2. Carmine's Pizzeria
8.4
358 Graham Ave (btwn Conselyea St & Metropolitan Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 85 tips and reviews
Sean Ludwig: High quality pizza slices all around. Philly cheese steak and cheese tortellini slices are two of the best.
Vivian Ramirez: Absolutely amazing pizza that has been around forever. Feels like family. Dozens of visits sometimes more than once a day- never tire of their food.
Bjorn L.: Very solid "local" pizza place. Nothing newfangled, just very good pizza, particularly IMO their white slice (try it with pepperoni) and their eggplant parm slice.
Peter Kelly: Super trashy and sketchy inside but hell they have buffalo chicken pizza slices.
Monee Perry: Great pizza, cheese is to die for and all the topping pizzas are good as well. Fav is the chicken ceasar slice!
Serious Eats: It's big, it's greasy, it's a little too cheesy and the sauce is a little too sweet, but the crust is always crisp and tender, and it always seems to hit the spot after a night out in Williamsburg. Read more.
4. Mugs Ale House
125 Bedford Ave (btwn N 10th & N 11th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pub · Williamsburg · 83 tips and reviews
Tracy Causey Jeffery: Some of the best craft beer in the neighborhood - love their weekend festivals
Brew York: Where we first discovered craft beer in New York City. Reasonably-priced, well-curated craft beer and tasty food in an unpretentious atmosphere.
James Allen: Unlike all the places that say they have a cask ale but "it's off right now" this place actually has one!
6. Tony's Pizza & Pasta
6.6
355 Graham Ave (btwn Metropolitan and Conselyea), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 32 tips and reviews
Kevin Lee: Great for a plain slice, garlic knots, soups, meatball sandwich, pasta, etc!!!
Chantele Bond: This is the best pizza, hands down, in the city. If you love a crisp thin crust, real cheese and a great sauce, you hit the jackpot here. Although it's usually busy, I am always treated great.
Serious Eats: While the round New York–style pizza at Tony's on Graham Avenue is very good, the Sicilian is even better.
7. The Big Whiskey
6.4
524 Grand St (Union), Brooklyn, NY
Sports Bar · East Williamsburg · 21 tips and reviews
Samantha Vanderhoof: Grilled cheese and great whiskey/bourbon selection. The crowd is a bit broey, but overall good vibes
Evan Allen: Great drink selection, good service, and lots of space. Notice the burgundy walls? Well, it's not coincidental that this place is a closeted Washington Redskins bar.
Leah Malone: My vote for best sports bar in Williamsburg. Buckets of wings and pitchers of beer, enough said.