The Milk Shake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

1. The Milk Shake Factory

8.4
1705 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Southside Flats · 61 tips and reviews

Terri O.Terri Orlowski: The peanut butter & jelly shake is wonderful! I highly recommend trying it.

Christina C.Christina Chodor: The peanut butter chocolate covered pretzels are AMAZING!

Matt W.Matt Wolford: Try the Peanut Butter Meltaway sundae...but get it with chocolate ice cream! Man'o'mannnn

OTB Bicycle Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

2. OTB Bicycle Cafe

8.4
2518 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA
Bar · Southside Flats · 78 tips and reviews

Paula J.Paula Jenkins: Peanut butter on a burger ...hello!!

ScottScott: I love all of the food at OTB, but the peanut butter and bacon burger is AWFUL! Too much peanut butter! I couldn't eat the burger. It should come with milk, not fries!

MT W.MT Welsch: The peanut butter burger left me feeling full for days. Great food! Great booze! Love it!

The Pittsburgh Popcorn Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

3. The Pittsburgh Popcorn Company

7.6
209 21st St (at Spring Way), Pittsburgh, PA
Snack Place · Strip District · 22 tips and reviews

Arjun M.Arjun Mishra: I suggest anything with chocolate or peanut butter. Or both together. Delicious.

MattMatt: My dad is hooked on all the flavors. I really like the peanut butter chocolate. We have ordered online too and it is just as good as in the store.

Mike W.Mike Warman: Such a fun atmosphere! My 88 year old grandpa made sure we stopped twice to get peanut butter chocolate popcorn.

Jitters Cafe Shadyside is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

4. Jitters Cafe Shadyside

8.4
5541 Walnut St (at Ivy St), Pittsburgh, PA
Coffee Shop · Shadyside · 17 tips and reviews

Tyler D.Tyler Doss: Mmm the peanut butter cookie is really soft and delightful (:

KristinaKristina: The coffee is amazing and the peanut butter cookie is the best I've EVER had.

DanDan: Jitters has the least expensive, best quality (la prima) coffee in Pittsburgh. It also has the most social activity in any coffee shop I’ve been to in pgh. ☕️🍦🍪🍌 Disclaimer: I know the owner.

China Buffet King is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

5. China Buffet King

7.3
2249 Noblestown Rd (Poplar St.), Pittsburgh, PA
Asian Restaurant · Westwood · 15 tips and reviews

Angela M.Angela Marker: Awesome peanut butter chicken and coconut shrimp. HEAVEN!!!

tikatika: Peanut butter chicken is awesome!

Jodi U.Jodi Uhron: The peanut butter chicken is great!

The Milk Shake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

6. The Milk Shake Factory

8.8
314 5th Ave (at Wood St), Pittsburgh, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Fifth and Forbes Corridor · 14 tips and reviews

Steve M.Steve Miller: Chocolate covered peanut butter crackers were my favorite and a bit different in a good way.

Mohnad A.Mohnad Abdullah: Peanut butter

Carrie D.Carrie Donovan: Best vegan milkshakes in the history of the world.

Klavon's Ice Cream Parlor is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

7. Klavon's Ice Cream Parlor

8.8
2801 Penn Ave (28th Street), Pittsburgh, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Strip District · 31 tips and reviews

Kari S.Kari Scalercio: They will make it how you want, we shared a turtle split with butter pecan ice cream and peanut butter sauce added... Yum!

MacGirlieMacGirlie: Best little old school ice cream shop! Delicious sundaes, malts & milkshakes with an old drugstore vibe.

Chloe F.Chloe Fan: Try the large pecan ball. So good!

Bluebird Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

8. Bluebird Kitchen

8.4
221 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA
Sandwich Spot · Fifth and Forbes Corridor · 36 tips and reviews

Heather M.Heather M: Peanut butter cookie sandwich is delicious!

Partha R.Partha R: Best Latte & Cappuccino in Pittsburgh!

