Oscar's Frozen Custard is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

1. Oscar's Frozen Custard

8.8
2362 S 108th St (W. Hayes St.), Milwaukee, WI
Ice Cream Parlor · 41 tips and reviews

Joe M.Joe M.: The best banana splits in Milwaukee!

TJ K.TJ K: Custard, burgers, shakes, fries..its all good.

Jennifer Y.Jennifer Yerkes: They have the best vanilla custard at the most reasonable price! Yes, I did an official taste test!!

Babe's Ice Cream is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

2. Babe's Ice Cream

8.1
2264 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI
Ice Cream Parlor · Bay View · 31 tips and reviews

Danielle K.Danielle Krause: The vegan options are fantastic! I esp love the Oreo overload ice cream and raspberry lemon Italian ice, the banana splits are delicious oh oh and the cakes! Mmm...

Geoff S.Geoff S.: Green Tea and Zanzibar Chocolate make for a great tasting ice cream!

Kim S.Kim S: Everything I've tried here was yummy! Tasted the Fat Elvis tonight...good stuff!!

Leon's Frozen Custard is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

3. Leon's Frozen Custard

9.2
3131 S 27th St (btw Oklahoma St & Euclid St.), Milwaukee, WI
Ice Cream Parlor · 102 tips and reviews

Ambers B.Ambers Blog: All custard. Cookie dough is a favorite.

John L.John Luetke: They only accept cash

mS.LyNn 💋mS.LyNn 💋: Hot Fudge Sundae with pecans.... nuff said :)

Classy Girl Cupcakes is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

4. Classy Girl Cupcakes

8.3
825 N Jefferson St (btwn Wells & Kilbourn), Milwaukee, WI
Cupcake Shop · Juneau Town · 23 tips and reviews

Marvin Z.Marvin Zingler: The chocolate peanut butter is amazingly. I bought fourjust for me!

Sarah B.Sarah Booth: Cheesecake cupcakes. Do I need to say any more? Read more.

Holden G.Holden Gehrung: Eat! Seriously...be fat cuz it's DELISH!

Purple Door Ice Cream is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

5. Purple Door Ice Cream

9.0
205 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI
Ice Cream Parlor · Walker's Point · 47 tips and reviews

Betsy S.Betsy Seip-Price: A flight of ice cream for $6! Try four flavors! The coffee flavors are always delicious and local coffee roasters are used. Very enviromentally friendly. Very community orientated business.

Christine T.Christine T.: Their espresso ice cream may be my favorite ice cream (ever).

Zabrina T.Zabrina T.: Fig and Black Tea ice cream is heavenly

Michael's Family Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

6. Michael's Family Restaurant

7.9
2220 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · Avenues West · 11 tips and reviews

Adam P.Adam Peleshok: Solid diner and great service. 5 stars

puckpuck: The corn beef hash rocks

TiaraTiara: Breakfast was sooooo yummy!!!

Nite Owl Ice Cream Parlour is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

7. Nite Owl Ice Cream Parlour

7.7
830 E Layton Ave (btw Layton Ave & Pine Ave), Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · Town of Lake · 32 tips and reviews

Jason K.Jason Konen: Awesome malts. Good burgers.

Diana V.Diana Voigt: This is the best burger in the world!!

Brian A.Brian Artka: Local joint. Awesome burgers, awesome ice cream. Did I mention it's local? Great Milwaukee only location and it's been there for years.

Milwaukee Chophouse is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

8. Milwaukee Chophouse

7.7
633 N 5th St (Hilton Milwaukee City Center), Milwaukee, WI
Steakhouse · Kilbourn Town · 13 tips and reviews

Tim J.Tim Johnson: Great prime rib and even better service from Derek. Come on Sunday for the 3 course special. Can't go wrong!

VISIT MilwaukeeVISIT Milwaukee: Try a blue cheese crust on your steak! Mmmm....

Conversational L.Conversational Lush: Great food!!!!

Athens Family Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Banana Split in Milwaukee.

9. Athens Family Restaurant

5547 N Lovers Lane Rd, Milwaukee, WI
Greek Restaurant · Timmerman West · 16 tips and reviews

Maria P.Maria Pflugradt: Its got excellent fish fry, excellent Sunday breakfast buffet. Plus. Our waitress tonight was excellent!

CindyLee H.CindyLee Hopper: Julie, Pam N and Pam W are the Best Servers here!!! They think of stuff you need even before you do!!! I LUV THIS PLACE :-D

Kiwi T.Kiwi Truthbtold: The broccoli cheddar soup sooo good