Better Than Sex is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

1. Better Than Sex

8.6
926 Simonton St (at Truman Ave), Key West, FL
Dessert Shop · 130 tips and reviews

Raph S.Raph Sangiovanni: Come on Fridays or Saturdays to have the award-winning Chocolate Grilled Cheese. It's got dark Belgian chocolate, Brie, sweet butter bread and strawberry prosecco. It's pretty incredible.

Sarah L.Sarah Lindsey-Lutz: got the tongue bath truffle and grilled cheese - both incredible!! get a rim job with your drink!! a must stop after dinner in key west. very romantic:)

R P.R Patel: Jenny the bartender is soo much fun. Really made the entire meal fun. The food DELICIOUS!! The grilled cheese, YUM!

The Lobster Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

2. The Lobster Shack

8.2
507 South St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

The Traveling D.The Traveling Dolphin: I highly recommend the Lobster Shack. In our party of 4 one of us had the traditional, one had the key lime, one hand the bacon & one had the grilled cheese lobster rolls Ahhhhmazing! 😍😋

Ashley M.Ashley Marie: Diablo lobster roll is the absolute best lobster roll anywhere on the island!

Brandi T.Brandi Taft: Diablo lobster roll is delicious and the staff is super friendly.

Blue Heaven is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

3. Blue Heaven

9.0
729 Thomas St (Petronia St), Key West, FL
Breakfast Spot · 422 tips and reviews

Mary FrancesMary Frances: Vegetarian Alert: Best grilled cheese I've had with tomato, arugula, and avocado. They also have vegetarian black bean soup and platter with tofu on the lunch menu.

Laura A.Laura Aldridge: Relaxed outdoor seating, friendly staff and gorgeous food! Can see why it is rated highly! Lobster grilled cheese sandwich was divine. 2 words - Banana Heaven. You MUST have this for dessert!

Morgan H.Morgan Hannigan: Loved the grilled cheese and tomato sandwich.

Mary Ellen's is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

4. Mary Ellen's

8.2
420 Applerouth Ln, Key West, FL
Dive Bar · 3 tips and reviews

Certainly S.Certainly Strange: MJ is super friendly... patty won't steer you wrong! Tomato soup and grilled cheese...

Nash P.Nash Pleasant: Great dive away from the Duval mayhem. Local preferred hang out

Craig O.Craig Ochs: No windows and great air-conditioning. Did I mention the Mary Ellen's Special. Break away from Duval Street and visit soon.

Coles Peace is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

5. Coles Peace

8.7
1111 Eaton St (White St), Key West, FL
Bakery · 6 tips and reviews

Michael A.Michael Albee: If you're on Key West ... YOU MUST STOP IN HERE! The food is amazing and the people are as well. They were friendly and beyond helpful. Made our trip even that much more fun and easy.

Magdalena W.Magdalena Wolak: Espresso, sandwiches

Travis L.Travis Larson: Sandwiches, Craft beer selection. Get the Ciabatta-Lotta or the Brisket Sandwich!

Santiago's Bodega is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

6. Santiago's Bodega

9.0
207 Petronia St (at Emma St.), Key West, FL
Tapas Restaurant · 123 tips and reviews

Mariia M.Mariia Moiseieva: Amazing tapas and sangria, very cool atmosphere and perfect service! Best tapas!!! Especially tuna ceviche, ribs, grilled cheese and beef carpaccio!

Erica B.Erica Bailly: Get a pitcher of Red Sangria, a wedge salad, dates, spicy shrimp soup and the ribs. Eat family style and you will be set for the night.

Vance B.Vance Born: If yor don't like this place go back to mc Donald's

Goldman's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

7. Goldman's Deli

8.4
2814 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Deli · 15 tips and reviews

Chelsea S.Chelsea Sawaya: Cute little diner with great service and even better bagels!

arzu k.arzu kucuktalay: Best breakfast!!!

