Best Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

1. Best Pizza

7.3
1038 1st Ave (at E 57th St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 15 tips and reviews

David G.David Greenberger: The place lives up to its name. 1 of the top 3 slices I've had in NYC. No need to get fancy, the plain and mini pepperoni slices are out of this world.

Harry D.Harry Davis: pepperoni and buffalo chicken slices

Dave R.Dave Reed: Go with the small pepperoni slice and you won't be disappointed.

Marinara Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

2. Marinara Pizza

7.7
985 1st Ave, New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 6 tips and reviews

Eric H.Eric Ho: The stuffed crust Sicilian pepperoni!

Steve M.Steve Maybo: Awesome high quality pizza. Topping all seem fresh and full of flavor. The classic square pepperoni and sausage is fantastic. Everything very good.

Gianna N.Gianna Nebbia: I love their chicken slices

Sofia Pizza Shoppe is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

3. Sofia Pizza Shoppe

7.3
989 1st Ave (btw 54th & 55th St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 16 tips and reviews

Lee H.Lee Hoffman: Very good slices - favs vodka, pepperoni, sausage

Matthew P.Matthew P: Spinach Dip pizza is amazing. Pepperoni Sicilian or Pepperoni slice is excellent. The Classica is really excellent as just a plain slice.

Robin B.Robin Biegeleisen: I had a slice of vodka pizza with mushrooms that was absolutely delicious. The crust was crispy just like I like it. Will definitely return to try their other offerings.

My Pie is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

4. My Pie

7.8
696 Lexington Ave (at E 57th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Midtown East · 61 tips and reviews

Gianmarco D.Gianmarco Di Michele: Amazing pepperoni and margherita!Yummy!

Tom M.Tom M: Really great find - small location with 5-6 tables. Had margherita chickenparm and pepperoni pizza. Thinner grandma Roman style, great crust crunch, fresh ingredients. My rating 8.5 🍕 out of 10

Jean L.Jean Lee: Don't know why it says it's expensive. It's only $4 for a slice of the best margherita pizza! All organic with no added sugar... You can taste the difference. Authentic Romana style!

Blue & Gold Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

5. Blue & Gold Deli

8.5
1075 1st Ave (E 59th St), New York, NY
Deli · Sutton Place · 2 tips and reviews

Lex G.Lex Gotti: The food is good and the price too 😋😋😋

Sean G.Sean Grano: Great food!

Serafina Osteria is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

6. Serafina Osteria

8.0
38 E 58th St (btwn Madison & Park Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 13 tips and reviews

funky f.funky flavor: Had my company Xmas party here. We had a great time. Drinks were great. Their Margarita pizza os good. And the entrees are great! Have the pastas they are awesome

Rachel S.Rachel Smith: Penne stolichnaya!!!

Keoni S.Keoni Souza: Yum Bruscheta!

The Shops at The Plaza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

7. The Shops at The Plaza

7.7
1 W 58th St (5th Ave), New York, NY
Shopping Mall · Midtown East · 5 tips and reviews

Emeltri G. A.Emeltri G. Alegre: Be sure to visit Gramercy Park Flower Shop ;). And also great place to hang tasty foods and frozen yogurt

Felicia V.Felicia Valentine: One of the cutest flower boy I did ever see ♥ and very charming too ;)

Sheshelaghost L.Sheshelaghost LaGhost: One of a kind pieces! A-List fav! Womens clothes & Accessories.

Toasties East is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

8. Toasties East

8.2
6 E 48th St (btwn Madison & 5th Ave.), New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Midtown East · 25 tips and reviews

Vicky D.Vicky Davis: The hot dishes & daily specials are remarkable and the sandwich line is always the length of the place, but worth the wait. Not cheap, the portions are huge.

Victoria G.Victoria G: Finally get the hype for sandwiches. Best hot sandwiches I have ever had. Get the Sgt Sweet Pepper on a hero. It's off the menu.

David L.David Li: If you enjoy being fat, have them keep the skin on the turkey. Perfection

Murray's Cheese at Grand Central Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

9. Murray's Cheese at Grand Central Market

8.1
42nd St at Lexington Ave, New York, NY
Cheese Store · Turtle Bay · 38 tips and reviews

Kate F.Kate Furman: Excellent selection of cheeses and meats. The sales associates are super nice too.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: The uptown outpost of one our favorite cheese shops in the city. Smaller than the original and lacking in the awesome sandwiches, but great for grocery shopping or a quick snack.

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Village Voice is excited to have Murray's Cheese at the 2012 Choice Eats food fest! Full list of restaurants here: http://ow.ly/8QjDQ

Pathos Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

10. Pathos Cafe

7.5
932 1st Ave (at 51st), New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 5 tips and reviews

Paola V.Paola Venturini: Octopus, tuna tartar, and prosciutto and gorgonzola pizza. Sangria pitchers too.

Monday L.Monday Lisa: Nice outdoor seating but food very over priced for what it is. BF got a Cuban that looked like a 5th grader made a turkey sandwich and it was $15 🙄

Elvi R.Elvi Rod: This place is really nice a the food it's excellent!!

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

11. Starbucks

7.5
655 Lexington Ave, New York, NY
Coffee Shop · Midtown East · 23 tips and reviews

RCRC: Spacious and clean. Standard Sbux.

V. B.V. Bella: The new Hazelnut Macchiato is a must have!

Sexy L.Sexy LF: Need an infusion of energy? This Starbucks gives you a double dose. If Josie takes your order you'll be upbeat even if there's a line. She's got such a great spirit. Positive energy + coffee = power!

La Bellezza Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

12. La Bellezza Pizzeria

7.5
145 E 49th St (Between 3rd & Lexington), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Turtle Bay · 29 tips and reviews

Ricky S.Ricky Sherrill: You cannot go wrong because the pizza, calzones, and hot sandwiches are all good.

Jake B.Jake Baker: Amazing eggplant parm heroes here. One of the true great hole in the walls, but watch put for major food coma after lunch.

Nick R.Nick Rovisa: The chicken roll is perfect. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.

Mangia is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

13. Mangia

8.0
50 W 57th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 55 tips and reviews

Jane A.Jane A: Eggplant tomato soup and wild mushroom, pesto, mozzarella pizza are amazing!

Douglas K.Douglas Kurdziel: They have moved some hot sandwiches (like the wonderful Telera and steak sandwich) to the counter in the back - don't miss them!

Jackie B.Jackie Burnbaum: If you're an Italian food lover, this is heaven. From the chicken Milanese salad, goat cheese tarts, refreshing salads, great lunch spot

Del Frisco's Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

14. Del Frisco's Grille

7.7
50 Rockefeller Plz (Rockefeller Center), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Rockefeller Center · 101 tips and reviews

Elia C.Elia Clemente: The burger is to die for. The long island iced tea is top notch

Rewan P.Rewan Parti: Cheesesteak egg rolls, filet mignon and side of fries! Also order the flatbreads they are delicious.

Steve W.Steve W.: Cheesesteak Eggrolls for the sweet and spicy win

'Essen is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Midtown East, New York.

15. 'Essen

7.3
515 Madison Ave (at E 53rd St.), New York, NY
Deli · Midtown East · 28 tips and reviews

William O.William Ostrow: Vietnamese sandwiches in the back across from the salads are amazing. The tofu skin sandwich on sourdough was ridiculously tasty and fully packed. Ask for some hot peppers. Grab some free bread.

P-LO L.P-LO Louis: Their shrimp shumai udon soup is to die for :-) #enjoy

Imani G.Imani G: Shakes and Fresh juices are delicious and healthy.