Onsen Sushi and Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

1. Onsen Sushi and Restaurant

9.1
597 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY
Sushi Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Arnold B.Arnold Bailing: Try the Nabe yaki udon, California rolls and Tempura banana. Deifinitely coming back!

Kristy H.Kristy Homan: One of the BEST hidden sushi gems on Long Island!

Maria S.Maria Simonetti: Try the Tuna Four Ways - #sushi #foodie

Crickets is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

2. Crickets

8.0
98 Main St, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

ChrisChris: I was very surprised by the food here. It was quite tasty and affordable. Try the Liver and Onions. Just try it. Very good

Alicia D.Alicia D: Try theFrench Onion Soup! It's the best around!

Alex A.Alex Aji: Absolutely delicious food! Low price! You can't go wrong! Nicest staff as well!

Cafe Joelle is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

3. Cafe Joelle

7.8
25 Main St, Sayville, NY
Café · 11 tips and reviews

Chris P.Chris Pinola: The calamari appetizer with sesame seeds and General Tso's sauce is incredibly unique and very good.

Long Island Restaurant WeekLong Island Restaurant Week: The First Spring Long Island Restaurant Week 2011 is April 3 -10. Come here to enjoy a 3-course prix fixe for $24.95. See other participants or make a reservation at www.longislandrestaurantweek.com.

DAVIDO A.DAVIDO ANYHONY: Ordered the CHEESE TORTELLINI, it was exceptionally very good, coming from an Italian boy. Highly Recommend.

The Sayville Inn is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

4. The Sayville Inn

8.0
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Two things you can count on being delicious....the burgers, and anything on the specials board.

KeriKeri: Great baja tacos!

🎃Sam M.🎃Sam Murphy🎃: My dads an awesome chef here :)

Aji 53 is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

5. Aji 53

8.5
53 E Main St (at 4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Japanese Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

Paul f.Paul federico: The green river roll is amazing!

Alexandra M.Alexandra Martignette: <3 crispy duck salad

Natalie S.Natalie S: Paradise Roll is amazing!

La Tavola is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

6. La Tavola

8.2
183 W Main St (Greeley Ave.), Sayville, NY
Italian Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Tara P.Tara Perez: Food is amazing especially the short ribs. Staff is super sweet and very accommodating. Love the atmosphere and very thing else. I highly recommend it.

Matt M.Matt Martin: The Mussels are to die for!!!

Michele F.Michele Falcone: Monday through Friday at the bar: happy hour + $5 appetizers.

Kingston's Clam Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

7. Kingston's Clam Bar

7.7
130 Atlantic Ave (Montauk Hwy.), West Sayville, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Dave L.Dave Lowry: Got to sit outside when you're there!

Denise F.Denise Federico: Great food

Ryan D.Ryan D: Clam strips!

Mitsui Japanese Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

8. Mitsui Japanese Restaurant

7.6
1 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Sushi Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Chris N.Chris Nolte: Dinardo Roll is one of there best. If your on a budget the Maki Combo is pretty awesome. I recommend the Tuna Carpaccio Roll

Adrian F.Adrian Frylink: Sushi special fills me up all the time 8-)

Kevin S.Kevin Saravia: Try the Green Tea Fried Ice Cream, it's awesome.

Peter Pan Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

9. Peter Pan Diner

8.0
854 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
Diner · 31 tips and reviews

Jessica P.Jessica Palladino: Burgers are delicious, get the deluxe because the cole slaw is the best!

Tim B.Tim B: Ask for Marsha....

Courtenay B.Courtenay B💋: The greek salad and wrap are the best! Love the jumbo burgers. Curly fries are awesome. Cole slaw is yummy. Love the gyros. They give you plenty of food. Ugh food is just so tasty!

Captain Bill's is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

10. Captain Bill's

7.5
122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Wayne S.Wayne Smith: Buffet breakfasts, lunches and dinners have all been good.

Tim O.Tim ORourke: Excellent clams and oysters

Michelle F.Michelle F: Ok so the dinner was delicious, the appetizers were small but expensive. Entrees are great and plentiful. But they had a new desert guy and the deserts were really cold!!!!

Applebee's Grill + Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

11. Applebee's Grill + Bar

7.9
2550 Sunrise Hwy (btwn Irish Ln. & Wilson Blvd.), East Islip, NY
American Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Jessica P.Jessica Palladino: Try the Fireball Whiskey Lemonade!

TaraTara: Great food get the 2 for 20 u get a free appetizer too I recommend the fiesta lime chicken and the boneless buffalo wings they are awesomeeee 

Blayne H.Blayne Haberkorn: Yummy 2frs!

J&R's Steakhouse is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

12. J&R's Steakhouse

7.3
116 Main St, Islip, NY
Steakhouse · 13 tips and reviews

Dawn   :o) D.Dawn :o) DamnYourNosey!: The stuffed flounder was pretty good. I enjoyed their salad also. But the cheesecake was awesome.

Lisa H.Lisa Holmes Nasta: The steak cuts and food are a heck of a lot better at Texas Roadhouse for the same prices.

Douglas H.Douglas Hefter: Marinate your steak

TJ Finley's is one of The 13 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Islip.

13. TJ Finley's

7.2
42 E Main St (at 3rd Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Beer Garden · 35 tips and reviews

Christine C.Christine Coolieo: Awesome beer list, sometimes a little too hoppy or strong, but delicious nonetheless.

Zac P.Zac Papendick: Join the beer club!

Robert E.Robert Elrose: This place is great! The staff knows beer & will help you find a new favorite if you're willing to try something new. Definitely join the Beer Club, it's 100 different servings of AWESOME!!!