Nico B.Nico Benedetti: Best bagels on the island.

Island House Bar and Pool is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

8. Island House Bar and Pool

8.2
1129 Fleming St (at White St), Key West, FL
Swimming Pool · 15 tips and reviews

William W.William W.: Making it a point to come here year, from now on! Friendly staff, very accomodating, awesome facilities and very comfortable rooms. Loved every minute of my stay at the Island House!!

Doug C.Doug Candler: Who IS Gugi G. Anyway? "She" stole my mayorship! This is a Men's resort! Sombody steal it back, or I will in December!

Rovinson M.Rovinson Mejias: I am a man in a dress get over it! Lol

Lucy's Retired Surfers Bar and Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

9. Lucy's Retired Surfers Bar and Restaurant

7.7
221 Duval St, Key West, FL
Caribbean Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Debra B.Debra Bryant: Great service and we only had a snack but the ceviche was delicious. WIt staff was jolly on the spot. Definitely will go back.

Krystle C.Krystle Champagne: It’s not really Caribbean food, but the food is yummy.

Eddie L.Eddie Lorenzo: The ceviche is awesome

Cuban Coffee Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

10. Cuban Coffee Queen

9.1
284 Margaret St, Key West, FL
Coffee Shop · 73 tips and reviews

Jordan G.Jordan Groseclose: Not only some of the best Cuban coffee anywhere, but easily the best coffee in Key West.

Kate Z.Kate Zimmer: Great breakfast sandwiches & coffee. Iced coffee is made with coffee ice cubes = no watered down caffeine.

Magdalena S.Magdalena Soto: Cuban Queen Mix Sandwich is massive enough for two people to share! good service... and cafe cubano!

La Crêperie French Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

11. La Crêperie French Café

8.7
300 Petronia St (at Thomas St), Key West, FL
French Restaurant · 67 tips and reviews

Marta R.Marta Rizzolo: Omg had the crepe with nutella and strawberries delicious with a cappuccino

Christopher S.Christopher Sands: Cash only?!?

Evan M.Evan Mehuys: Best breakfast on the island!

Roof Top Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

12. Roof Top Cafe

7.7
308 Front St, Key West, FL
Italian Restaurant · 39 tips and reviews

Naomi T.Naomi Thomson: The crab cake, from someone who eats a lot of crab cakes, was spectacular. All delicious chunks of crab, held together with wisps of delicious crunch.

Bettina S.Bettina Schmidt: The mango and coconut mojito is really good! So is the crabcake and the Big schrimp dish! Great location/great food

Gina G.Gina Gaft: Lobster Gnocchi is the best = )

El Siboney Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

13. El Siboney Restaurant

8.9
900 Catherine St (Margaret St.), Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 142 tips and reviews

Jeff O.Jeff O'Berry: Go for affordable, delicious food. The service is consistently indifferent. Try the mango or guava cheesecake for dessert!

JenKuduJenKudu: Just get a pitcher of sangria. You'll want another glass ;)

MooseMoose: This place is popular for a reason. Great Cuban food and a mean sangria. :)

Smallest Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

14. Smallest Bar

7.5
124 Duval St (between Front & Greene Sts), Key West, FL
Bar · 33 tips and reviews

John H.John Hagga: This the smallest bar in the world!

Adrian C.Adrian Castillo: A must visit to this place! Great service and drinks!

Bill H.Bill H: If you are going to take a photo here, at least support the place and buy a drink!

Two Friends Patio Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in Key West.

15. Two Friends Patio Restaurant

8.0
512 Front St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 93 tips and reviews

Robert A.Robert Amezquita: Best parking rate in town at $10 for the whole day. AND you get a free piece of Key Lime Pie (with a purchase at the restaurant)!

Tara G.Tara Gangi: Try the conch fritters here. yum yum

Tricia B.Tricia Bellamy: Good crab sandwich and homemade potato chips! The key lime pie was delicious!!