Sidecar at P.J. Clarke's is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

1. Sidecar at P.J. Clarke's

7.9
205 E 55th St (3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Speakeasy · Midtown East · 8 tips and reviews

sean r.sean roberts: Great creamy tomato soup and salmon. Very cool atmosphere.

Mark H.Mark Heyert: Excellent tater tots, crab cakes, beet salad, and the bartenders are sweet and funny.

Michael W.Michael Witbrock: Cocktails, old fashioned wedge salad, steak

Tamarind TriBeCa is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

2. Tamarind TriBeCa

9.0
99 Hudson St (at Franklin St), New York, NY
Indian Restaurant · Tribeca · 157 tips and reviews

Travel + LeisureTravel + Leisure: An outpost of a Flatiron district restaurant by the same name. Try the chicken tikka masala: tandoori chicken tikka in a creamy tomato and fenugreek sauce.

Kate H.Kate Huyett: Order the lasuni gobi - cauliflower fried with tomato and ginger. It's not on the menu but it's my favorite thing here

The Wall Street JournalThe Wall Street Journal: Plush banquettes and sizable booths make this Indian restaurant ideal for private business meetings. But after a three-course lunch, you may be more in the mood for a nap. Read more.

Baccarat Hotel is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

3. Baccarat Hotel

9.1
28 W 53rd St, New York, NY
Hotel · 34 tips and reviews

Soeske H.Soeske Hartjes: I love drinking an espresso here. It's so relaxing and a perfect, zen, tranquil environment. Amazing.

Mariah B.Mariah Boyd: File under: chicest place in Midtown.

Rameeka H.Rameeka Hinton: The drinks are really good. The place is really relaxing

Paname is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

4. Paname

7.7
1068 2nd Ave, New York, NY
French Restaurant · Midtown East · 10 tips and reviews

Paname French R.Paname French Restaurant: Perfect cut before the act of grilling prime for carnivores only at paname french restaurant1068 second Ave bet 56x57 st nyc capp212 207 3737 for priced fixed dinner the town best value

Levent A.Levent A.K.A. Progressive: Try cod fish. It is amazing.

Bruce M. F.Bruce M. Foster: For those made a habit of Meli Melo on Madison Avenue...

Blue Valley Deli & Grocery is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

5. Blue Valley Deli & Grocery

7.6
570 Avenue of the Americas (at W 16th St), New York, NY
Deli · Union Square · 6 tips and reviews

Nicky K.Nicky K.: Surprisingly hard to find a decent egg sandwich in the area. This place has the best one!

ErikErik: Always has good hot lunch/dinner selections, and, more importantly, beer and blow-pops

Nicky P.Nicky Petroni: Dirt cheap bodega food, that’s it

Swagat is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

6. Swagat

8.3
411 Amsterdam Ave (btwn 80th St & 79th St), New York, NY
Indian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 39 tips and reviews

Gabriel A.Gabriel Agostini: The garlic naan is a must with any saucy dish. The chicken Mangalorean and the chicken malai kebab are excellent

Paula R.Paula Ragucci: delicious food! chicken tikka masala + garlic naan.

Gordon L.Gordon Landwirth: Best Indian on Upper West Side

Anassa Taverna is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

7. Anassa Taverna

8.2
200 E 60th St, New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Upper East Side · 56 tips and reviews

Samantha F.Samantha Falotico: Delicious and amazing atmosphere. Get their eggplant dip!

Jodi G.Jodi Goodman: Incredible restaurant very reasonably priced with a dope atmosphere. Even a dj. Also next door to bloomies and Dylan's candy bar :)

Jenny K.Jenny K: Delicious food, prompt service and wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend the striped bass and walnut cake. A lovely new addition to neighborhood!

Nerai is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

8. Nerai

8.0
55 E 54th St, New York, NY
Greek Restaurant · Midtown East · 42 tips and reviews

AljoharahAljoharah: Exquisite dinning experience. Everything was absolutely delicious! Highly recommended 💯

rahul d.rahul d: Great King Salmon w/ spinach rice & crispy leeks

Leon J.Leon Josowitz: Salad tomatoes not good, zucchini chips soggy. I've had better Greek food.

