Dairy Kastle is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

1. Dairy Kastle

9.2
575 Eastern Pkwy (at Bradley Avenue), Louisville, KY
Ice Cream Parlor · Saint Joseph · 30 tips and reviews

Carol S.Carol Schroerlucke: Get the FAT ELVIS! Awesome peanut butter and banana shake! INCREDIBLE!

Cody G.Cody Gardner: The Fat Elvis is a peanut butter and banana milkshake. Get it! You will not regret it!

Tiffiany C.Tiffiany Collier: Ice cream, chili dogs, slushies, banana split, vegan soft serve

Dairy Del is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

2. Dairy Del

8.6
1516 S Shelby St (Burnett Ave), Louisville, KY
Ice Cream Parlor · Central Louisville · 5 tips and reviews

Jessica W.Jessica Whann: Best chili dogs, peanut butter shakes and cheese fries

Deanna C.Deanna Claycomb: Vanilla shakes and chilli dogs to die for!!!

Honey C R.Honey C REALTOR: Chili Dogs are fabulous!

Napa River Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

3. Napa River Grill

8.3
1211 Herr Ln, Louisville, KY
Wine Bar · East Louisville · 17 tips and reviews

Dan S.Dan Smith Chavira: The peanut butter chocolate creme brulee was amazing. And I usually skip dessert!

RichardRichard: Burgers, Steaks, nachos, bread pudding, pad thai

LouisvilleLouisville: Can't miss with the tomato soup (covered with puff pastry) and caesar salad (served in an edible parmesan bowl. Read more.

Graeter's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

4. Graeter's Ice Cream

8.1
9430 Brownsboro Rd, Louisville, KY
Ice Cream Parlor · East Louisville · 6 tips and reviews

Emily S.Emily Smith: Peanut butter chip and strawberry chip are by far my favorite!! Graeters is so my favorite place

Gregory G.Gregory Goodin: Order any of their flavors here. Great selection with a very friendly staff.

Michelle B.Michelle Buice: It’s ok, not great.

Orange Leaf is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

5. Orange Leaf

8.2
3012 Bardstown Rd. (Gardiner Lane Shopping Center), Louisville, KY
Ice Cream Parlor · Gardiner Lane · 8 tips and reviews

Zach J.Zach Johns: Peanut butter and brownie batter combination is the best!

Sam A.Sam A.: UK Coach John Calipari owns 7 Orange Leaf stores and is expanding. Eating Orange Leaf supports UK/Calipari. Still want some Orange Leaf?

Orange Leaf Frozen YogurtOrange Leaf Frozen Yogurt: Sam A., Coach Cal doesn't actually own any Louisville Orange Leafs.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

6. BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse

7.5
7900 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY
American Restaurant · East Louisville · 61 tips and reviews

Bryan S.Bryan Siders: Save room for a Pizookie! My favorite is the Peanut Butter one, but I still need to try the Triple Chocolate one. Read more.

Austin R.Austin Rush: Peanut Butter with chocolate ice cream pizookie, with a PM Porter...a must try!

Michael F.Michael F: Fried avocado rolls for appetizer. Just perfect!

Gigi's Cupcakes is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

7. Gigi's Cupcakes

7.8
1977 S Hurstbourne Pkwy (at Hurstbourne Cir), Louisville, KY
Cupcake Shop · East Louisville · 11 tips and reviews

Joey C.Joey Couch: Chocolate tort, cookie dough, and peanut butter cupcakes are the ones I like from here so far

red collar photographyred collar photography: You can special order flavors! I did cinnamon cream cheese icing with chocolate cake for my boyfriends birthday to make beach looking cupcakes! He loved them and they were tasty!

Elizabeth G.Elizabeth Goforth: Wedding cake is awesome!

The Comfy Cow is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

8. The Comfy Cow

8.5
1301 Herr Ln (Westport Rd), Louisville, KY
Dessert Shop · East Louisville · 40 tips and reviews

Barry L.Barry Lauterwasser: Cow Tracks! Peanut Peanut Butter Butter

Lindsay S.Lindsay Seidel: Loved the cherry amaretto but pistachio is one of my favorites!

Travel ChannelTravel Channel: THE place in Louisville for ice cream sundaes, shakes and pies. As seen on Man v Food Nation.

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

9. Cold Stone Creamery

7.6
2015 S. Hurstbourne Pkwy., Louisville, KY
Ice Cream Parlor · East Louisville · 16 tips and reviews

Patrick M.Patrick MacDonald: Peanut Butter Cup perfection! YUM!!

Caroline L.Caroline Long: Cake batter, yellow cake, strawberries, and whipped cream!!

Phillip B.Phillip Barnett: Tip see what song they sing

Zen Garden Vegetarian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

10. Zen Garden Vegetarian Restaurant

7.5
2240 Frankfort Ave (btw Payne & S Jane), Louisville, KY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Clifton · 9 tips and reviews

margie v.margie veasey: Vegan Chocolate Peanut Butter pie is AMAZING, but it's very rich. A small slice can be shared by a few!

Michelle J.Michelle Jones: Orange tofu is the business.

John P.John Park: The Shitake' Mushroom Lomein is just perfect!!!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

11. The Cheesecake Factory

8.6
5000 Shelbyville Rd Ste 1585 (Mall St. Matthews), Louisville, KY
American Restaurant · East Louisville · 53 tips and reviews

Stacy H.Stacy Hoehle: I was just thinking about how much I miss the Godiva white chocolate peanut butter cheesecake.

Stacy H.Stacy Hoehle: Chicken madiera is my favorite dish still on the menu!

David C.David Clark: Mood lighting is a little TOO dark

Louisville Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

12. Louisville Cream

7.7
632 E Market St Ste 101 (Clay St.), Louisville, KY
Ice Cream Parlor · East Market District · 6 tips and reviews

DobleDoble: This is a 9.0+ ice cream shop even though current rating says 7.9. Peanut butter fudge cookies and cream was incredible. Banana pudding was as well.

IvyIvy: Taste everything! It is all amazing!

Leland B.Leland Brewster: Delicious small batch ice cream. Definitely try the waffle or pretzel cone. The strawberry cheesecake cookies and cream was a seasonal flavor but fantastic!

Plehn's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

13. Plehn's Bakery

9.0
3940 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY
Bakery · East Louisville · 10 tips and reviews

💜Abbey S.💜Abbey Snawder💜: Everything is INCREDIBLE! Love the angel dips and decorated cupcakes especially!!!!❤️❤️👉🏼🍩

Louisville Family Fun S.Louisville Family Fun Stephanie White: Best pumpernickel bread you'll find in town!

Katy M.Katy Miller: They have a donut called the Yum Yum that is unrivaled by any donut opponent.

The Cheddar Box is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

14. The Cheddar Box

8.5
12121 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY
Deli · East Louisville · 7 tips and reviews

Hannah W.Hannah Webster: The tuna salad sandwich is delicious! ...and try some tomato artichoke soup w it! So good!

louisville.comlouisville.com: "This lunch spot also does a brisk deli carryout trade. Tomato artichoke soup, Derby Pasta, honey pecan chicken salad are favorites."

Ryan C.Ryan Clark: Mustard here is super bold, if you're not a mustard lover, don't take the chance

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Louisville.

15. Panera Bread

8.2
2125 S Hurstbourne Pkwy, Louisville, KY
Bakery · East Louisville · 5 tips and reviews

Sarah R N.Sarah R Nasr: Love everything here

Harry H.Harry Hood: Bad service and employees are rude. Go to the location at 500 south hurstboune lane instead.

Carol F.Carol Freels: Everything