My Pie is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

1. My Pie

7.8
696 Lexington Ave (at E 57th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Midtown East · 61 tips and reviews

Jean L.Jean Lee: Don't know why it says it's expensive. It's only $4 for a slice of the best margherita pizza! All organic with no added sugar... You can taste the difference. Authentic Romana style!

Seth B.Seth Bishop: Best margarita pizza I've ever had

Tom M.Tom M: Really great find - small location with 5-6 tables. Had margherita chickenparm and pepperoni pizza. Thinner grandma Roman style, great crust crunch, fresh ingredients. My rating 8.5 🍕 out of 10

Sofia Wine Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

2. Sofia Wine Bar

8.6
242 E 50th St (Bet 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Turtle Bay · 93 tips and reviews

Lorraine S.Lorraine S: Cute & cozy lil Italian place! Meatballs are yummy. Margherita pizza is OK.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: A cute, but tiny, wine bar in Midtown East - an area that could use more places like this. This is our go-to date spot, with a vast wine list and great tapas to share. We love the margherita pizza!

Shana J.Shana Jordan: One of my favorite places in the city! Well worth the wait! Enjoy the garden in back and make sure to save room for the Mac and cheese!

Roberta's is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

3. Roberta's

8.4
230 Park Ave (45th St & Vanderbilt Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Midtown East · 63 tips and reviews

Carlos S.Carlos Suárez: Authentic Margherita pizza. It was so good I had two pies!!!

Chrissy T.Chrissy Thomas: Famous original and margherita pizzas were lovely! We got large pizzas and they hit the spot! Located in a very cool shared space so the atmosphere is good!

ChristophChristoph: Awesome pizza. Start with the famous original.

Brooklyn Pizza Masters is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

4. Brooklyn Pizza Masters

7.7
1055 1st Ave, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 3 tips and reviews

Russell H.Russell Hirschorn: Best pizza in midtown east on 1st over Marinara, Soph and Best on 1st. Margherita, buff and bbq packd w. quality chicken, veg is awesome, wife loves pear and the rice balls are killer at $3.

Polina W.Polina Weitz: They have a nice variety of toppings, and their crust is nice (not thin though). They allowed me to made substitutions on their pizzas. Loved both the Wild mushrooms and the Quattro Stagioni.

Zdenek F.Zdenek Farana: Pretty good actually, don't let the rating distract you. Crust crispy, not super thin, but I did like it very much! Vodka sauce is all the rage, sausage one was packed with sausage. A bit pricier.

Pazza Notte is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

5. Pazza Notte

7.9
1375 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 141 tips and reviews

nymagnymag: "This was one of the first places I had lunch with my relatives when I won Miss USA," Rima Fakih tells us in her NY Diet. She recommends the margherita flatbread. Read more.

King S.King Sharif: Margarita pizza but add chicken

Gail A.Gail Amurao: The 2-for-1 martini special is awesome, favorites are blood orange, passion fruit, and French. Great vibe and atmosphere for having a drink and conversation with someone. Their food is solid too.

Pizzarte is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

6. Pizzarte

7.3
69 W 55th St (btwn 5th Ave.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 54 tips and reviews

A K.A K: Try my very favorite Frittura All'Italiana as a starter, followed by Pizza Pulcinella or a classic Margherita ....YUM!

Jo G.Jo G.: If you're looking for a real Italian pizza, then go there and try the Pulcinella, it's so good and tasty!

JennyJennyJennyJenny: Overlooked calamari, bland pizza, lentil soup is pile of lentils with no broth & they didn't honor the foursquare specials. Don't waste your money.

Warwick New York Hotel is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

7. Warwick New York Hotel

8.7
65 W 54th St, New York, NY
Hotel · Midtown East · 56 tips and reviews

Александра К.Александра Клюева: Wonderful hotel in the center of NYC! Great location! Closed to Times Square and Central Park. I had great view from my amazing terrace. You'll never find other hotel in the center of NYC with terrace

The New York Daily NewsThe New York Daily News: PHOTO: The Beatles meet the press at the Warwick Hotel in 1964, at the link! Read more.

Haya A.Haya Al Dossary: Lovely view, cold rooms which is a plus for me, too bad about the mini bar though, $50 for moving a bottle of water? Yeesh!

