1. Pizza Brutta
9.0
1805 Monroe St, Madison, WI
Pizzeria · Dudgeon - Monroe · 26 tips and reviews
Dave Sawyer: The open-flame, brick oven adds an incredible smoky char flavor to the wonderfully chewy, delicious thin crust. An authentic Neapolitan pizza for a great price. Can't go wrong.
James Haws: Authentic pizza
Alexey: My Italian friend from Naples says the pizza here is quite authentic, so I don't see how can one argue it is not. Either way, best pizza in town!
USA TODAY: Authentic tacos and tamales are prepared behind the counter. The best-selling steak-and-onion or vegetarian tacos go for $1.75 each. Get takeout and picnic at nearby Lake Menona. Read more.
Paul Logan: This place is fantastic. Definitely the best, most authentic Mexican food in town.
Yoli Z: Not a clue why this place is soooo overrated. Much better and more authentic Mexican can be found at both El Pastor and also at El Jalapeño on Midvale Blvd. Less crowds there too.
Jason Hepperly: The salsa and chips are awesome. Excellent authentic Mexican restaurant
G Hoyer: Fajitas , burritos and tacos all delicious. Generous portions and friendly staff. I will be back.
Graham Fuguitt: Great Margaritas, Pico de Gallo, and Enchiladas. A wonderful spot.
7. Novanta
8.6
8452 Old Sauk Rd, Madison, WI
Pizzeria · 22 tips and reviews
Derek VanRiper: Very good authentic pizza -- definitely will go back. Tried the Parma for my first visit, intrigued by many of the other options. Try the San Pelligrino Limonade if you are passing on beer and wine.
Ally M: By far my favorite pizza place in Middleton/Madison area. Delicious!!
Todd Hill: This is a great new place on the west side. Wood stove cooked pizzas and salads with homemade mozzarella and fresh ingredients. Like!!
8. Naples 15
8.4
15 N Butler St, Madison, WI
Italian Restaurant · Downtown Madison · 9 tips and reviews
Jenni Buss: Wood fire pizza, lobster ravioli and 3 meat ragu are amazing! Great cozy vibe, authentic food and Chef Sal is a great host! Feels like we are back in Italy!
George Waite: Super friendly owner/chef. Great food with lots of traditional dishes. Wood fired pizzas are amazing.
Greg Schulz: Their home made salad dressing is excellent. The gnocchi is also really good if you're into that kind of thing.