1. Fat Witch Bakery
7.9
75 9th Ave (Chelsea Market), New York, NY
Bakery · Chelsea · 72 tips and reviews
Natasha Taylor: Oh yes, I have been coming here for years and it still produces one of the best brownies in New York. Love the original, the snow and the blondie.
Bianca Evangelista: Caramel brownie is definitely a must try!
Jinnie L: gotta try their brownies, best brownies ever!♥ this place is well worth a visit!
2. Chelsea Market
9.2
75 9th Ave (btwn W 15th & W 16th St), New York, NY
Market · Chelsea · 1218 tips and reviews
Dora: Try some of the best brownies in NYC at the Fat Witch Bakery. Mini variety packs are perfect for sampling. Powered by ParentsConnect.com
Samantha K: Amazing food venue... hard to pick your sweet treat with Jacques Torres Wicked Hot Chocolate, Fatwich Brownies, Eleni'sCupcakes and Amy's Bread all under the same roof!!
Ana Salles: The best place in the city to buy vegetables and fruits. The italian market has some amazing cheeses and pasta. It's also great for lunch. You'll also find the best brownie from NY.
4. Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery
9.3
28 Greenwich Ave (Charles Street), New York, NY
Bakery · West Village · 62 tips and reviews
Mike Friedlich: One of the best bakeries in NYC. The must have is the delicious brownie. The dark chocolate explosion cookies are excellent, & although the chocolate chip cookie is not the best ever it is very good.
Sarah: Dark chocolate lover's delight! Brownies, cookies and cake. Friendly service with careful attention to allergy details, too.
scott ...: The chocolate explosion is rather delicious. The density, consistency, and texture are closer to a brownie than a traditional cookie.
6. By the Way Bakery
8.8
1236 Lexington Ave, New York, NY
Bakery · Upper East Side · 8 tips and reviews
Karlina Gonzalez: everything is great! they can check for allergens upon request! almond cookies, brownie cookies, orange almond cake are grain free and so delicious!!
Selina M.: Totally gluten-free and diary-free bakery - simply awesome! I have chosen the apple crumble cake and the brownie: both were yummy and moisty!
Paige C: Delicious cakes and cupcakes. You would never know they were gluten free!
jessica m. hintermeister: Umber Ahmad sweets 😵 - dark chocolate brownies, choc chip cookies, Mah Ze Dahr bars, vanilla bean shortbread... round em' up.
Jacqueline To: Great coffee and the dark chocolate brownie was good
Caitlin Clements: NY Mag recommends the brownie!
12. Beyond Sushi
8.9
134 W 37th St, New York, NY
Sushi Restaurant · Garment District · 13 tips and reviews
Diana: Dumplings, noodle salads, mango sushi roll, coconut ice cream with rose petals and sweet potato brownie!
Stu Goldman: Dumplings were delicious. The warm brownie with chocolate ice cream was sinful
Linda Le: 👌 Flower Top Dumplings, Spicy Mango Roll, & Sweet Tree Roll
Pooja: Try the tofu skin wraps, seitan skewers, and smoked teriyaki seitan. If you still need more to fill you, the brownie dessert is great!
Evie: Bibimbap to fill you up and the crispy fudged brownie to finish!
Dan Jones: Great decor and very healthy, tasty food. This place has literally the best vegan brownie I've ever had. Should have bought 10+ of them.
15. Magnolia Bakery
8.1
1240 Avenue of the Americas (at W 49th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Rockefeller Center · 682 tips and reviews
Racky Ross: I am addicted to their brownies and the hot chocolate... Way tastier, creamier and also cheaper than elsewhere
Rahul Rishi: Brownies and ice cream sandwich were amazing
D C🐧: Marble brownie, vanilla cupcake, and ofc the amazing banana bread pudding