Joshua C.Joshua Ceaser: Everything they make is gold. If it sounds weird it's going to be great. This an amazing eatery one of, if not, my favorite lunch spots.

Osteria is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

9. Osteria

7.9
2350 Railroad St (24th), Pittsburgh, PA
Italian Restaurant · Strip District · 9 tips and reviews

val s.val schomer: Gnocchi for lunch and the massive peanut butter cup for dessert was a great choice!

Shahriar B.Shahriar Broumand: The food is fantastic and high quality, for a very reasonable price. Italian fare, some of the best in Pittsburgh.

Food C.Food Court: The food here is amazing! You would be happy with anything you order! I highly suggests the pasta and pizza here. The salads are very good as well.

Eddie Merlot's is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

10. Eddie Merlot's

8.5
444 Liberty Ave Ste 100, Pittsburgh, PA
Steakhouse · Fifth and Forbes Corridor · 14 tips and reviews

Dennis B.Dennis Bailey: Try the peanut butter cup dessert!

Stephan B.Stephan Butler: Fillet is always delicious. I recently tried the prime rib meatloaf and mashed potatoes. Very healthy portions, tender and flavorful as well. Cocktails are always great also 🍹👌🏾

RitaJRitaJ: Mother’s Day brunch: excellent! Mimosa. King crab legs & shrimp. Fresh fruit chunks. Omelette station. Filet mignon & Lamb chops: perfection. Steamed carrots, cauliflower, 5 cheese macaroni. Desserts!

Page Dairy Mart is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

11. Page Dairy Mart

9.3
4112 Carson St (at Becks Run Rd), Pittsburgh, PA
Ice Cream Parlor · Southside Flats · 56 tips and reviews

Arlene M.Arlene Murphy: Go for the Yinzburg or Nancy's B's chocolate peanut butter chip Sundae

Lauren P.Lauren Phillips: The top ice cream shop in the city! There's no competition.

Joseph A.Joseph Antantis: The best! Just remember to bring cash!

Two Louie's Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

12. Two Louie's Market

7.7
1233 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA
American Restaurant · Strip District · 8 tips and reviews

Jensen L.Jensen Lugo: Try their Peanut Butter and Grape Jelly Sandwich!! It's delicious!!

Alexandra O.Alexandra Oliver: Large pre-packed vegetarian tortellini salads don't skimp on the greens! For $7.25, it's a great and healthy deal.

Josh E.Josh Eadie: Friday's meatball special is a great value.

DeLuca's Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

13. DeLuca's Diner

8.3
2015 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA
Diner · Strip District · 89 tips and reviews

John A.John Adams: Best breakfeast ever no lie peanut butter chocolate chip pancakes the best

Adam G.Adam Gancarczyk: Peanut Butter Pancakes

Arjun M.Arjun Mishra: My favorite place in Pittsburgh. It is that rare place that can preserve that mythical idyll ambiance of the 1950s in the modern era. Reasonably priced for incredible food - dessert for breakfast!

Brighton Hot Dog Shoppe is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

14. Brighton Hot Dog Shoppe

8.3
2401 Noblestown Rd, Pittsburgh, PA
Hot Dog Joint · 17 tips and reviews

Ray S.Ray Sager: Never play with matches around gas jets...just kidding. The peanut butter milkshake is awesome.

Bunny L.Bunny Lynn: Order your dogs with no bun, and they give you a bowl of hot dog soup!

Anthony F.Anthony Failla: Burgers are fresh never frozen and really tasty

The Pretzel Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Pittsburgh.

15. The Pretzel Shop

8.3
2316 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA
Snack Place · Southside Flats · 22 tips and reviews

Erin K.Erin Kelly: Best cheap lunch! Try a peanut butter chocolate chip cookie for dessert.

John S.John Sanders: Really good soft pretzels. Even better dipped in cheese!

IheartPGHIheartPGH: best place for lunch for $ - pretzel shop on Carson