Creole Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

1. Creole Creamery

9.3
4924 Prytania St, New Orleans, LA
Ice Cream Parlor · Uptown · 123 tips and reviews

Sami B.Sami Brisson: Peanut butter fudge pie in a waffle cone was so good I thought I would die.

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Peanut Butter Fudge Pie Ice Cream - Excellent. With a scoop of Cookie Monster below it (chocolate chip cookie dough with crushed Oreos and chips ahoy cookies)

Donovan F.Donovan F.: Peanut Butter Fudge Pie is among my faves. Bring back Chartreuse flavor!

Bayona is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

2. Bayona

8.5
430 Dauphine St (btwn St. Louis and Conti), New Orleans, LA
New American Restaurant · French Quarter · 57 tips and reviews

Trisha W.Trisha Wood: The peanut butter duck was to die for.

Gloria C.Gloria Chin: try the smoked dush cashew peanut butter and pepper jelly sandwich, honey lavendar ice cream, garlic soup & sweetbreads

TripExpertTripExpert: A tip from our expert reviewer, Fodors: "A legendary favorite at lunch is the sandwich of smoked duck, cashew peanut butter, and pepper jelly." -On TripExpert Read more.

Copper Monkey is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

3. Copper Monkey

8.3
725 Conti St (Bourbon), New Orleans, LA
American Restaurant · French Quarter · 36 tips and reviews

Justin W.Justin Wall: My favorite place in the quarter. Cheap drinks great food and service! Lorna and Marisa are awesome. If you wanna try something different try the peanut butter burger!

Jordyn G.Jordyn Giddens: Highly reccommend the peanut butter burger!

Brandie C.Brandie Creswell: Try the peanut butter burger!!

Le Pavillon Hotel is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

4. Le Pavillon Hotel

8.0
833 Poydras St, New Orleans, LA
Hotel · Central Business District · 56 tips and reviews

Randy B.Randy Bernsen: Great location, great vibe. Pool deck is nice and the peanut butter and jelly late night sandwiches! Oh. Food/buffet ,,,'n'awlins all the way.

The Leading Hotels of the WorldThe Leading Hotels of the World: Le Pavillon Hotel serves peanut butter and jelly sandwiches every evening in their lobby! Read more.

Chad T.Chad Tovar: Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are super good!!! Look for them at10pm

Pêche is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

5. Pêche

9.3
800 Magazine St (Julia), New Orleans, LA
Seafood Restaurant · Lower Garden District · 204 tips and reviews

FacePaulm R.FacePaulm Revere: Peanut butter banana chocolate pie. Omg.

Juan G.Juan Geldres: There's no banana in the chocolate peanut butter banana pie.

Lears F.Lears Fool: Peanut butter banana pie FTW

Cochon Butcher is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

6. Cochon Butcher

9.4
930 Tchoupitoulas St (at Andrew Higgins St), New Orleans, LA
Sandwich Spot · Lower Garden District · 585 tips and reviews

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - With candied spicy peanuts. One of the best peanut butter things I've eaten.

KenKen: The Elvis king cake is filled with peanut butter, banana and house-cured bacon and topped with marshmallow and traditional Mardi Gras decoration. A small pink pig replaces the baby. @Gambit

Vino50: Grape American Road TripVino50: Grape American Road Trip: Try the Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - #chocolate #peanutbutter pie @cochondining New Orleans. #orgasm #foodporn #nomnomnom

The Joint is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

7. The Joint

9.0
701 Mazant St (at Royal), New Orleans, LA
BBQ Joint · Bywater · 131 tips and reviews

Gambit New OrleansGambit New Orleans: Peanut Butter Indulgences: after smoky barbecue, try this light, nutty mousse in pie crust. -Gambit's Five in 5

Plwm B.Plwm Bwm: Brisket is the best meat. Mac n Cheese is the best side. Peanut Butter pie is the best dessert

Guy D.Guy Davidi: Peanut butter pie

Restaurant R'evolution is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

8. Restaurant R'evolution

9.0
777 Bienville St, New Orleans, LA
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · French Quarter · 81 tips and reviews

Pete D.Pete Dumont: Incredible food, service. Great ambiance. LOVED this place! Try the homemade peanut butter ice cream.

