Carmines Pie House
Pizzeria, Italian Restaurant, and Bar$$$$
Riverside, Jacksonville
The pizza at Carmines Pie House is a can't miss
"The Zucchini fries are awesome and come out fast."(3 Tips)
"Awesome Deep Fried Calzones."(6 Tips)
"And the lobster Mac and cheese is off the hook."(3 Tips)
"The best Stromboli, sandwiches, and Pizzas in the area"(24 Tips)
79 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- calzones
- casual
- zucchini fries
- good for groups
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Anya Usher TollerJune 15, 2012Everything I have had on the menu so far is Fantastic. The staff is always friendly and accomodating. You truly will feel like welcomed guest.
Matt WollitzSeptember 9, 2016The Barbossa and the snob are both delicious. Small, yet very decent, selection of local craft beer.
Yuval ZukermanApril 16, 2019Friendly service and cool interior but the pizza, if you've been to NYC or Boston, is just pretty good. Jacksonville clearly is not a pizza Mecca.
Kevin BorchersNovember 18, 2013Blink and you might miss it, and you don't want to do that! This hole-in-the-wall has fabulous calamari that makes other restaurants' offerings just squid by comparison!- Awesome Deep Fried Calzones. The meatball appetizer rivals any commercially prepared meatball! Plus Pepsi.
Craig ErskineMay 31, 2013Real Deal Chicago Style Pies. Not the case in most places who say they have Chi-Town pies. A++++. Never had a bad anything here and their menu is extensive
Easily one of the best pizzas in town, but their strombolis are also ridiculously good. Especially the "Naturalized Citizen".
Lauren A.August 16, 2014Great lunch special (2 slices & drink for $5) and the slices are huge. Variety of toppings are not used sparingly.
Sarah LopezJuly 13, 2014Pineapple Express with extra coconut...amazing! Also those bacon sweet potato fries are killer. And huge!!!- The best Stromboli, sandwiches, and Pizzas in the area
I love everything I've tried here - stromboli, pizza. Ziti, chilly parm
What's not to love? Great food, unbeatable staff, and desserts...OMG, the desserts! @carminespie- Best NYC style pizza in Jax. And the lobster Mac and cheese is off the hook.
Wonderful place . Love the owner. He always so nice to me and guests. The food is very good.
- J. XMMarch 22, 2013Hit or miss here, worse on busy nights. Parties of 2 or 4 are preferred. Parties of 3 will have their third person standing... deduction of cool points
Kevin YoungAugust 28, 2018Get uncle al’s Alfredo if you’re looking for an Alfredo that is made correctly.
Every thing is great here.esp the zucchini fries yum yum
Jacob ReichleApril 2, 2017The pizza was awesome! Never tasted better crust!!!! I recommend the margherita pizza!
C HJanuary 11, 2013Pineapple Express ("nice" version) was delish but could have had more ham for my taste. Coconut was a nice addition.
Ask for Stephanie, shes the best! Also, give the BLT pizza a try, its suprisingly good! (lots o' bacon)
Chicago style is the way to go. The Jersey shore is delicious, but you might want to split it with someone.
They charge $5 for craft beer, despite the fact it is brewed less than 500 yards away. F@$k their beer pricing. Just get water and go to a near by bar.
I cannot stay away. Everything is delicious. And they're vegan friendly :)
You take any of the food and put it in your mouth. It's all good.
The pesto change-o bread is pretty awesome. Must try!!
Try the Slice Of Cheese & Slice Of Meatball And Onion
if you stare at your table, the horrific murals are almost invisible
191 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Authentic Deep Dish and Italian Thin Pizza, and Classic Italian Dishes plus Micro Brews
Open until 10:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:30 PM
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
(904) 387-1400
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Carmines Pie House
- 7.3
"A whiskey bar with a couple decent draft selections most drinks are served in mason jars, the lids can be tossed for a chance to win a shot. If you get tired you can always relax in the bathtub."
David Fake - 7.3
"Great music, inexpensive drinks, friendly staff, non-smoking interior, no weapons allowed, and a huge outdoor patio with covered seating and fans."
Russ Hatcher - 7.6
"Yummy grilled wings...nice and big!"
Beth Baxter
Appears on 67 lists
Created by Julia Valleau
20 items • 2 followersCreated by Sara Barley
73 items • 6 followers
Created by Casey Dryden
135 items • 12 followers