Mamas Italian Restaurant Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

1. Mamas Italian Restaurant Pizza

7.8
1352 Montauk Hwy, Islip Terrace, NY
Italian Restaurant · 1 tip

Chris G.Chris Garfield: Great gluten free menu!

Mamma Lombardi's is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

2. Mamma Lombardi's

8.1
877 Main St, Holbrook, NY
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

PETER B.PETER BONNA: Great food pizza, calamari, pasta's are great

Lou C.Lou Capezza: Just smelling the food makes me full.

Megan S.Megan Splain: Amazing hot food bar... Whole wheat pasta is yummy! Best eggplant parm around!

Carvel Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

3. Carvel Ice Cream

8.6
579 Veterans Hwy, Hauppauge, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 2 tips and reviews

AnnMarie N.AnnMarie Neubauer: The chocolate thick shake floats are the best!

Christopher B.Christopher Beattie: Try the deluxe shake; like "cookies n cream"

Mulberry Street is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

4. Mulberry Street

8.7
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Steven C.Steven C: They have a great lunch and dinner menu. Most come with salad and bread. Food is reasonably priced. Staff is great!

Andra M.Andra Matera: All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.

Bill Mary Seymour M.Bill Mary Seymour Martini: Alfredo sauce :-)

Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

5. Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

8.7
75 Howells Rd (Fifth Avenue), Bay Shore, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 10 tips and reviews

Anna O.Anna Osias Stellman: Awesome interior, awesome service, awesome ice cream!!

MikeylitoMikeylito: Go here and enjoy old-time sweet shop favorites and the freshest ice cream in the Great South Bay area.

Patrick N.Patrick Noack: Doped, foursquare is a mobile app. If you are going to offer check in promos then the mobile screen IS the coupon. Don't bother with this

Off the Block Gourmet Kitchen & Meats is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

6. Off the Block Gourmet Kitchen & Meats

8.4
501 Main St, Islip, NY
Butcher · 10 tips and reviews

Sheila 🌊☀️ M.Sheila 🌊☀️ M: I had the roasted Cajun chicken sandwich & tried the 16hr brisket... Wow. So good 😍

Brian M.Brian Medeiros: Come for brunch or GTFO. Special was cheddar pancakes with fried chicken in Sriracha maple syrup. Omnonon

Igal G.Igal Ghitelman: Amazing steaks

The Lake House is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

7. The Lake House

8.2
240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Mark A.Mark Agovino: Veal tenderloin is excellent and very large portions. Great dinner.

Michelle C.Michelle C.: Newsday #1 pick for New American on LI. Try Cinnamon donuts with dulce de leche cream and a Mexican hot Chocolate

Amy S.Amy Sigillo: Striped bass was amazing! Excellent service

Bay Shore Bean Coffee House is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

8. Bay Shore Bean Coffee House

7.2
47 E Main St (3rd Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Coffee Shop · 12 tips and reviews

John D.John Daskalakis: Coconut and Almond milks are their dairy free options and most of their sweets are gluten free and few dairy free.

Travis B.Travis Buonocore: Very nice, clean, cozy interior. Wait staff very helpful. And the cappuccino was excellent; exactly what I needed!

John D.John Daskalakis: Two words, açai bowl!!!

The Snapper Inn is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

9. The Snapper Inn

8.5
500 Shore Dr, Oakdale, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

Megan E.Megan Elizabeth: It’s such a fun, friendly local place with an old school east coast vibe that was incredibly charming. I had the snapper salad with the blackened salmon on top and it was delic.

Jim S.Jim S: Very attentive and professional staff with just the right touch of humor.

Priscilla D.Priscilla DiVisconti Anderson: Lobster rolls were fantastic and so was the lobster platter. Everything we had was delicious. We will be back again.

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

10. Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

8.7
70 E Main St (Shore Lane), Bay Shore, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 28 tips and reviews

Anthony T.Anthony Tartaglia: Amazing food & cocktails. Staff is great and their Sunday brunch has live music !

Anthony T.Anthony Tartaglia: Sunday brunch every week with a great menu and $5 bloody Mary's and mimosas !

Anthony T.Anthony Tartaglia: Hands down the best mezcal & tequila selection on Long Island

Five Guys is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

11. Five Guys

8.5
601 Veteran's Highway, Hauppauge, NY
Burger Joint · 25 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Awesome burgers, you cant beat grilled onions. Seemingly endless fries, and rich shakes.

Emely V.Emely Vargas: Oh my goodness. Oh my dayum. This is how bacon is supposed to be. The fries, they blend so perfectly.

DannyDanny: Try the Cajun fries!!

Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

12. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

8.0
335 E Main St, East Islip, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Jennifer R.Jennifer Reilly: Love the fish taco! Has a little wasabi sauce on it. So good!

TaraTara: Love this place......best food ever when you go get the penne with chicken, spinach, and mozzerella in a pink cream sauce it's like eating heaven : D

Alexandra M.Alexandra Mendes: Delicious food and reasonably priced, also really fun drink menu!

Cornucopia Natural Foods is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

13. Cornucopia Natural Foods

7.7
39 N Main St, Sayville, NY
Grocery Store · 11 tips and reviews

Jonathan L.Jonathan Lien: Try the Lentil Patty, and the Quinoa salad...Delicious!

Tom M.Tom Murray: Sandwich is overpriced, but everything else there seems great.

Ian W.Ian Wilder: Salmon is yummy. Pre-made green salads are great.

The Sayville Inn is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

14. The Sayville Inn

8.0
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Joanne B.Joanne Bartolomeo: I agree,hamburgers are awesome...love their blackboard specials...always something great!

KeriKeri: Great baja tacos!

🎃Sam M.🎃Sam Murphy🎃: My dads an awesome chef here :)

Albert's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places with Gluten-Free Food in Islip.

15. Albert's Pizza

7.6
676 Motor Pkwy Ste E, Hauppauge, NY
Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Eye M.Eye Muffler: Best garlic knots and you get one free with your slice if dining in.

MattMatt: Worst pizza of all time.

Eye M.Eye Muffler: This place has changed for the better 100% with this staff in comparson to two years ago. Great food. They are killing it.