Kevin L.Kevin Lilly: HANDS DOWN THE BEST RESTAURANT IN NOLA... Get the Filet, Crab Beignets and the Peanut Butter Ice Cream.. Thank me later

Ariana V.Ariana Voyer: Crab beignets were lightly fried, filled w/plenty of crab. The tuna tartare was unique & delicious. The chocolate cake was also light and flavorful! Lastly, the NOLA Mule was very absinthe-forward👍🏻

Ralph's On The Park is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

9. Ralph's On The Park

8.7
900 City Park Avenue, New Orleans, LA
Southern Food Restaurant · City Park · 31 tips and reviews

Gambit New OrleansGambit New Orleans: Peanut Butter Indulgences: try a sweet terrine of peanut butter ice cream, peanut praline and chocolate. -Gambit's Five in 5

Genny D.Genny Dean: Amazing food at a great location across from city park. Large upstairs location for big group meals

Gambit New OrleansGambit New Orleans: Crazy for crabmeat? Crab is made into a Napoleon with couscous, roasted corn and salsa verde - "Gambit's Five in 5" Read more.

Creole Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

10. Creole Creamery

8.4
6260 Vicksburg St, New Orleans, LA
Ice Cream Parlor · Lakeview · 15 tips and reviews

James W.James Welch: My family loves this place. Try a Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae. Amazing!

Cyn F.Cyn Ful: Chocolate Amaretto Cheesecake & Caramel Chickory Chocolate is the best!

Cody Y.Cody Yocom: Enjoyed the King Cake flavor during Mardis Gras season.

Southern Candymakers is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

11. Southern Candymakers

9.0
334 Decatur St, New Orleans, LA
Candy Store · French Quarter · 43 tips and reviews

AlexisseAlexisse: Best coconut pralines and white chocolate dipped peanut butter ritz crackers ever. Delicious. Coupon for 10% off in maps given at hotels.

Nicole E.Nicole Eparvier: Best pralines in town! Looks a bit dodgy from the outside but absolutely wonderful on the inside! A hidden gem.

Waymon M.Waymon Morris: You have to try the tortues!!!

Twelve Mile Limit is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

12. Twelve Mile Limit

9.0
500 S Telemachus St (Baudin), New Orleans, LA
Cocktail Bar · Mid-City · 32 tips and reviews

Candice H.Candice Huber: The peanut butter cup cupcake is awesome!!

Charlene F.Charlene Foote: The Baudin.... Yummy, spicy drink.

Bridget M.Bridget M: The baudin cocktail is delish! The tater tots and coleslaw are hands down most amazing I have ever had. Make sure to eat here. Smoke free Saturday - Monday!

Southern Candy Makers (French Market) is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

13. Southern Candy Makers (French Market)

8.3
723 Saint Peter St (at St Philip St), New Orleans, LA
Candy Store · French Quarter · 18 tips and reviews

Christin "X1" L.Christin "X1" L: Excellent Pralines - original, chocolate, peanut butter, sweet potato and more.

LeeAnn T.LeeAnn Talarico: Absolutely the best praline in NOLA, and I tried them all!

Ferne K.Ferne Kilcollum: Tried the top 5 praline shops per Yelp and yes, these are the best.

Loretta's Pralines is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

14. Loretta's Pralines

8.2
2101 N Rampart St (Frenchman), New Orleans, LA
Bakery · Marigny · 8 tips and reviews

Jennifer E.Jennifer Edwards: They have the best pralines! Peanut butter and chocolate were my personal favorites.

Nicole C.Nicole Cheramie: This famous bakery lays claim to New Orleans famous praline dessert. Get praline beignets for a rich, sweet treat or savory beignets stuffed with crab or bbq chicken. Open Tuesday through Saturday.

Nicole C.Nicole Cheramie: This famous bakery lays claim to New Orleans famous praline dessert. Get praline beignets for a rich, sweet treat or savory beignets stuffed with crab or bbq chicken. Open Tuesday through Saturday.

Golden Lantern is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in New Orleans.

15. Golden Lantern

8.1
1239 Royal St, New Orleans, LA
Gay Bar · French Quarter · 28 tips and reviews

heather g.heather galloway: Ask Andy for the peanut butter and jelly shot! Incredible!

Russ G.Russ Gloria: Fun neighborhood bar. Fun people. Good service. Will be back to visit!

Jerry C.Jerry C: Bottoms up, the best Bloody Marys in New Orleans! You won't be disappointed.