Canfora Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

1. Canfora Bakery

8.2
1100 E Oklahoma Ave (at S. Herman St), Milwaukee, WI
Bakery · Bay View · 22 tips and reviews

Carrie O.Carrie Orlowski: Great american potato salad

Lori L.Lori L: They have great breads, to-go sandwiches and always hot ham and rolls on Sunday. It is a terrific Italian bakery nestled in Bay View.

Mike T.Mike T.: Fantastic bakery with the best donuts in the area. A little wait on weekends but that is because they're great! Read more.

Grebe's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

2. Grebe's Bakery

8.8
5132 W Lincoln Ave, Milwaukee, WI
Bakery · 25 tips and reviews

Melissa R.Melissa Reyes-Rivera: Love coming to the hot ham and rolls with the coleslaw and potato salad. Best in the city

Greg W.Greg Wiedenhoeft: Every great fast service

Toshiro M.Toshiro Mifune: Try the crullers - the best anywhere!

Milwaukee Brat House is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

3. Milwaukee Brat House

8.2
1013 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI
Pub · Kilbourn Town · 97 tips and reviews

Justin M.Justin Marks: German style brat, pretzel, potato salad.

Mark E.Mark Ericson: Get the jalapeño brat with potato salad

Caskey H.Caskey Hunsader: Thursday drink special (3 for 1) and German brat with side of fried cheese curds...perfection!

Rupena's Fine Foods is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

4. Rupena's Fine Foods

7.8
7641 W Beloit Rd, Milwaukee, WI
Grocery Store · 17 tips and reviews

Amy B.Amy Bauer: Grandma's potato salad ftw!

Tom S.Tom Schneeberg: We love getting the hot ham and rolls. Their deli and meat selections are top notch. Great local independent neighborhood grocer.

Duane D.Duane Drzadinski: Like fresh, locally roasted coffee? They sell Sven's. Nice!

West Allis Cheese & Sausage is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

5. West Allis Cheese & Sausage

8.4
400 N Water St (at E St Paul Ave), Milwaukee, WI
Sandwich Spot · Juneau Town · 15 tips and reviews

Dennis J.Dennis Jenders: Love the Cheezy Joe, it's my go to sandwich!

Tim C.Tim Cigelske: Get the chocolate cheese.

Abigail N.Abigail Naumann: Woah. Cheese curds are out of this world.

Jake's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

6. Jake's Deli

8.5
1634 W North Ave (17th St), Milwaukee, WI
Deli · 25 tips and reviews

Juan P.Juan Phillips: Pastrami is the best. Corned beef is so tender it melts in your mouth.

BroidyBroidy: I grew up in NYC and I can say this place has legit Jewish style deli food. Can't go wrong with the Reuben or anything pastrami or corned beef based.

Nick L.Nick Lyons: The best corned beef/ reuben you'll ever have in your life. End of discussion. See how it's meant to be done.

Oscar's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

7. Oscar's Frozen Custard

8.7
2362 S 108th St (W. Hayes St.), Milwaukee, WI
Ice Cream Parlor · 41 tips and reviews

Joe P.Joe Priewe: The mushroom and swiss is the best in town! Love it! :-D

Jennifer Y.Jennifer Yerkes: They have the best vanilla custard at the most reasonable price! Yes, I did an official taste test!!

Kelsey P.Kelsey P.: Great custard. Try Chocolate Covered Cherry or Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough flavors of the day in a waffle cone.

Kegel's Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

8. Kegel's Inn

8.5
5901 W National Ave, Milwaukee, WI
German Restaurant · 37 tips and reviews

Elizabeth G.Elizabeth G: Great German food! Friday fish fry is amazing.

JamesJames: Good sauerbraten and spaetzel!

ᴡ P.ᴡ Paddock: So far so good :)

Turner Hall Ballroom is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

9. Turner Hall Ballroom

8.4
1040 N 4th St (at W Highland Ave), Milwaukee, WI
Concert Hall · Kilbourn Town · 46 tips and reviews

Michael D.Michael Davis: Nice beer selection, decent prices for downtown cool atmosphere. A great place to go after Bradley Center events!

Ryan M.Ryan Matteson: If you're 21+, it doesn't get much cheaper than a $3 PBR Tall Boy! Great beer selection, NOT at concert prices!

Jeff C.Jeff Carter: Good German food and good local beer

Mader's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

10. Mader's Restaurant

8.2
1037 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI
German Restaurant · Kilbourn Town · 39 tips and reviews

Kevin A.Kevin Anderson: Great lunch from start to finish. Pretzel bread to start. Excellent service. Great range of dishes from traditional German to an option or two for vegetarians.

Late Night M.Late Night Marquette: Marquette students get 10% discount off entire food purchase. You have to show your MUID!

Katie B.Katie B: OMG the pretzel rolls are incredible. Great place, good food cool bar fun! A must while in Milwuakee

Gold Rush Chicken is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

11. Gold Rush Chicken

7.6
3500 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI
Fried Chicken Joint · Tippecanoe · 5 tips and reviews

Tim J.Tim Jackson: best chicken around

GDGD: Only 2 left of this icon in the city. The best fried chicken anywhere.

Beba l.Beba la loquilla: Good chicken

El Rey Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

12. El Rey Market

7.6
3524 W Burnham St (35th St), Milwaukee, WI
Mexican Restaurant · Burnham Park · 16 tips and reviews

Duane D.Duane Drzadinski: Try the horchata (Mexican rice water) in the restaurant. The cinnamon adds just the right touch to make it delicious!

HonniHonni: Best tamales and puerto rican rice in the city!

Jeff P.Jeff P: Incredibly fast service for a quality sit-down lunch.

The Honey Baked Ham Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

13. The Honey Baked Ham Company

7.4
817 N. Mayfair Road, Milwaukee, WI
Deli · 4 tips and reviews

Betty W.Betty Walker: You should try this place. They have the best ham.

Toy M.Toy McKinney: The Tavern Club is the best!

JasmineJasmine: Try the smoke stacker!

JJ Fish & Chicken is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

14. JJ Fish & Chicken

7.3
1334 N 35th St, Milwaukee, WI
Seafood Restaurant · 2 tips and reviews

Andrew G.Andrew Glaser: Get the extra crack for the fries. It's the way to go

Jamal W.Jamal Washington: This is one of the better JJ's in the city. Their perch is good.

Casablanca is one of The 15 Best Places for Potato Salad in Milwaukee.

15. Casablanca

8.4
728 E Brady St (N Cass St), Milwaukee, WI
Middle Eastern Restaurant · Lower East Side · 110 tips and reviews

Danny R.Danny R: First time eating here and enjoyed it. Try the Shish kabob with salad. Very good. $5 martinis on Thursday.

Mike K.Mike Kramer: Enjoy the hummus. It's really good

Romke d.Romke de Haan: Shady service made reservations for 10 got charged for 14. Wouldn't negotiate on price. Never coming here again.