Crickets is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

1. Crickets

8.0
98 Main St, Sayville, NY
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

sweaty G.sweaty Ghost: Get the wings and the Philly cheese steak rare

ChrisChris: I was very surprised by the food here. It was quite tasty and affordable. Try the Liver and Onions. Just try it. Very good

Alicia D.Alicia D: Try theFrench Onion Soup! It's the best around!

Mulberry Street is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

2. Mulberry Street

8.7
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Steven C.Steven C: They have a great lunch and dinner menu. Most come with salad and bread. Food is reasonably priced. Staff is great!

Andra M.Andra Matera: All the pizza and if you eat the restaurant style food good plus great portions. Can make 2 meals from 1.

Bill Mary Seymour M.Bill Mary Seymour Martini: Alfredo sauce :-)

IHOP is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

3. IHOP

8.2
666 Motor Parkway (at Marcus Blvd), Hauppauge, NY
Breakfast Spot · 5 tips and reviews

Jeniffer A.Jeniffer Alvarado: The best service, everyone is so nice!!

JoJos_TweetsJoJos_Tweets: The address here is 666.... Creepy

Emily C.Emily Coffin: IHOP IS THE BEST

The Garage is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

4. The Garage

8.1
170 Bridge Rd, Islandia, NY
Sandwich Spot · 6 tips and reviews

Renee B.Renee Barnes: They have a fabulous Denver omelet with a side of home fries. Everything I've purchased has been delicious. I recommend them for breakfast or lunch. You can eat in or take out.

Liza B.Liza Bullen: Good food great prices.

Jeff F.Jeff F: Ok good. Beyond over priced. Go sparingly. When just in that mood go overpriced food

Bagel Buzz is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

5. Bagel Buzz

7.8
498 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
Bagel Shop · 2 tips and reviews

Dayana H.Dayana Hering: It's one of the places in west Islip that make the best egg sandwiches!!!

Nora M.Nora Morris: The egg sandwiches are AMAZING. The line is usually to the door but it's sooooo worth the wait!

New Idle Hour Deli is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

6. New Idle Hour Deli

7.5
1500 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY
Deli · 6 tips and reviews

Mark H.Mark Heyert: Homemade Baked goods! The homemade coffee cake and brownies are wonderful! There are also great homemade desserts including Rice pudding. The hot entrées are freshly prepared. Highly recommended!

SeanSean: There egg sandwiches are the best in the area

John P.John P: Get the half and halfs!!

Carlo's Pizza Oven is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

7. Carlo's Pizza Oven

7.4
23 Patchogue-Holbrook Rd, Holbrook, NY
Pizzeria · 6 tips and reviews

Kellei A.Kellei Ammirati Burke: Best Italian food ! Great owners and staff! Always use for our catering events !

Ryan A.Ryan Arnold Nauert: Fantastic food and the owners are super nice guys. Been eating here for over 20 years

AlanAlan: Grate food

Changing Times is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

8. Changing Times

7.6
29 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Sports Bar · 20 tips and reviews

Jason M.Jason M.: Jack it up burger, jumbo pretzel, French onion soup, mozzarella Napoleon, hot wings, great beer selection, burgers, fish bowls

SamanthaSamantha: Thursday is ladies night !!! $2 mix drinks and $2 buds -- the perks of having a vagina...

George R.George Raab: Best bar/sports bar im bay shore. Always a good time. The bartenders are great and sociable. I always have a great times

Mama Angelinas Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Steak Subs in Islip.

9. Mama Angelinas Restaurant

7.1
1251 Veterans Hwy, Hauppauge, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Joe G.Joe Gast: This is my favorite place in town. Rich and his team consistently provide an outstanding experience...great food, healthy portions and fair prices! Try the a la vodka, chicken parm or Chicken Marsala!

Dan B.Dan Bod: Do yourself a favor, drive like 1 minute in either direction and buy your Italian food from somewhere else – they don’t deserve your business!!! Mega rip-off, worst service ever! The guy is a prick!

Rich Z.Rich Zbikowski: Everything seems ok service is very good place is quaint and comfortable