Verde Kitchen & Cocktails is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

1. Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

8.7
70 E Main St (Shore Lane), Bay Shore, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 28 tips and reviews

Anthony T.Anthony Tartaglia: Awesome craft cocktails and margaritas and the best authentic mexican food around. The restaurant is beautiful and has a live greenhouse as a dining room where they grow their own herbs and peppers !

Verde Kitchen & CocktailsVerde Kitchen & Cocktails: Happy Hour Monday-Friday 3pm-7pm$5 Margaritas & Mixed Drinks$4 Beers, $2 Off all Wine1/2 Price Tacos & Quesadillas

Anthony T.Anthony Tartaglia: The best tacos and happy hour around ! Margaritas are unreal

Pico Tequila Grill is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

2. Pico Tequila Grill

7.6
19 W Main St (4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Caitlin A.Caitlin Arbeiter: They play shaggy and daddy yankee here. The Pineapple Margarita makes up for it...

Sara G.Sara Guzzone: Best fish and shrimp tacos I've ever had - the cilantro ranch dressing was amazing and my watermelon margarita was prefect!

Avinash A.Avinash Arora: The margaritas are AMAZING, and the tacos are among the best I've had. Love the coconut Margarita and habanero guacamole

Chipotle Mexican Grill is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

3. Chipotle Mexican Grill

8.1
694 Motor Pkwy Ste 1 (Motor Parkway & Kennedy Drive), Hauppauge, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Daniel G.Daniel Guido: Have Wilson the Mayor prepare your Margarita.

Natalie S.Natalie S: Long ass line...

Giulianna Z.Giulianna Zumbo: Ew such bad customer service

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

4. The Cheesecake Factory

8.5
1701 Sunrise Hwy Westfield South Shore, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Arnold M.Arnold Marmol: Everything we had was really good ,the nachos is excellent and big

Daniel W.Daniel W: White bean chili and that white raspberry cheesecake. Yes!

john r.john rossiello: Food was right on point as usual but it's the first time I dined in house and I hope tonight's service isn't indicative of the overall staff. They somehow forgot about us and brought wrong entree.

Changing Times is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

5. Changing Times

7.6
29 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Sports Bar · 20 tips and reviews

Tiffany R.Tiffany Rivera: Frozen strawberry margarita!

Greg H.Greg Hoffman: Awesome wings with homemade blue cheese

SamanthaSamantha: Thursday is ladies night !!! $2 mix drinks and $2 buds -- the perks of having a vagina...

Besito Mexican Restaurant is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

6. Besito Mexican Restaurant

8.2
399 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Jennifer R.Jennifer Reilly: I love this place! Great shrimp tacos and empanadas. Guacamole is delicious! The staff are very nice. Will definitely be back.

Jeffrey D.Jeffrey Deipolyi: Fantastic Mexican restaurant. The menu is s little short, but every person in our party of four absolutely loved their entrée. The guacamole order is HUGE so plan for that. Will definitely return!!

Courtney M.Courtney Morris: The atmosphere is amazing the bartenders are superb..wait staff outstanding.....food ...out of this world...fresh and flavorful

Senor Taco Mexican Grill is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

7. Senor Taco Mexican Grill

8.0
480 Patchogue Holbrook Rd, Holbrook, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Lisa G.Lisa Giampa-Mignogna: Everything on the menu is delicious! The prices are great! Empanadas and burritos excellent! Taco salad excellent!

Patty H.Patty Hicks: Nachos are delicious!

Tiffany W.Tiffany Winter: Mmmmmmm empanadas

The Lake House is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

8. The Lake House

8.2
240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Mark A.Mark Agovino: Veal tenderloin is excellent and very large portions. Great dinner.

Michelle C.Michelle C.: Newsday #1 pick for New American on LI. Try Cinnamon donuts with dulce de leche cream and a Mexican hot Chocolate

Amy S.Amy Sigillo: Striped bass was amazing! Excellent service

Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

9. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

7.9
335 E Main St, East Islip, NY
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Jennifer R.Jennifer Reilly: Love the fish taco! Has a little wasabi sauce on it. So good!

TaraTara: Love this place......best food ever when you go get the penne with chicken, spinach, and mozzerella in a pink cream sauce it's like eating heaven : D

Alexandra M.Alexandra Mendes: Delicious food and reasonably priced, also really fun drink menu!

The Sayville Inn is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

10. The Sayville Inn

8.0
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Two things you can count on being delicious....the burgers, and anything on the specials board.

KeriKeri: Great baja tacos!

🎃Sam M.🎃Sam Murphy🎃: My dads an awesome chef here :)

Nickys On The Bay is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

11. Nickys On The Bay

7.4
Bayshore Marina, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Susan S.Susan S.: The mussels in the white wine sauce were so good! They give you a lot of bread for dipping in the sauce! The Moscow mule was really nice too.

Sara E.Sara Elizabeth: The calamari is awesome!

Mo K.Mo K: Newly renovated and reopened. There's a gorgeous view from that second story deck addition.

Houser's is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

12. Houser's

7.4
781 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach, NY
Beer Garden · 18 tips and reviews

Kelly A.Kelly A: My go-to FI place!! Great jams in the pm. Fun laid-back crowd! Love the backyard area--tough to get a seat back here during the day unless your eating. Buckets o' beer!

Jill L.Jill Laufer: Order a zippy for the ultimate pregame drink!

Tina-Marie D.Tina-Marie D.: Lobster special $15.00 can't go wrong!

View is one of The 13 Best Places for Margaritas in Islip.

13. View

7.5
3 Consuelo Pl (at Shore Dr), Oakdale, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Lisa P.Lisa P: The chocolate bomb was amazing!

Holly D.Holly Dowell: The food was not great, the service was subpar, and the wine was pretty bad. Disappointed :(

Alexandra M.Alexandra Martignette: Need bigger woman's bathroom