Christine DaCruz: This food truck is legit: Mickey Scars : fresh Italian bread, roasted eggplant, breaded chicken cutlet, fresh moz, arugula, hot peppers, balsamic dressing - also available as a vegetarian option
Rich Gallagher: One of the best Societies I've embraced - this food truck has some of the best sandwiches in NYC.
Serious Eats: An Italian deli on wheels. Excellent eat and cheese from Di Palo's are sliced to order, the bread is fresh, and the accents are real. Great for an Italian hero.
3. Trattoria Dell' Arte
8.1
900 7th Ave (at 57th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 157 tips and reviews
Julio Arias: Trophie with pesto + prosciutto and arugula pizza + Tartuffe = A++++!
Benjamin Adler: For a simple Chicken Cutlet, the Milenese is delicious and Superhuge, served with fennel & arugula salad. Also, get anything from their Vegetable bar. Cannoli and Tiramisu were also beyind amazing!
H.L.: Go all out with the amazing antipasto bar to start, veal chop parm for entree and canolli + tartuffo for dessert. Great for sharing. Get a booth in the back!
4. Schnipper's
7.7
620 8th Ave (at W 41st St), New York, NY
Comfort Food Restaurant · Theater District · 313 tips and reviews
Cheapeats Inc: 50's style burger joint but with a twist. It's healthy & organic. Sshhhh....don't tell the kids. I recommend the Grilled chick sandwich w/brie, arugula on country wheat bread. Delish!!!!
Stephanie M.: Try the hand carved turkey and arugula sandwich. Yum!
Sandra R: Schnipper's Classic Burger Our special cheese blend, carmelized onions, bacon, arugula, Schnipper sauce is Out of this world! OMG
5. Osteria al Doge
7.6
142 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 55 tips and reviews
Samantha Henderson: Tagliatelle with shrimp, arugula, and cherry tomatoes—proof that a delicious dish doesn't need very many ingredients.
Michael Vierra: Perfectly executed Italian... Absolutely Delicious! The chocolate mousse served in a dark chocolate shell? To die for! Also, if you're attending a show at the Sondenheim theatre it's a 2 min walk!
bernie davis: Great spot in midtown for authentic Italian. Great decor. Nice staff.
6. Le Pain Quotidien
7.2
250 W 55th St (at 8th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Theater District · 15 tips and reviews
Emily Lustig: The seasonal butternut squash, arugula and goat cheese frittata is a must! The Belgian waffle with berries is a great choice too.
Sally Gibson: My 12 & 13 year olds loved the mini pancakes with fruit. And the lemonade, particularly the raspberry and the mint ones. I had the bakers choice with smoked salmon. Lovely and cappuccino was fab!
Mads Mikkelsen: Atmosphere
7. 54 Below
9.2
254 W 54th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Performing Arts Venue · Theater District · 45 tips and reviews
Tracy Krupitzer: The cocktails are amazing. And get the fries. Just... Just get the fries.
Concert Ticket Agency: A must for all Broadway fans! From Ben Vereen to Patti LuPone. Food/drink minimum, but the small plates are delicious. Not a bad seat in the house, staff is very accommodating and performance-friendly
Andrea Mathias: The perfect place for a first date, catch up with friends, or just to slip away from reality for a while. Also, I will do bad things to get my hands on some of their truffle Mac & Cheese.
8. Paul's On Times Square
7.9
136 W 42nd St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 9 tips and reviews
Dri Bacci: Great place with a helpful and kind staff! Penne vodka al salmone is very good! We had pizza and bruschettas for entries, tartufo and chocolate mousse cake for dessert. Everything were great!
Dino Redzic: Enjoy a cocktail on us with the purchase of your entrée when you mention FOURSQUARE! Simply show to your server to redeem!
Marcos Armenta: Very good food, service and atmosphere. Must see in Time Square.
11. The Little Beet
7.3
135 W 50th St (between 6th Ave and 7th Ave), New York, NY
Gluten-Free Restaurant · Theater District · 74 tips and reviews
refinery29: Fresh salads, like the namesake beet, goat cheese, and arugula one, as well as an array of hot and cold sides, like roasted butternut squash with apples and Parmesan, are on rotation. Read more.
PureWow: Create your own plate with chicken, salmon, steak, tofu or a veggie patty, then load up on seasonal, rotating sides and salads like charred broccoli, grilled sweet potatoes & roasted butternut squash. Read more.
Brittany Barbos Whitmer: Salmon and the hot sauce are really good. Overpriced for what you get. Go to DigInn
14. Blue Fin
7.5
1567 Broadway (at W 47th St.), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Theater District · 161 tips and reviews
Zeke Franco: Try the Hamachi Maki - Watermelon, arugula, jalapeño and hamachi. Amazing combination.
Adriana Llames: Try the lobster bisque, yellowtail shiso roll and valrhona chocolate pot the creme.
Food Lover: Try The Sorbet Trio, Georgia Peach, and Pineapple Lime Sorbet for dessert. Refreshing tart In flavor!