NYPD Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

1. NYPD Pizza

7.9
2589 S Hiawassee Rd (Metrowest Blvd), Orlando, FL
Pizzeria · Metro West · 32 tips and reviews

NYPD P.NYPD Pizza: February 99Cent Slice is the Sicilian! YUMMS

Terri/Love & ConfectionsTerri/Love & Confections: 2 for Tuesdays! Buy any specialty pizza, get a cheese pizza free! (excludes 10" & sicilian)

Brandi H.Brandi Helman: You will leave totally stuffed! Truly the best pizza place in Orlando!

Carrabba's Italian Grill is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

2. Carrabba's Italian Grill

8.3
5701 Vineland Rd, Orlando, FL
Italian Restaurant · 30 tips and reviews

Amelia J.Amelia Johnson: Mama Mandola's Sicilian chicken soup is fantastic!

Zulkeira R. S.Zulkeira R. Stefchak: Chicken Bryan is my fave..goat cheese on chicken is heaven ;)

Pauly H.Pauly Hurley: request the pesto maybe they'll put it back on the menu

Anthony's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

3. Anthony's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

8.1
N Summerlin Ave (Washington St), Orlando, FL
Pizzeria · South Eola · 44 tips and reviews

Oscar T.Oscar Toller: Had a Sicilian with meatballs. Very disappointed. It was cold when I got it and the sause was bland.

Willie C.Willie Cabrera: Pizza here is really good. So far this is my favorite pizza spot in all of Orlando . Try the Bianca!

Alexandrea W.Alexandrea West: The Greek Salad is great!

California Pizza Kitchen is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

4. California Pizza Kitchen

8.5
4200 Conroy Rd Ste 251 (at The Mall at Millenia), Orlando, FL
Pizzeria · Millenia · 54 tips and reviews

Flavia W.Flavia Walter: Great pizza and pasta. Try the Kung Pao Spaghetti! They also have a gluten free menu

Orlando InformerOrlando Informer: The Avocado Club Spring Rolls might be the best thing on the menu!

Will L.Will LeBlanc: BBQ Chicken Pizza...original I know. So good!

Pie-Fection is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

5. Pie-Fection

8.4
3120 S Kirkman Rd, Orlando, FL
Pizzeria · Metro West · 55 tips and reviews

Callum K.Callum Kerr: Absolutely fantastic pizza, we had a great time when we were there! Watch the pizza sizes though, took us by surprise - they're so big! :)

Gabrielle C.Gabrielle Costa: Best pizza in Orlando

Tony C.Tony Claitor: Extremely satisfied! They made our delicious pasta and pizza in front of us with a smile! Decently priced. Definitely recommend it. :D

Olive Garden is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

6. Olive Garden

8.8
4101 Conroy Rd (Millenia Blvd), Orlando, FL
Italian Restaurant · Millenia · 51 tips and reviews

Cristina T.Cristina Tavares: Always nice! Good food and wine!! Can't miss it! 😋

Kimberly M.Kimberly Mccaslin: It's all about the chicken Alfredo!

Moonlamoo ..Moonlamoo .: Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken😍

Greens & Grille is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

7. Greens & Grille

8.7
4104 Millenia Blvd (conroy rd), Orlando, FL
Salad Restaurant · Millenia · 55 tips and reviews

Dwayne W.Dwayne Wynns: Great organic food in a contemporary setting. Try the summer sweets with salmon or the cali Cobb with tiger shrimp

Doug B.Doug Berger: Worst service. The Russian girl needs an attitude adjustment.

Caleb D.Caleb Dean: Good food, but absolutely worthless & clueless staff.

Papa D's Pizza and Pasta is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

8. Papa D's Pizza and Pasta

7.2
5106 Dr Phillips Blvd, Orlando, FL
Pizzeria · Grand Oaks Village · 18 tips and reviews

Brian B.Brian Blazejewski: This is the owner of the Donatos restaurant from the 1990's in the marketplace (for you old school Orlando folks). Best pizza outside of New York you MUST try this place! There is no better!

Brian S.Brian Snell: NY taste, NY feel, folded with melted cheese

Steven M.Steven Mumby: Stromboli! Excellent!

Pizzeria Del Dio is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

9. Pizzeria Del Dio

7.6
3210 E Colonial Dr (at Maguire Blvd.), Orlando, FL
Italian Restaurant · Colonial Town Center · 21 tips and reviews

David B.David Brim: The pizza toppings are all very fresh! I always get pepporoni, sausage and bacon...yum!

Tasty Chomps O.Tasty Chomps Orlando Food Blog: Truly the best pizza in Orlando

Anissa R.Anissa Rodriguez: The pizza is amazing, but for me, the best thing is the fresh baked focaccia bread. This is the real Little Italy in Orlando. All it's missing is a Bocce court in the back.

Italian Pie And Pasta House is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

10. Italian Pie And Pasta House

7.4
1400 S Crystal Lake Dr (Crystal Lake Rd & Curry Ford Rd), Orlando, FL
Italian Restaurant · Lake Como · 11 tips and reviews

Shatina R.Shatina Rogers: Try the bacon, pepperoni & Italian sausage Calzone. EXCELLENT!! And they have great salads..

Randy D.Randy Davison: Beware, they no longer do lunch menu on the weekend. You should only eat here during the week to avoid their high prices.

Sara C.Sara Carbone: Sooooo good!

Olive Garden is one of The 11 Best Places for Sicilian in Orlando.

11. Olive Garden

7.2
3111 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL
Italian Restaurant · Colonial Town Center · 45 tips and reviews

Flores8Flores8: Soup is great. Lobster raviolis are delicious. Take Pinot Noir 667, and enjoy.

william r.william ramsey: Tour of Italy is awesome

Annette M.Annette McDougall: Bring on the salad, nothing better, also enjoyed the north tour of italy