.0
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Joanne B.Joanne Bartolomeo: I agree,hamburgers are awesome...love their blackboard specials...always something great!

KeriKeri: Great baja tacos!

🎃Sam M.🎃Sam Murphy🎃: My dads an awesome chef here :)

Albert's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

10. Albert's Pizza

7.6
676 Motor Pkwy Ste E, Hauppauge, NY
Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Eye M.Eye Muffler: Best garlic knots and you get one free with your slice if dining in.

MattMatt: Worst pizza of all time.

Eye M.Eye Muffler: This place has changed for the better 100% with this staff in comparson to two years ago. Great food. They are killing it.

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

11. Tony's Pizza & Restaurant

7.6
161 Clarke St, Brentwood, NY
Pizzeria · 12 tips and reviews

Edwin T.Edwin Tardy: Margarita Pizza - unquestionably Delicious, and can't forget desert Canoli

RR: Best pizza in Brentwood!

Eye M.Eye Muffler: The f'ing best. Old school brentwood all the way.

New Idle Hour Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

12. New Idle Hour Deli

7.5
1500 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY
Deli · 6 tips and reviews

Mark H.Mark Heyert: Homemade Baked goods! The homemade coffee cake and brownies are wonderful! There are also great homemade desserts including Rice pudding. The hot entrées are freshly prepared. Highly recommended!

SeanSean: There egg sandwiches are the best in the area

John P.John P: Get the half and halfs!!

Land's End is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

13. Land's End

7.4
80 Browns River Rd, Sayville, NY
Event Space · 4 tips and reviews

Ivelysse P.Ivelysse P: All you can eat Lobster Dinner on Wednesday's in the summer is amazing! Great way to go back to this fabulous place where we got married!

Robert B.Robert Bachman: So so I wasn't impressed with the meal

AJ I.AJ Ingoglia: Don't ever fill up a soda on your own....you will get yelled at....

Joe's Pasta & Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

14. Joe's Pasta & Pizza

7.4
73 Howells Rd (at Fifth Avenue), Bay Shore, NY
Pizzeria · 12 tips and reviews

C.F. M.C.F. Monaghan: Just the best! Fresh homemade pastas and delicious pizza. Good choice for dining too!

Cheryl E.Cheryl Echevarria: They have the best pizza and homemade Italian cheesecake

Luis A.Luis Alicea: Chicken Night every Thursday religiously. Thirteen dollars for bread and garlic knots, salad, entree of chicken and pasta, coffee or tea, and dessert.

Sempre Vivolo is one of The 15 Best Places for Fettuccine in Islip.

15. Sempre Vivolo

7.0
696 Motor Pkwy, Suffolk County, NY
Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Krisi P.Krisi P: Authentic Italian food. Fabulous old school Italian feel. Extensive menu wonderfully prepared and presented. The specials are usually fantastic.

Ken G.Ken Greenberg: Asparagus au gratin appetizer is superb - as is most food here.

Ilknur ✨Ilknur ✨: Very elegant service, professional staff and real Italian cuisine, must go!