Ashley: Great place! Staff was so friendly and nice. Food was ALL delicious. Fish dip and key lime pie should be a must!
Tyler Carter: Great seafood dip and really good fish sandwiches. Not great choices for kids menu but service and food was good.
Monica Soler Carballo: Definitely must have the smoked fish dip and the Matecumbe. We weren’t thrilled with the fish and chips. Nice ambience and great service.
Don Kerner: Great local place. Ahi. Tuna, smoked fish dip, Mahi sandwich, Sharkey burger and Baja tacos on our table, Excellent! Christina was a great waitress. Dog friendly on outdoor deck. Drinks A+.
Nancy Piersol: Great food breakfast, lunch or dinner! Had the "Catch & Cook" our dolphin key eest style & frid in their shrimp batter ... YUMMMMY! have to try if you have fresh fish to bring in for them to cook.
Jennifer Gebelein: Smoked fish dip is awesome! Bloody mary mussels are not very good.
Iliana Taleno Swain: Family's will be more comfortable inside. Adults out at the glass-bottom bar. Fish dip, good. Mahi blackened tacos or Harvey style sammy w/ onion rings- phenomenal! Great Svc, sit with Ms. Amenary.
Jose Sanchez: You have to try the seafood bake, was so good we came back again the next night
Rachel S.: Turtle club bartenders are great, prices are a bit high, but you get what you pay for. Fish dip was awesome!
Eric Munter: Beautiful scenery, great food and live music. What more could you want?
Matt Cason: Wife had fish tacos and they were the best we have ever had, I had seafood burrito it was ok, not what was expected. View was amazing. Conch fritters were good as well.
Omar Cartaya: They ran out of tuna, oysters and fish dip. FML
Phil Santana: The food the ambiance the service and its people are second to none. The Big Chill is the only place I like to go eat and swim ride Wave Runners etc ..the live music is wonderful and the staff 👍🏻
Bryan Reeves: Get the fish sandwich (it's fried). Def try the chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick!
Jade Precious: Best key lime pie in the keys! Not too sweet and jut sour enough.
David T: Don't let the looks of the place deceive you. The food is great and cheap. Had the fish tacos and they were fresh and tasty! Super friendly staff and cool little shop next door.
Patti Stanley: Very clean and cool feeling here! Busy place with lots if locals!
Elisha: Try the Key Lime Pie!
Julia Parker: Fresh fish sandwich of the day was awesome (Yellowtail Snapper) & for non seafood lovers, the chicken tenders & potato discs were perfect. Wait staff was great + they have local Coconut beer
Sign up to tell us what you like, and never miss a beat on finding the best places for you.