BO's Fish Wagon is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

1. BO's Fish Wagon

8.8
801 Caroline St (at William St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 63 tips and reviews

Rosie M.Rosie M: Fried grouper sandwich is always fresh and good. The conch fritters actually have a good amount of conch unlike other places which are more dough. The grilled catch of the day platter is also great!

Yesi P.Yesi Prados: Very Key West style fish shack. The fried fish of the day sandwich is very fresh and the fish is so soft it literally melts in your mouth. The fries are okay, nothing to die for.

Heathor K.Heathor Kerr Balazy: Love this place! Fish tacos are to die for. The grouper sandwich is also wonderful!

Five Brothers is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

2. Five Brothers

8.6
930 Southard St (Grinnel), Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

carl m.carl midson: Best coffee on the island! Great sandwiches too.

RichardRichard: Great coffee and Cuban sandwiches. Need to move the paper stands and put a couple of little tables on sidewalk.

Zach B.Zach Brown: ham croquettes. amazing on their own, phenomenal on a sandwich! at $0.65 each you gotta try them, but be careful not to order too many...they're addictive as crack <3

Cuban Coffee Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

3. Cuban Coffee Queen

9.1
284 Margaret St, Key West, FL
Coffee Shop · 73 tips and reviews

Kate Z.Kate Zimmer: Great breakfast sandwiches & coffee. Iced coffee is made with coffee ice cubes = no watered down caffeine.

Magdalena S.Magdalena Soto: Cuban Queen Mix Sandwich is massive enough for two people to share! good service... and cafe cubano!

hh: Key wester sandwich is amazing!! So savory and texturally rich 😁

Mr. Z's -Old Town is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

4. Mr. Z's -Old Town

7.6
501 Southard St (at Duval St.), Key West, FL
Pizzeria · 57 tips and reviews

ChelseaChelsea: Best cheesesteaks I've ever had - definitely plan on making this your last stop of the night!

Michael F.Michael Fenner: Best cheesesteaks on the island. Try the cheesesteaks or pizzasteak. Everything here is amazing. Hit it up on your walk home from duval for even better results.

Carolyn H.Carolyn Hoffmann: Great pizza and cheesesteaks! Also, great pork roll sandwich!!

Panini Schamini is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

5. Panini Schamini

8.1
1075 Duval St (Virginia), Key West, FL
Sandwich Spot · 25 tips and reviews

Jorge M.Jorge M.: The Prosciutto & Goat Cheese Panini is my favorite sandwich on in KW!

Jason S.Jason Spoor-Harvey: Cuban panini is great!

courtney c.courtney choate: The goat cheese and prosciutto panini was fantastic and very filling.

Eaton Street Seafood Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

6. Eaton Street Seafood Market

8.7
801 Eaton St, Key West, FL
Fish Market · 19 tips and reviews

James D.James Davis: Excellent food! Try the Salmon Sandwich & Crab Cake Sandwich!! Fresh Fish!!!

Danielle F.Danielle Fracalossi: Mahi sandwich was delicious!!!

Mary ann K.Mary ann Kavouras: The shrimp salad sandwich on croissant was amazing! Great place to pick up happy hour food to take on a sunset cruise.

Fernandy's Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

7. Fernandy's Café

8.2
1110 White St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 56 tips and reviews

Pam F.Pam Fleischer: Deserves the claim of original (and best) Cuban sandwich...

Carl R.Carl Ramallo: Get the Cuban Sandwich.

Victoria E.Victoria Elizabeth: Great Cuban Sandwich!

Sloppy Joe's Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

8. Sloppy Joe's Bar

8.4
201 Duval Street (at Greene Street), Key West, FL
Bar · 213 tips and reviews

Jeff O.Jeff Ollis: Come in and get a Sloppy Joe sandwich, drink a beer, and listen to some music. You may not be able to write like Hemingway, but you can drink like him!

Chris S.Chris Savino: The meatloaf sandwich is to die for

Mouad B.Mouad Baha: Sloppy joe sandwich is amazing

Caroline's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

9. Caroline's Cafe

8.3
310 Duval St (at Caroline St), Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 98 tips and reviews

Don B.Don Becker: Best cheese steak outside of Philly.

Jenn T.Jenn Tofanelli: Lettuce wrap salad. Or order the cheese steak except with chicken. Super delish. And fantastic people watching.

Janis D.Janis Deedy: The fish sandwich is ah-may-zing. Crispy on the outside and flaky on the inside! Love it!!!!

Cuban Coffee Queen -Downtown is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

10. Cuban Coffee Queen -Downtown

8.5
508 Southard St. Key Lime Sq. #5, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Gideon O.Gideon Olshansky: Delicious Cuban sandwiches and coffee.

Dave S.Dave St Dennis: Best breakfast sandwich I ever had. And best breakfast in Key West.

Rick C.Rick Clayton: Best coffee and fantastic sandwiches

Salute! is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

11. Salute!

8.2
1000 Atlantic Blvd, Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 74 tips and reviews

Mary Margaret M.Mary Margaret McLeroy: Get the fish sandwhich- it is amazing

OdieOdie: If you get dessert, try the homemade ice cream cookie sandwich!!! It is so delicious!!!

Mark M.Mark Meijerink: The anti-pasta Sandwich tastes delicious!

Coles Peace is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

12. Coles Peace

8.7
1111 Eaton St (White St), Key West, FL
Bakery · 6 tips and reviews

Chad N.Chad Newman: Great bakery and great sandwiches. It's a lunch spot as it's only open till 2:00 pm. The specials are always really good. Read more.

Travis L.Travis Larson: Sandwiches, Craft beer selection. Get the Ciabatta-Lotta or the Brisket Sandwich!

Magdalena W.Magdalena Wolak: Espresso, sandwiches

Better Than Sex is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

13. Better Than Sex

8.8
926 Simonton St (at Truman Ave), Key West, FL
Dessert Shop · 131 tips and reviews

Raph S.Raph Sangiovanni: Come on Fridays or Saturdays to have the award-winning Chocolate Grilled Cheese. It's got dark Belgian chocolate, Brie, sweet butter bread and strawberry prosecco. It's pretty incredible.

Sarah L.Sarah Lindsey-Lutz: got the tongue bath truffle and grilled cheese - both incredible!! get a rim job with your drink!! a must stop after dinner in key west. very romantic:)

R P.R Patel: Jenny the bartender is soo much fun. Really made the entire meal fun. The food DELICIOUS!! The grilled cheese, YUM!

D.J.'s Clam Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

14. D.J.'s Clam Shack

8.7
629 Duval St (at Angela St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 91 tips and reviews

SepSep S.SepSep Sphr: The lobster sandwich is the best thing in the whole world. Your life is pointless if you don't try it!

KenKen: The lobster roll is a sandwich filled with whole lobster

Dasha E.Dasha Efimova: Sandwiches are die for! Even more tasty than meatballs of my grandmom! Amazing, crazy, awesome!

Kim's Kuban is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Key West.

15. Kim's Kuban

8.5
2302 N Roosevelt Blvd (at 5th St), Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Bing F.Bing Futch: Steak, egg and cheese sandwich = heaven!

Sean B.Sean Ballesteros: Awesome Cuban sandwich.

Stephanie ☥ S.Stephanie ☥ Swogger: Great cold Cuban sandwiches and Café con Leche!