Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

1. Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop

8.9
925 Western Ave, Pittsburgh, PA
Sandwich Spot · North Side · 32 tips and reviews

Scott KleinbergScott Kleinberg: Steak sub is so good! Save room for fries.

CheapismCheapism: There is a very large menu, with catering and subs for fund raising. They serve loaded subs, and even have specilty subs named after local sports stars. Read more.

erin d.erin duffy: Great Subs!!!! And great employees!!! And they are open on Steeler Sundays!

Deli on Butler Street is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

2. Deli on Butler Street

7.9
4034 Butler St (Main St), Pittsburgh, PA
Sandwich Spot · Central Lawrenceville · 4 tips and reviews

Chris P.Chris P.: Chicken pesto panini is delicious. Nice people. Good small little deli.

Norman P.Norman Papernick: The summer wrap is tasty

Alex C.Alex Cressman: They sell Everfresh...yum!

Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

3. Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop

7.8
1721 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA
Sandwich Spot · Strip District · 20 tips and reviews

Kyle J.Kyle Jennings: Great food, cool place. Try the cheesesteak you won't be let down!!!

ShortyShorty: The Joey Porter...tasty AF!

Walter A.Walter Acevedo: Take your time. Usually slow service.

Uncle Sam's Subs is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

4. Uncle Sam's Subs

7.7
5808 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA
Sandwich Spot · Squirrel Hill South · 16 tips and reviews

Patrick R.Patrick Rieger: Always very yummy! Always too much for one meal, so half of the sandwich goes home.

Abby K.Abby K.: definitely order the sweet potato fries.

Monica T.Monica Takacs: Make sure to bring cash or you don't eat.

Deli On North Avenue is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

5. Deli On North Avenue

7.3
4 E North Ave (at Federal St), Pittsburgh, PA
Deli · Central Northside · 6 tips and reviews

Andrea H.Andrea H: Fantastic sandwiches. The owner was very friendly and helpful. Ask for suggestions. Boar's Head meats and cheeses. Delicious!

John K.John Kocur: Get the Pasquale!!!

Jane B.Jane Branicky: Tell pete you want the arrosto dimanzo. I like it with mustard.

La Gondola is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

6. La Gondola

7.3
4 Market Sq, Pittsburgh, PA
Pizzeria · Fifth and Forbes Corridor · 7 tips and reviews

Marlena Z.Marlena Zollars: Love their pizza. The cheese stretches fooorrrreeevvveeerrr. So yummy. Jus wish they delivered

Chavonte M.Chavonte Martin: Its was great service and the food was awesome.

Christian S.Christian Stofko: Good pizza. Extremely slow service.

Uncle Sam's Subs is one of The 7 Best Places for Italian Sandwiches in Pittsburgh.

7. Uncle Sam's Subs

7.4
936 Freeport Rd (in Waterworks Mall), Pittsburgh, PA
Sandwich Spot · 19 tips and reviews

Dave F.Dave Forman: They're cash-only. You get two 6-inch halves and hot and crispy shoestring fries if you eat-in. Can't go wrong with any of the steaks, but don't overlook the italian (hot), sausage, or portobello.

James W.James Watt: Get the bacon cheeseburger sub.

Samuel F.Samuel French: All the sandwiches are awesome. But they only take cash.