Brooklyn Diner is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

1. Brooklyn Diner

6.8
155 W 43rd St (at Broadway), New York, NY
Diner · Theater District · 111 tips and reviews

Dan L.Dan Luner: Chicken Pot Pie is fantastic. Overall, a little expensive for a diner, but worth it.

Ömer G.Ömer G.: Very tasty Chicken Pot Pie, stromgly recommended...

Jessica A.Jessica Angeles: Fanciest diner I've ever been to. You MUST try the Chicken Pot Pie here before you die. Best I've ever known.

Brooklyn Diner is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

2. Brooklyn Diner

6.8
212 W 57th St (Broadway), New York, NY
Diner · Theater District · 196 tips and reviews

MoRizaMoRiza: Try the Large Chicken Pot Pie

MoRizaMoRiza: Try the Chicken Pot Pie - Finely sculpted, The largest pot pie I have ever face to face with.

Gilson G.Gilson Grosscop de Carvalho: Chicken pot pie is a soup!!!!

O'Lunney's is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

3. O'Lunney's

145 W 45th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Pub · Theater District · 134 tips and reviews

Brian S.Brian Sit: The chicken pot pie is great! And it's better than the beef brisket.

Cathy B.Cathy Batles: The chicken pot pie is amazing! My husband had the Reuben and was very happy!

Ed F.Ed Figarsky: Shared the sliders and chicken pot pie. Oh yeah, and the wings! Nice place to wind down, drink up and get fed.

Emmett O'Lunney's Irish Pub is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

4. Emmett O'Lunney's Irish Pub

6.5
210 W 50th St (at Broadway), New York, NY
Irish Pub · Theater District · 68 tips and reviews

Adrienne C.Adrienne Cooper: Bartender, Ty, was very friendly when I was there. Decent pub for the area. Like the Irish coffee drinks and the chicken pot pie is pretty good.

Carol N.Carol Nolan: Chicken pot pie and crab cakes! Delicious!

John G.John Greer: We stopped in after a show (Jersey Boys was GREAT!) and had a Guinness and a burger, just in time to catch the 4th quarter of the Giants game! Very nice place. We'll be back!

Ellen's Stardust Diner is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

5. Ellen's Stardust Diner

8.0
1650 Broadway (at W 51st St), New York, NY
Diner · Theater District · 449 tips and reviews

EllensStardust D.EllensStardust Diner: Warm up with a hot and delicious Chicken Pot Pie served in a cast iron crock. Chunks of chicken with carrots, celery, peas and mushrooms in a rich (oh so tasty Read more.

Joy T.Joy Tenenberg: The food is hit or miss here but the entertainment is A++. Great restaurant for any theater lover. The Chicken Pot Pie is the best thing I've tried on the menu so far.

Marie A.Marie Antz: Best place to share a good moment with friends who love music and the 50's... It's a dinner with a singing waitstaff....incredible... ;) definitely a place to go!

The Playwright Tavern is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

6. The Playwright Tavern

6.4
202 W 49th St (btwn 7th Ave & Broadway), New York, NY
Pub · Theater District · 62 tips and reviews

Doug M.Doug MacMillan: Burger, fish n chips, shep pie, chicken pot pie, or sampler. Say hi to Jimmy on you're way in

Karadad S.Karadad Somerville: The Oscar Wilde burger is incredible. Hand pattied burger, portobello mushroom, cheese, huge

JanelleJanelle: "the most important things to do in the world are to get something to eat, something to drink, and somebody to love you." - Brendan francis behan

Playwright Celtic Pub is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

7. Playwright Celtic Pub

7.0
732 8th Ave (btwn 45th St & 46th St), New York, NY
Pub · Theater District · 82 tips and reviews

Justin H.Justin Hileman: Get a chicken pot pie. The crust is amazing, and the rest of it is quite delicious as well :)

Jade L.Jade Longstaff: Great nachos. Not the usual mound of overloaded chips drenched in toppings rather a reasonable portion with a lovely avacado crema topping. Delicious snack or light meal.

IsaiahIsaiah: Do not take the free shots. U will throw up :-)

Broadway Lounge & Terrace is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

8. Broadway Lounge & Terrace

7.3
1535 Broadway, 8th Floor of the New York Marriott Marquis (8th Fl), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Theater District · 23 tips and reviews

Simran D.Simran Dass: Cool vibes & good food. Really enjoyed the roasted red peppers in the Caesar salad, and the chocolate cake was good too

Zena W.Zena Weist: Great floor to ceiling window view of Times Square.

Evan L.Evan Lopez: You want to escape Time Square shenanigans?! Then come up to the 8th floor of the Marriott Marquis and enjoy beautifully crafted libations, a curated cuisine and outdoor terrace overlooking it all!

Junior's Restaurant & Bakery is one of The 9 Best Places for Chicken Pot Pie in the Theater District, New York.

9. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery

8.4
1515 Broadway (at W 45th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 725 tips and reviews

Chris C.Chris Chavez: I had the chicken pot pie, best ever, flavorful, and filling. Any cheesecake here is awesome!

Kim K.Kim Kingsbury: Try the "something different". Beef brisket on two potato pancakes with au jus and apple sauce ... Yummy! :)

BravoBravo: There is no substitute anywhere in the world for Junior's cheesecake. -Emily Sprissler, Top Chef