3. Sofia Pizza Shoppe
7.3
989 1st Ave (btw 54th & 55th St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Sutton Place · 16 tips and reviews
Lee Hoffman: Very good slices - favs vodka, pepperoni, sausage
Matthew P: Spinach Dip pizza is amazing. Pepperoni Sicilian or Pepperoni slice is excellent. The Classica is really excellent as just a plain slice.
Robin Biegeleisen: I had a slice of vodka pizza with mushrooms that was absolutely delicious. The crust was crispy just like I like it. Will definitely return to try their other offerings.
4. My Pie
7.8
696 Lexington Ave (at E 57th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Midtown East · 61 tips and reviews
Gianmarco Di Michele: Amazing pepperoni and margherita!Yummy!
Tom M: Really great find - small location with 5-6 tables. Had margherita chickenparm and pepperoni pizza. Thinner grandma Roman style, great crust crunch, fresh ingredients. My rating 8.5 🍕 out of 10
Jean Lee: Don't know why it says it's expensive. It's only $4 for a slice of the best margherita pizza! All organic with no added sugar... You can taste the difference. Authentic Romana style!
8. Toasties East
8.2
6 E 48th St (btwn Madison & 5th Ave.), New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Midtown East · 25 tips and reviews
Vicky Davis: The hot dishes & daily specials are remarkable and the sandwich line is always the length of the place, but worth the wait. Not cheap, the portions are huge.
Victoria G: Finally get the hype for sandwiches. Best hot sandwiches I have ever had. Get the Sgt Sweet Pepper on a hero. It's off the menu.
David Li: If you enjoy being fat, have them keep the skin on the turkey. Perfection
10. Pathos Cafe
7.5
932 1st Ave (at 51st), New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 5 tips and reviews
Paola Venturini: Octopus, tuna tartar, and prosciutto and gorgonzola pizza. Sangria pitchers too.
Monday Lisa: Nice outdoor seating but food very over priced for what it is. BF got a Cuban that looked like a 5th grader made a turkey sandwich and it was $15 🙄
Elvi Rod: This place is really nice a the food it's excellent!!
12. La Bellezza Pizzeria
7.5
145 E 49th St (Between 3rd & Lexington), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Turtle Bay · 29 tips and reviews
Ricky Sherrill: You cannot go wrong because the pizza, calzones, and hot sandwiches are all good.
Jake Baker: Amazing eggplant parm heroes here. One of the true great hole in the walls, but watch put for major food coma after lunch.
Nick Rovisa: The chicken roll is perfect. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.
13. Mangia
8.0
50 W 57th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 55 tips and reviews
Jane A: Eggplant tomato soup and wild mushroom, pesto, mozzarella pizza are amazing!
Douglas Kurdziel: They have moved some hot sandwiches (like the wonderful Telera and steak sandwich) to the counter in the back - don't miss them!
Jackie Burnbaum: If you're an Italian food lover, this is heaven. From the chicken Milanese salad, goat cheese tarts, refreshing salads, great lunch spot