D.J.'s Clam Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

1. D.J.'s Clam Shack

8.8
629 Duval St (at Angela St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 91 tips and reviews

Ryan L.Ryan LLoyd: Try the Maine Lobster Roll (via @Foodspotting)

Ivy M.Ivy Muthart: My husband loves the Maine Lobster Roll and this place meet the standards of having good food. I got the garlic steamed clams and it’s the best!

Odile R.Odile Roujol: Love the place. Fresh beer, delicious steam clams and lobster sandwich

A&B Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

2. A&B Lobster House

8.1
700 Front St, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 45 tips and reviews

Patrick B.Patrick Buffard: Great seafood : try the Maine lobster !!

David S.David Schwartz: This restaurant sits dockside, which might account for the fresh, awesome seafood. Try the Buffalo Shrimp and everything else on the menu.

Greg N.Greg Needham: Fantastic! Best restaurant on the island.

Louie's Backyard is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

3. Louie's Backyard

8.8
700 Waddell Ave (at Vernon Ave), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 122 tips and reviews

Anton K.Anton Kolpakov: Fried truffles, octopus, maine lobster pie and fish du jour (daily special).

Will M.Will Matthews: Pineapple burger and lobster blt were great.

Steve S.Steve Schilling: This is my favorite place... period. Come here for the sunset and skip the tourist mess at the square.

Martin's is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

4. Martin's

8.0
917 Duval St (btwn Olivia & Truman), Key West, FL
New American Restaurant · 34 tips and reviews

courtney c.courtney choate: Went for happy hour and was very impressed! Had a few different kinds of the martinis and I especially loved the Key West Sunset. We also shared apps; the pork tenderloin tapas was phenomenal.

Adam V.Adam Van Bavel: Sit outside in the garden. Ask for Dennis!

Will M.Will Matthews: Pam and I had the Grouper and Lobster, both local catches. They were amazing. Wait staff the best since we have been here.

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

5. Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

8.1
1007 Simonton St (at Truman Ave.), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Nicola S.Nicola Setford: Best meal we had on our trip. Great steak and shrimp and lovely cocktails. Reasonably priced too. Would highly recommend. You won't leave hungry.

Monique M.Monique Melton: The fried alligator tail is amazingly yummy!!!!

Steve M.Steve Murray-Smith: great prime rib and yellow tail

Blackfin Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

6. Blackfin Bistro

8.3
918 Duval St (btwn Olivia St. And Truman Ave.), Key West, FL
New American Restaurant · 49 tips and reviews

Nicole L.Nicole Logan: Faves: Lobster Spring Rolls, & Key West Pink Shrimp!

Sarah .Sarah 🌴: I've been here three time so far and am never disappointed with the food or service. Service food and ambience are out of control. Definitely check this place out if you are in key west.

jPjP: This place it's awesome!! Eat here!

Smokin' Tuna Saloon is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

7. Smokin' Tuna Saloon

8.5
4 Charles St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 62 tips and reviews

Nash P.Nash Pleasant: Great live music out back. Solid raw bar and good priced cocktails. Chill spot off of duval to hang

Cathy B.Cathy Belcher: New bar - great music and atmosphere.

Leah S.Leah Sacksteder: The fish dip is DELICIOUS!

Mangia Mangia is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

8. Mangia Mangia

7.5
900 Southard Street (at Margaret St), Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 40 tips and reviews

Tina v.Tina von K: I really don't think you can go wrong here. Creamy marinara sauce is beyond amazing with the quinoa pasta. Key Lime pie is spectacular!

JimmyGotUpsJimmyGotUps: Ask to sit outside if the weather is nice.

Sven W.Sven Wiesner: Really nice staff and food. Try the Schmappelinis. Pasta to the people!

Commodore Steak & Lobster House is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

9. Commodore Steak & Lobster House

7.5
220 Margaret Street, Key West, FL
Steakhouse · 18 tips and reviews

bryn k.bryn kehoe: Yes, it's expensive... But it's worth it! The prime rib is incredible and the service is great

Jason K.Jason Keath: Order the Yellowtail Snapper. Thank me when you're done. Sans lemon butter sauce to save the calories. Either way, delicious.

Carl R.Carl Ramallo: Unbelievable location & food on the Pier.

Banana Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

10. Banana Cafe

8.7
1215 Duval St (Louisa St), Key West, FL
French Restaurant · 82 tips and reviews

Vinicius P.Vinicius Procopio Guerra: Must have in KeyWest for a quick and delicious breakfast. Try any of the sweet crepes, and the smoked salmon omelette. 😋

Derek H.Derek Howell: Try the water, it's wicked good.

Shawn N.Shawn Nicholson: Excellent food and service. French onion soup, mahi mahi, and hog snapper special was amazing. 4.5 Stars all Day! A Must Try Place.

Key West Yacht Club is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

11. Key West Yacht Club

7.2
2315 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Boat or Ferry · 7 tips and reviews

Jason J.Jason Jessee: Start with red conch chowder. Finish with perfect temp prime rib because there's no room for desert.

Soraia H.Soraia Holanda: PASSEIO TOPPPPP

Kim B.Kim Beatty: Everything!

Conch Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

12. Conch Shack

7.2
118 Duval St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Natalie G.Natalie Guerra-Valdes: Best conch fritters ever! Cheap beer too. Cash only

DwainDwain: Cheap PBR tall boys and awesome conch fritters... What more could one ask for?

Jack M.Jack Mayo: Oh, and best beer prices outside CVS. $3 tallboys!

Mangoes Restaurant & Island Cuisine is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

13. Mangoes Restaurant & Island Cuisine

7.0
700 Duval St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

kimberly n.kimberly n: Two for one drinks during happy hour. The poke was good but small for $16. Salsa trio was great

Bartek R.Bartek Ringwelski: $90 for 3 tacos, poke and 3 drinks.

Bartek R.Bartek Ringwelski: Drinks are solid, food is meh

South Beach is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

14. South Beach

7.3
Duval St, Key West, FL
Beach · 30 tips and reviews

Quentin L.Quentin Lafon: The best beach in Key West and the nearest from Cuba. Great place for sunbathe and Jet-ski .

Cody L.Cody Lee: 90 miles to Cuba

Cesar R.Cesar Razuri: Ignore your phone, and indulge in being at the southern most point of America... and get a cocktail while you're at it

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton is one of The 15 Best Places for Maine Lobster in Key West.

15. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

7.6
1500 Reynolds St, Key West, FL
Hotel · 87 tips and reviews

Alberto L.Alberto Lugo: Best hotel in Key West. Big, private beach, two pools. Great location.

Rex D.Rex Dow: Had a chance to stay here a few days a while back - great retreat in this slightly nuts town

AT&TAT&T: Another great reason to stay here: AT&T Wi-Fi is one of the many amenities here for guests. It’s fast and easy to connect.