Spice Symphony is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

9. Spice Symphony

8.2
182 Lexington Ave (b/t E 31st & E 32nd Sts.), New York, NY
Indian Restaurant · Rose Hill · 49 tips and reviews

ZenFoodsterZenFoodster: Tasty & spicy Indo-Chinese: Shrimp Piri Piri, Ckn Tikka Masala, Paneer Szechwan, Ckn Malai Kabob & Salmon Tikka. Pricey & no lunch specials on wkend. Ask to turn on AC to help U sweat thru the spice!

Daniel G.Daniel George: the chicken is incredibly tender and moist. try the chicken biryani or tikka masala. some of the best biryani I've tried.

Kavita B.Kavita Baba: Off menu Hakka noodles are yum

Malai Marke is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

10. Malai Marke

8.6
318 E 6th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Indian Restaurant · East Village · 79 tips and reviews

Noah W.Noah Weiss: From the owners of Dhaba (best indian in NYC), this is the best restaurant on Curry row. Lots of coastal curries you won't normally find. The more spicy and coconut-y, the better.

The Wall Street JournalThe Wall Street Journal: Break out of the chicken tikka masala rut with the coondapur kori, a flavorful, deep-orange coconut chicken curry from the coastal city of Mangalore. Read more.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Not your average Curry Row restaurant. The huge menu has dishes from all over India, and most of them succeed.

La Masseria is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

11. La Masseria

8.8
235 W 48th St (at 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 87 tips and reviews

Stephanie G.Stephanie Gareri: Cheesecake was insane - light and yummy!! Risotto was delicious. Burrata was fresh. Comfy atmosphere.

Ivana G.Ivana Goldstein: The cheesecake is to die for!!!! Never had a better one.

Alex M.Alex M: Wi-Fi password - lamasserianyc

Tandoor Oven is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

12. Tandoor Oven

7.7
175 East 83rd Street (btw Lexington Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
North Indian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 28 tips and reviews

Abbie N.Abbie Normal: Best raita and garlic naan I've ever had!!!!

Kai T.Kai Technolust: Really good vindaloo, excellent service! Our water glasses never went below 1/4 full and we were meeting a friend from Ohio so even after we paid we stayed to talk & they brought water.

MN R.MN R: Great service! Very nice and friendly staff. And the food was delicious. Garlic naan was my favorite. But tikka masala was great too. The rice pudding was a nice way to top it off.

Masala King is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

13. Masala King

7.3
64 E 34th St, New York, NY
North Indian Restaurant · NoMad · 2 tips and reviews

Victoria D.Victoria Dixon: All you can eat Indian buffet (with desserts!) at a great price. A much welcome addition to 34th St!

Angelo F.Angelo Franco: Best Indian ever. Most attentive service.

D Elici is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

14. D Elici

7.4
71 Nassau St, New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Financial District · 10 tips and reviews

Kimmie O.Kimmie Ohh: I’ve only been here for their breakfast sandwiches. They make bomb sausage egg & cheese sandwiches & bomb bacon egg & cheese sandwiches! Cashiers are always friendly & always smile so early in the AM.

RobespierreRobespierre: ALL DAY BREAKFAST! Winning.

Christine Y.Christine YO: Cubans ... Mmm

Cibo E Vino is one of The 15 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in New York City.

15. Cibo E Vino

7.4
2418 Broadway (89th street), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 14 tips and reviews

Alice S.Alice Savta: Excellent special salmon!! Excellent lamb chops!! Very good service! Enjoyed the deserts too. Definetly wiil be back.

The Right IngredientThe Right Ingredient: CIbo & Vino at 89th/Bway is my favorite new place in UWS. Best clams vongole!

Melissa F.Melissa Ford: Very accommodating to vegetarians!