The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Key West

Business Reps: Great date night place! Peanut Butter Perversion was my favorite!

Tony Bago: The staff is extremely polite and helpful. The desserts are out of this Key! The Peanut Butter Perversion was to die for with the help of the moscato wine dipped in carmel!

Brian Sammons: Reservations a must. Peanut Butter Perversion is so delicious!!

saran saran: Cookies, Fudge, Key Lime Pie, Ice Cream, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Toasted Coconut, Mint Chip, Vanilla, Chocolate

ThomasP RakMDFACS: Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge, Catering, Chocolate chip, Peanut butter with chocolate fudge, Sugar cookies with sprinkles, Freshly baked goods, Freshly made sweets

Chris Francis: The absolute best ice cream and sorbet on the island. They also ship their delicious cookies at a reasonable price

Sutton Stewart: Awesome little spot with organic items on the menu and in the market. The peanut butter smoothie is really good!

Eve Sandlova: Love love the place the atmosphere and the food and drinks, tried the wraps they are amazing

Arjun Ram: Burrito was ok. Good place to walk in and eat. Wasn’t blown away though.

Caren Cone: I love my peanut buster parfait!!!!!

Andrew Dahl: Get the ice cream!

Matthew Heiser: The lemon meringue blizzard is actually key lime blizzard and it is superb!

Angel 🍷 Anderson: peanut butter and jellyfish sandwich!!!!

Mike Lewis: Fish tacos are phenom. Dog friendly with some great characters. I feel like the local boozers really love this place. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.

Cathy Belcher: Try the Tuna Nachos. Amazing!

Dilek: A classic diner with good food

Ghaida✨: Strawberry fried pancake was awesome!

Nash Pleasant: Tacos! Greens! Locally sourced food!

Maura Grace: Must try the Four Flowers Juice for brunch. Fresh pomegranate, orange, banana and pineapple juice.

HeresJay Kesslinger: Sunday night is fried-chicken night...Don't miss it!

Juli Fahrner: Try the lemon ricotta pancakes...they are fantastic.

Mark Lanier: Sushi grade tuna, fresh hot meals, soups...all different each day. Best deal in town!

Stacey Herron: A really great wine selection. In a grocery store! Sure, you can get a box of Franzia, but you'll find a nice selection of wines from Russian River, the Willamette Valley and more.

Carl Ramallo: Like a mini Whole Food, in the Keys.

Bella Baustian: AMAZING dumplings and fried rice! Quick and kind service, definitely would suggest for comfort food❤️

Tom Sullivan: Pan fried dumplings, shrimp fried rice and Pho

Casey: Chick pad tia.. Really good. Service was excellent. Willing to customize the orders too!

Amber DeBevec: Tuesday and Thursday 5-7 happy hour half price apps and drinks! Stayed for dinner, great prime rib good price!

Brittney Baker: Great food

Amy Malespin: Best Happy Hour in Key West! Any drink is buy one, get one free daily from 5-7. Food is absolutely amazing!! Come in and get the best service. :)