Michael's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

8. Michael's Restaurant

8.0
24 W 55th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Midtown East · 30 tips and reviews

Jonathan P.Jonathan Perkel: The new menu is amazing! Duck confit sliders, Korean tacos, it's all delicious...

Ian S.Ian Schafer: Make sure you notice the (now) vintage 80s artwork. This place is frozen in a very different time.

Chris S.Chris Simon: The best blueberry pancakes in the world!

Ethos is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

9. Ethos

8.4
905 1st Ave (at 51st St), New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 79 tips and reviews

Zoë E.Zoë E.: Incredible food, great service and an adorable atmosphere. No need to order hummus - they bring you hummus and pita when you sit down. Say it's your birthday - you're in for a treat.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Come and enjoy delicious Greek food, especially the Grilled Calamari, Shrimp & Octopus, and get a whole Bronzini. The clintele skews older.

Dan B.Dan Berube: Great service and yummy seafood. Grilled calamari is the best I've had.

Cello Wine Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

10. Cello Wine Bar

7.6
229 E 53rd St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Midtown East · 27 tips and reviews

Nicole A.Nicole Albano: Delicious food - short ribs are not to be missed! Amazing service. My new favorite neighborhood joint!

Kristen P.Kristen Peirano: Great flatbreads especially the white one !

Jarett L.Jarett Lewis: 2 drinks $43 enjoy. Didn't get wine.

La Cava Wine Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

11. La Cava Wine Bar

7.6
939 2nd Ave (at E 50th St), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Turtle Bay · 34 tips and reviews

Georgia R.Georgia R: Fantastic staff, wonderful Malbec, orgasmic panini. Best wine bar in midtown!

HarryHarry: Nice, cozy little wine bar. Decent selection of wines and finger food. Conveniently located. However, the music does not suit the place and decor imho

Sexy L.Sexy LF: Nice selection of wines by the glass and a great, classy after-work scene. This isn't your popcorn and peanuts on the counter crowd.

Il Tinello is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

12. Il Tinello

7.3
16 W 56th St, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 16 tips and reviews

Alex B.Alex Bogdanovich: Don't trust those who say they have a bad service! All guys work excellent ! Good music, cozy place! Fresh, homemade bread! Also they can cook anything u want even if it's not in a menu.

Ashley M.Ashley Mas: One of my favorite restaurants in NY! Spectacular food, classic old Italian ambiance. Worth the price, but it's not for you if you're looking for something quick and/or quiet (like I said, Italian...)

AlbertoAlberto: Horrible service...completely ignored after our dinner was served. Took 45 minutes to leaves after we were done

Mangia is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

13. Mangia

8.0
50 W 57th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 55 tips and reviews

Adam H.Adam Handley: Great fresh Italian. Lots of different salads and meats to choose from. High quality. Not cheap nyc Italian deli junk

Douglas K.Douglas Kurdziel: They have moved some hot sandwiches (like the wonderful Telera and steak sandwich) to the counter in the back - don't miss them!

Jackie B.Jackie Burnbaum: If you're an Italian food lover, this is heaven. From the chicken Milanese salad, goat cheese tarts, refreshing salads, great lunch spot

Gente Ristorante Italiano is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

14. Gente Ristorante Italiano

7.4
153 E 45th St (btwn Lexington & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 24 tips and reviews

BlackboardEatsBlackboardEats: Start with the bruschetta with mozzarella, prosciutto and roasted peppers and then move on to the risotto pollo e spinaci. Read more.

Kevin M.Kevin Mantell: The gelato is imported from Italy. It is amazing.

Mariano G.Mariano Gnecco: Excellent lasagna at this place!

Inside Park at St Bart's is one of The 15 Best Places for Margherita Pizza in Midtown East, New York.

15. Inside Park at St Bart's

7.2
109 E 50th St (Park Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Midtown East · 33 tips and reviews

Tina Hui T.Tina Hui Tina Hui: Dine al fresca on a lovely summer night for happy hour. It's almost magical.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Grab an outside table during the warmer months and enjoy a pitcher of sangria with a Beef Burger or Steak and Eggs. Relax, it’s the weekend, who cares if the service is slow.

Dawn S.Dawn Sandomeno: Great spot for a drink outside and the spiciest crab cakes I've ever had inside!