Hideaway Pizza is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

1. Hideaway Pizza

8.8
5966 S Yale Ave (61st Yale Kingspointe Center), Tulsa, OK
Pizzeria · 4 tips and reviews

ChristianChristian: The Garlic Cheese Bread is a great start to a tasty dinner.

Melodie K.Melodie Kilgore: The fried mushrooms are to die for!

Rodger L.Rodger LeFlore: Food was good but they were way understaffed. I think they only had 2 servers for the entire place.

Hideaway Pizza is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

2. Hideaway Pizza

9.0
7549 S Olympia Ave W, Tulsa, OK
Pizzeria · 20 tips and reviews

Stephanie D.Stephanie D: Great service for small groups... our server easily accommodated 6 adults + 4 kids. To amuse and give variety for pizza lovers, try the Hideaway Special -- a different kind of topping on every slice!

Melanie L.Melanie Lahti: Love the mamma mia meatball! The "mini meatballs" are actually enormous. CASH is the best!! "One planet, one pizza."

Cash B.Cash Bridges: Check out our updated beer and wine list! Lots of new selections for the summer.

Mario's NY Style Pizzeria is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

3. Mario's NY Style Pizzeria

8.3
3350 E 51st St, Tulsa, OK
Pizzeria · 15 tips and reviews

April D.April Dunnam: Mushroom and tomato pizza, the perfect combination

Fred F.Fred Fleischner: Simply the best in the Tulsa. Want better? Have to go to New York.

Chris S.Chris Stevens: Best pizza in Tulsa. It's the real deal

Cicis is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

4. Cicis

7.3
3126 S Garnett Rd Ste B, Tulsa, OK
Pizzeria · 4 tips and reviews

Christle S.Christle Speegle: Must try the spinach Alfredo

Matthew V.Matthew Vandruff: The manager is a brownie hoarder!!!!!!

Missy P.Missy Proctor: Love when a family of 5 can eat for under $24 especially all u can eat!

Chimera Cafe is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

5. Chimera Cafe

8.6
212 N Main St (btwn Brady and Cameron), Tulsa, OK
Café · 44 tips and reviews

MichaelMichael: I had the Bluebird sandwich on sourdough... Spectacular!

Cabrone B.Cabrone Brewer: Breakfast Tacos. All of them. Do it.

Arvell C.Arvell Craig: Try a Cortado. The perfect coffee.

Subway is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

6. Subway

3109 S Harvard Ave Unit D, Tulsa, OK
Sandwich Spot · No tips or reviews
Marley's Chicago Style Pizzeria is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Peppers in Tulsa.

7. Marley's Chicago Style Pizzeria

6104 E 71st St, Tulsa, OK
Pizzeria · 19 tips and reviews

Rich L.Rich Lohman: One of the best sit-down casual pizza joints in T-town.

Mary Kate H.Mary Kate Harkreader: The food is always great. But we went on a Sunday morning, and I'm pretty sure our waitress was still drunk. Must've been a hard night.

Danielle L.Danielle Lisle: If you can smell the pizza before you walk in the door you know it's got to be good.